twilight lovers! discussion
Breaking Dawn Movie
>
Should Breaking Dawn be turned into a movie?
message 1:
by
Sydney
(last edited Apr 17, 2009 02:28PM)
(new)
Apr 17, 2009 01:37PM
I think it would be really cool to see breaking dawn turned into a movie I would love to see edward and bella's wedding and we all know new moon and eclipse are going to be movies but breaking dawn is being optioned off becuase some think it will be hard to create renesmee which I agree how can u cast a girl that grows twice as fast and was born with teeth. Also this movie may be rated R but that's not a big deal for me but maybe for younger twilight fans so Also how would they make kristen look pregnant she would have to gain weight what do u think????
reply
|
flag
I would, personally, hate to see Breaking Dawn be made into a movie. Not just because I utterly despise the book, but also beacuse if it was to be made they were saying it would be in two parts and I can't see the cast they have right now up to being wedding doers or vampires, example Kristin.
I would hate it so much. I hate the book, and I would NOT want to see such... disturbing (the birth) things. But I know it's going to be a movie... (EEEWWW!)
I think that is the only book that I would have to skip the movie experience for. The ending was such a let down.
ya know, i think if breaking dawn was made into a movie than it would probably be rated alaong the line of...R!!!
They wouldn't. They'd lose so many views.
Like mostly everyone is under the age of 17. Not everyone but a vast majority of us are so, if hypothetically we were to want to watch it we wouldn't be able to.
I think it would be creepy if they made it into a movie. I mean, reading it, we all got the picture fried into our heads, I don't think seeing it would be any better.
I want to see some parts, lke the wedding and the volturi attack. but i some of the parts are........rated r
I think it should be a movie. The ending of the book bothered me a little bit (the volturi gave in way too easily for my liking), they could really make a great movie given the chance.
message 11:
by
Stephanie, Loves Vamps and Werewolves but Zombies scare me!!
(new)
Mod
Summit Entertainment has acquired the rights (optioned property) from Stephenie Meyer to film and distribute Breaking Dawn, the fourth novel in her series. The project has now been green lighted by the studio. Pre-production for Eclipse is already underway, and Breaking Dawn is in the early planning stages. Casting information will be posted here as soon as available. “Breaking Dawn” will start shooting in the spring of 2010, with a release scheduled for early 2011
message 14:
by
Stephanie, Loves Vamps and Werewolves but Zombies scare me!!
(new)
Mod
It will be way to gory! Although not as bad as eclipse. I do NOT want 2 c Victoria(Even though I hate her) lose her head
i know but in Twilight we saw James lose HIS head
i think if breaking dawn would be made into a movie i wouldnt want to see it, i mean i love the movie but it would be way to gory and gross on the big screen
if they made it PG-13 (so they dont lose viewers) it wouldnt b that gory... n for the rated R scenes they would just do wat other movies do.... IMPLY it... then other parts just not show anything... like shoulders up on those shots...
Jenna wrote: "if they made it PG-13 (so they dont lose viewers) it wouldnt b that gory... n for the rated R scenes they would just do wat other movies do.... IMPLY it... then other parts just not show anything....."I agree completely! I would love to see the book made into a movie, and the whole sex scene was not really described which only really leaves the birth, and they can do a collage thing like they did with Twilight or something if it really came to it, they don't need to go into detail. They know who the fan base is so they would work around it no doubt. Although personally i didn't find the birth scene "gross" anyway.
Ashley wrote: "Faith wrote: "Jenna wrote: "if they made it PG-13 (so they dont lose viewers) it wouldnt b that gory... n for the rated R scenes they would just do wat other movies do.... IMPLY it... then other pa..."
ikr
ikr
I WANT ALL THE MOVIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I personally believe that the fourth book was the best out of the whole bunch. I believe that the honeymoon part was very well done in the book and they can do the same as in the movie. Example would be when she is about to go into the water they simply cut the shot as she starts walking to the water in a robe and pan the screen off to the sunset or something. And with the birth part, I agree with with Faith. Yes there will be blood and suggestive parts. But if done correctly I believe the movie would be good rated as PG13. If they rate the movie any lower I believe there will be to many holes and that it would be to childish. Oh and some one mentioned the hardship of creating a Renesmee. I think that it would be very possible to create her using multiple young actresses that look very much alike but are slightly older than the next. Plus wonders can be made with the correct camera angle when they need to just show slight growths. And the teeth can be computer generated on the babies.
