The Perks Of Being A Book Addict discussion

741 views
Debates & Discussions > Harry Potter vs Twilight vs Hunger Games vs Divergent

Comments Showing 51-61 of 61 (61 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Tati (new)

Tati | 1 comments 1 harry potter
2 hunger games
3 divergent
4 twilight (haven't read it but I hear its not good)
SPOILERS
tbh harry potter cant even be compared its amazing. like a lot of people have said it will become a classic and we'll probably still be reading it in 50 years time, unlike the other series.JK Rowling creates a whole new world in harry potter - shops, schools, over 200 characters, government, places etc and while all of it is impossible it seems so real while you're reading it. none of the characters are shallow and there are so many elements to the story and twists, like why snape hates harry, tom riddles past etc... also, there are funny and lighthearted bits as well as action scenes and deep parts in harry potter, which divergent and hunger games fail to include and yeahh idk theres so much more I could say!
the hunger games are very good but not as good as hp. like I said, there are no funny bits, its basically sad the whole way through and the ending was pretty bad, katniss lead the rebellion so that the capitol couldn't manipulate her and she wouldn't be pressurised into marrying peeta, and then she married him anyway. some of the characters are very shallow, even at the end of the series I don't feel like I know katniss very well.
divergents ok but a bit of a copy of the hunger games. I think the story is too fast paced and the thing of it being set in the future and having factions which are fairly similar to districts like in thg.
I haven't read twilight but from what ive heard its bella lying there waiting for her sparkly vampire boyfriend to come and help. sorry that was pretty long!


message 52: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (clockworkhannah) | 4 comments 1. Harry Potter
2. The Hunger Games
3. Divergent
4. Twilight

Harry Potter and The Hunger Games are about even for me in terms of quality but The Hunger Games isn't a story I would want to live in while Harry Potter is. Divergent (the book) is excellent but the series slowly goes downhill for me. Then there's Twilight which I like but I will admit its awful.


message 53: by Evannah (new)

Evannah (suspiciousness99) Alright.
1. Harry Potter (the best books series ever, hands down, it is beautifully written with amazing characters and a great plot)
2. Divergent (it was well-written It had some good characters, though they all got killed, I think they may ha overdone the killing a bit, but it has a good plot)
3. Hunger Games (awesome idea, I liked the first two books but hated. Mockingjay, it was well-written but I didn't like most of the characters)
4. Twilight (Why are we even comparing it to the others??)


message 54: by Sha (new)

Sha | 324 comments Harry Potter > Hunger Games > Twilight > Divergent

...what? I enjoyed Twilight for the melodramatic teenage love story it was, and Divergent seemed very knock-offy to me.


message 55: by Blue (new)

Blue Muffin | 29 comments I am hufflepuffishly loyal gryffindorishly proud ravenclawishly confident and slytherinshly prejudiced to Harry Potter


message 56: by Zara (new)

Zara   | 75 comments i think all of them are really great and it's really hard to choose cuz I love them all.
I have heard a lot of people saying that Twilight is not a good story. I do respect everyone's opinion but I really like twilight.


message 57: by R (new)

R (rxwhxb) harry potter, closely followed by the hunger games, divergent in the middle (wasn't crazy about it) and even though I haven't read twilight, it sounds awful.


message 58: by Ananya (new)

Ananya I love both Harry Potter and hunger games but Harry Potter is slightly above hunger games.
I do not like Twilight(sorry but the storyline is cringe)
Haven't read any divergent books.


message 59: by Juhi (new)

Juhi (juhi-malani) | 22 comments 1. Harry Potter ( Hands down; no competition)
2. Twilight (While the original series was cringe-y, Midnight Sun was honestly surprising and kicked it up a couple spots for me.)
3. Divergent (Not detailed enough and the series goes downhill but Tris is a badass.)
4. Hunger Games (I hate love triangles, period.)


message 60: by May (last edited Sep 18, 2020 09:07AM) (new)

May | 37 comments 1. Twilight ( I liked the end but I thought I was trapped in a depressed girls head half the time)
2. Harry potter ( I only made it to the 5th book, but it was ok )
3. Divergent ( LOVED the ending but I thought the series just kept dropping until the ending)
4. Hunger Games


message 61: by Veronica (new)

Veronica F | 11 comments Twilight and then Hunger Games ... though depending on my mood those can flip flop. Followed by Harry Potter, only made it through a couple books and have not read any of Divergent yet.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top