Camp Half-Blood discussion

546 views
Debates! > Percy or Jason?

Comments Showing 51-100 of 219 (219 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by [deleted user] (new)

I really have to reread MOA before HoH comes out. From what I remember, I felt like Jason's character deteriorated in MOA. He was kind of just another voice there instead of a distinct personality.


message 52: by Cathleen (new)

Cathleen Anderson | 6 comments I feel like, since we got to kind of see the Roman camp again, and know some of the characters better that I got a better understanding of Jason and his relationship with Reyna and his history. I really hope we get a little bit more of Jason in HOH.


message 53: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah, I hope we get a lot more of all the characters in HoH


Aηahι- Aηι:{P  (ani--justkeepbeingawesome--) | 760 comments Percy! Percy! Percy!


message 55: by Haley (new)

Haley (CHDHaley) | 12 comments Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Cathleen wrote: "I don't really understand the whole 'Percy vs Jason' debate thing! take Percy, make him slightly more of a rule follower and blonde and you''ve practically got Jason! People keep c..."

I agree with you


message 56: by [deleted user] (new)

Both


message 57: by Fergal (new)

Fergal | 6 comments Michele wrote: "Percy! He's our Seaweed Brain! We watched him go through the Underworld and back to stop a war between the gods. He fell in love with Annabeth (he even fell into Tarturus for her!). He stood by Tys..."

read my mind ;)


message 58: by Fergal (new)

Fergal | 6 comments BECKENDORF good with his hands smart enough to make camo armour and couragous enough to take one for the team him or leo hephastus all the way


message 59: by mels (new)

mels (padmeskywalkers) Percy!!!!!!!!!


message 60: by Fergal (new)

Fergal | 6 comments nuh uh


message 61: by Fergal (new)

Fergal | 6 comments BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF


message 62: by Fergal (new)

Fergal | 6 comments hehe


message 63: by CJ (new)

CJ | 7364 comments Fergal wrote: "BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF BECKENDORF"

I feel like it's bad that I actually can agree with that...


message 64: by [deleted user] (new)

Percy


message 65: by [deleted user] (new)

Percy


message 66: by Nia (new)

Nia (DaughterofTartarus) | 12 comments IF YOU PICK JASON THEIR IS SOMETHING WRONG WITH YOU! NO AFENCE!

TEAM PERCY


message 67: by [deleted user] (new)

Jason. Hands down.


message 68: by Kimiko, Inactive Original Moderator (new)

Kimiko (kawasumi-kimiko) | 5962 comments Mod
It is spelled Offense, Nia.


message 69: by Elmina (new)

Elmina | 10551 comments Now I agree with you 100% but Kimi is right.


message 70: by Coralyn (new)

Coralyn | 3 comments Persassy Jackson All the way!!!!

Jason is so normal

While Percy is all like "Is that blue?I like blue, my mom made blue cookies all the time , oh did u know my dad Is a water god , woot woot guess what day it is!!!! HUMP DAY , oh yeah Hera screw you. Did you know there's wifi in Tarturas? Oh hey Annabeth u wanna get married ? Cool!


message 71: by [deleted user] (new)

JASON! HE CAN FLY! XD


message 72: by [deleted user] (new)

I would have to say Percy because not only his personality but his weapon. it was a pen turned into a sword and it always appeared in his pocket but Jason had a coin he flipped and it never appears in his pocket if he loses it


message 73: by Annabeth (new)

Annabeth Chase | 46 comments Percy ULTIMATE DUH


message 74: by Elmina (new)

Elmina | 10551 comments What if you combined them?


message 75: by Rameela (Star) (new)

Rameela (Star) (starshynebrite) Percy.
His fatal flaw is better (as in if he died because he cared too much about others, It'd be better than Jason who's fatal flaw seems to be hubris so if he died, all he'd be known for is that he defeated Titans and all that stuff. But if Percy died, people would remember him not only for fighting, but because he did everything he could to save his mother and keep his family safe. He saved his own protector! He cared about his half brother even if people made fun of him. etc etc etc. )