So overall, I believe it will be an AWESOME movie! And, that's the one I am looking the most forward to! :-)
LOL @Ashley: Only six times? I think I've watched 30 or so times in 3 weeks!! (I have a problem...) At least I can laugh at myself about it.
Jessica wrote: "I personally believe that the fourth book was the best out of the whole bunch. I believe that the honeymoon part was very well done in the book and they can do the same as in the movie. Example wou..."Couldn't agree more!
message 26:
by
Stephanie, Loves Vamps and Werewolves but Zombies scare me!!
(new)
Mod
it could turn out to be the scariest slasher movie ever if done badly LOLBut they're making too much money to allientate most of their audience by going "R" rated
TBH they cut so much out of Twilight lots of those things could be brushed over LOL
No, i personally think none of the books should have ever been made into a movie. I mean movies only ruin the beauty of a book by ripping into it and tearing it apart, taking out half of the story which usually ends up completely changing how you view characters or the whole point of the story. Like in the Twlight movie (which I watched once and will never watch it or any other twilight movie again)Edward completely failed at more than half of his most important lines. They were supposed to be meaningful and epic and they blew through them and the rest of the book like it was nothing. As a true fan of Twilight I don't think anymovie will ever come close to doing the books justice.
well they should take out the end of jacobz POV then take out some of the honneymoon.
alice cullen wrote: "well they should take out the end of jacobz POV then take out some of the honneymoon."
Please, the honeymoon was nothing compared to some pg-13 films in hollywood.
Please, the honeymoon was nothing compared to some pg-13 films in hollywood.
BookGeek wrote: "But again, some of Jake's POV has to be tweaked."
Jacobs POV? Of the honeymoon? He saw the honeymoon too?! I only read Bella's POV so far, and based on that I must say that I've seen more in PG-13's, and she's the one that was actually there.
Jacobs POV? Of the honeymoon? He saw the honeymoon too?! I only read Bella's POV so far, and based on that I must say that I've seen more in PG-13's, and she's the one that was actually there.
yes important...but also gory.
yes i think it should its just then not very much kids would be able to see it casue it gets a little inapropreit
Im not looking foward to the film of breaking dawn because I really like the book and the movie can ruin things. They cant show all of it if they dont want to lose half their audience, but they'll probably just show the honeymoon bit and end of Jakes POV a bit more subtly than in the book.
I dont get how they'll make the movie because some of the scenes might be like rated R.And if it was rated R then most of the ppl (teenagers) who read the books cant watch the movie so the'll lose as megan said like a 3rd of their viewers...iteresting.
They'll probably just imply somethings going on. Like Bella and Edward will kiss fully clothed, and they cut to the next day at breakfast, where they never actually say what happened. Same thing goes for other parts. They'll just cryptically talk about it, and cut away. You'll know whats going on without actually seeing it.
I want Breaking Dawn and all of it's gory little details. I'm 13 and I want it to be just like the book, they won't lose audience really, maybe it will attract more adult people. DOes it matter if it doesn't go super well, I mean it IS the last movie and all.
Sydney wrote: "I think it would be really cool to see breaking dawn turned into a movie I would love to see edward and bella's wedding and we all know new moon and eclipse are going to be movies but breaking dawn..."it wld.
I wouldn't mind them to make the film long to stay true to the book, you know how the Lord of the Rings movies were like three hours long? I sat through the whole thing, and I only kind of liked the films. I was only there for my mom, and I didn't mind the length. So I doubt Twilight fans wouldn't mind watching a lengthy Breaking Dawn. Breaking Dawn is like 700 pages so it's perfect.
Yeah, that was creepy. *shudders*
I think that it really isn't a question anymore if they're should/or should not put Breaking Dawn into a movie--they made SO much money off of Twilight, that they're obviously going to make all of the series into movies. I have mixed feelings about Breaking Dawn. Its a little more PG-13 than the other books, but if they don't make it into a movie, Twilight Fans across the globe will be screaming for more.
FMA ,FRUITS BASKET, and HEROES OTAKU!! wrote: "i fell down a ladder 2 day!"
Ouch, I have big feet so I always watch my step, even on even surfaces. Otherwise I bump into things, careful or injured. Which one would you choose?
Ouch, I have big feet so I always watch my step, even on even surfaces. Otherwise I bump into things, careful or injured. Which one would you choose?
I would love to see Breaking Dawn become a movie even though I haven't read it
It's almost twice the size of the other books.
