Go Harry Potter And Twilight! discussion
The Books
>
I cried when..
message 51:
by
Swati , The Awesomest Moderator!
(new)
May 19, 2009 11:21AM
Mod
reply
|
flag
Mod
In Breaking Dawn, I cried when Jacob was thinking about how it was wrong to kill Carlisle Cullen, because he was good. I also cried a bit for Leah, and when Rosalie told her story in Eclipse.I cried a LOT in Harry Potter. One really big one is in DH, when Voldemort tells Hogwarts to give up Harry, and Pansy Parkinson and all the Slytherins scream at eachother to grab Harry because he's right there, and ALL the other students just draw their wands, turn away from Harry, and point them at the Slytherins, just daring them to try. I thought that was incredible. I basically cried a bit for every good person's death in HP. And at Harry's parents' graves, and Snape's memories, and when Harry walked to his death in the forest...Yeah, I'm very emotional when I read.
Yeh so am I. I never cry in real life so I make up for it in books and movies haha.Question - does 'idk' mean I don't know??
Mod
Oh, I found this funny thing once that said:"Twilight made me cry because I could feel part of my brain dying."
Swati wrote: "I creid a LOT during the whole series:1. When Sirius died
2. When Dumbledore died
3.When Dobby died
4. When Fred died, I didn't CRY, there were just tears in my eyes.
5. When Mad-Eye died.
I creid all those times too! espesially when fred died!
I thi..."
PPl that died!!!
-Fred
-Dobby
-Hedwig
-Cedric
SAD SAD SAD!
When Dobby died I was like the poor thing, He was soooo sweet!Bellatrix is a meanie BUTT!
-Fred
-Dobby
-Hedwig
-Cedric
SAD SAD SAD!
When Dobby died I was like the poor thing, He was soooo sweet!Bellatrix is a meanie BUTT!
Wafa wrote: "PPl that died!!!-Fred
-Dobby
-Hedwig
-Cedric
SAD SAD SAD!
When Dobby died I was like the poor thing, He was soooo sweet!Bellatrix is a meanie BUTT!"
I agree!Doby never did anything wrong!He always did everything he could to help harry,even though it ended up killing him.
me too! I was also really sad when fred died because it's always "fred and george", they're always together.now it's just george, and i think that's sad.
In Twilight, I cried when....
Bella got run over by a van. [Book 1:]
Edward left bella abandoned in the forest. [Book 2:]
Harry Potter isn't all that sad.
Bella got run over by a van. [Book 1:]
Edward left bella abandoned in the forest. [Book 2:]
Harry Potter isn't all that sad.
harry potter is WAY sadder then twlight! harry potter is way deeper and has more to be sad about! the twlight books are stupid and fake and supper urealistic!
ooh I can't remember which book it was but I was reading some book when I was supposed to be doing schoolwork and I started crying, lol... luckily my parents didn't walk in then. oh yeah I remember now it was the Scarlet Pimpernel, which I was reading for school but I was supposed to be doing other stuff at the moment.
Whitney wrote: "harry potter is WAY sadder then twlight! harry potter is way deeper and has more to be sad about! the twlight books are stupid and fake and supper urealistic!"
good point
good point
The twilight books were about vampires resisting the urge to be "evil".
and that's a good idea, and the books are good the first time, but the next couple of times through they seem unrealistic and boring.
then just read them once! lol, I read them twice, once out of order, then I watched the movie, then I wanted to read them again, and I ended up reading them out of order again...
i cried when edward left bella in the woods just because it was really sad.
Vanessa wrote: "i cried when edward left bella in the woods just because it was really sad."Yeah it was, but it was also supper pathetic!!She needs him so much, and that's not what it's like in real life! The books are so stupid!
Whitney wrote: "Vanessa wrote: "i cried when edward left bella in the woods just because it was really sad."Yeah it was, but it was also supper pathetic!!She needs him so much, and that's not what it's like in..."
yeah i know
It's not pathetic! You guys are for hating twilight!