I'm sure Jaosn's great, but Percy is definitely better at least in my opinion. Maybe it's cause Percy was there first :)


message 76: by [deleted user] (new)

Percy connects to people better i think


message 77: by Andy (new)

Andy  | 7 comments I vote for Percy. He's so cute and even though he's (according to some of you ) not the smartest kid in the pack he's got loads and loads of courage. I mean come on he went into the underworld to save Annabeth without giving a thought about his self.... That's gotta count as something. Jason's just Jason... He doesn't make me laugh like Percy does.


message 78: by [deleted user] (new)

Percy.


message 79: by Nanma (new)

Nanma | 17 comments I vote for Percy. He's so cute and even though he's not the smartest kid in the pack but he's got loads of courage and knows how to cheer someone up.


message 80: by mels (new)

mels (padmeskywalkers) Percy.?


Gameboy the mental Mario  (gameboythelegomaster) | 2122 comments Percy and Jason mixed=person get it per +son= person just kidding Percy or Jason?no Percy,no Jason,no percy,no Jason,no Percy ah forget it I'm going with person!


message 82: by Chase (new)

Chase Hudson | 38 comments TEAM LEO


message 83: by [deleted user] (last edited Nov 01, 2013 11:53AM) (new)

I like all of them besides Jason he is a little want to be leader. Grant it he got them to the doors of death but he couldn't have done that with out Frank to command the dead. And Frank couldn't have done it without Jason to promote him. They couldn't have done it without Hazel and Leo to trick whatever her name is. And Piper did her charm speak for a lot of different things. So they are a team whether we don't like one of them or not. I'm including Nico he may not be one of the seven but he is part of the team.


message 84: by izzy (new)

izzy (nighthawkss) PERCY


message 85: by Isabella (new)

Isabella | 1 comments PERCY


message 86: by [deleted user] (new)

LEO XD!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 87: by s (new)

s (cherrybelugas) | 1405 comments Percy! I just didn't connect with Jason...

I'm also on Team Leo!! XD


Sasha Ivashkov-Herondale-Jackson (aka Clarisse) (sasha101) | 1 comments what kinda comparison is this? Of course it is my beloved Percy.
Jason is so plain and boring.
Percy is wayyyy hotter.


message 89: by [deleted user] (new)

Cathleen wrote: "I agree. Jason did kind of seem like a replacement for Percy at first but I feel like he developed a better character in MOA"

He got way better in HoH ^^


message 90: by [deleted user] (new)

sheldon wrote: "I would have to say Percy because not only his personality but his weapon. it was a pen turned into a sword and it always appeared in his pocket but Jason had a coin he flipped and it never appears..."

I always was sort of wondering about that... what if the weapon wasn't giving to him, or it doesn't accept him as its user or something... 0_0
What if he stole it!?

JK


message 91: by Ruiz (new)

Ruiz (Ruiz311) | 788 comments Percy!'


Gameboy the mental Mario  (gameboythelegomaster) | 2122 comments I choose person.percy + Jason=person


message 93: by Ruiz (new)

Ruiz (Ruiz311) | 788 comments Haha,nice one :)


message 95: by Elmina (new)

Elmina | 10551 comments ^not an option. Cheater


message 96: by Ruiz (new)

Ruiz (Ruiz311) | 788 comments People mostly pick Percy


message 97: by Elmina (new)

Elmina | 10551 comments Yup!


message 98: by [deleted user] (new)

Elmina wrote: "^not an option. Cheater"

hmmm, lemme guess, someone said Leo? XD


Gameboy the mental Mario  (gameboythelegomaster) | 2122 comments Pick person!

Per + son =person<------ per-cy,ja-son


message 100: by Ilsa, I name me, destroyer of worlds! (new)

Ilsa (eruaistaniel) | 24791 comments Mod
I said Leo first. :P


back to top