Yeah, I mean there are books I really don't like, but I don't hate them. You need to have an open mind and see things from different points of view.
Well, it is true that it is NOT healthy if Bella can't function without Edward there to hold her hand and take care of her. She's almost lost herself as an individual because her whole life revolves around Edward. And hi Whitney! It's me!
You guys are pathetic for crying in HP. Twilight is more like it.
Why on Earth would you cry in Twilight? So Edward leaves Bella. Big deal. We all know he comes back, because both of them are pathetic, lovesick, and selfish. Oh no, Alice and Jasper have LEFT the Cullens because they don't want their partner to be hurt! Who cares? We all know they are just pretending, so they can help. Tell me, what is the saddest part in Twilight? Do people actually DIE in Twilight? Of course not, because it's a perfect fairy-tale happy ending. Harry Potter is MUCH more realistic. He loses almost everyone. Harry walks to his own death to save the entire world, even if it means leaving behind everyone he loves. Could Bella ever leave Edward alone, even for the good of millions of people? If you aren't at least SADDENED by Harry Potter, you are honestly heartless. No exaggeration.
Alyssa wrote: "Why on Earth would you cry in Twilight? So Edward leaves Bella. Big deal. We all know he comes back, because both of them are pathetic, lovesick, and selfish. Oh no, Alice and Jasper have LEFT the ..."first of all what ever ,second oh all wtf dude and third of all im done
Sorry, I didn't mean to be rude, I just can't think of any sad parts in Twilight really. Just when Jacob, in BD, chooses leave his pack to help the Cullens. That part was sad. And when they all thought they were going to die, and Bella wanted to save Nessie. That was really sad. But other than that...I think that Harry Potter has more parts to cry about. Like when Fred dies :(
Alyssa wrote: "Sorry, I didn't mean to be rude, I just can't think of any sad parts in Twilight really. Just when Jacob, in BD, chooses leave his pack to help the Cullens. That part was sad. And when they all tho..."well i dont really care dude your such a hypocrite
ALL OF Y'ALL ARE PATHETIC! I'M THINKING ABOUT LEAVING THE GROUP.
How so? I'm sorry I upset you, I just wanted to state my opinion. I guess I was a little too opinionated. I just enjoy debating to much, I guess.
Yeah you better be sorry you upset me!
Sorry. When I get mad, I get M-A-D!
It's ok. Me too. I have a bit of a temper. I fight with my brothers all the time. [I have 3 - and no sisters ): ]
Katherine wrote: "ALL OF Y'ALL ARE PATHETIC! I'M THINKING ABOUT LEAVING THE GROUP."i dont care if you didnt know everyone gets upset then your the pathetic one.
Vanessa wrote: "Katherine wrote: "ALL OF Y'ALL ARE PATHETIC! I'M THINKING ABOUT LEAVING THE GROUP."
i dont care if you didnt know everyone gets upset then your the pathetic one."
Okay you just made it worse.
i dont care if you didnt know everyone gets upset then your the pathetic one."
Okay you just made it worse.
Katherine wrote: "Vanessa wrote: "Katherine wrote: "ALL OF Y'ALL ARE PATHETIC! I'M THINKING ABOUT LEAVING THE GROUP."i dont care if you didnt know everyone gets upset then your the pathetic one."
Okay you just ma..."
oh okay im sorry
Sigh I really should control my anger.
I just think that the "Twilight-Harry Potter" debate is just very...fueled and passionate (I think those are the words) and it makes people angry easily. Sometimes I need to remind myself that they are two series published seperately for enjoyment, not to be compared and debated, because they are so different.
I really should monitor my stress and anger though.
Mod
=D
All's cool now, though?
Katherine wrote: "I really should monitor my stress and anger though."well yes u should
Maybe we all need to cool it a bit (myself included) and go back to the topic.In Twilight, I cried for Leah, in that part where she was talking to Jacob.
In Harry Potter, I cried about Ariana.
