Shoujo Manga Book Club discussion

52 views
Challenges > Arguing Couples Challenge

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kristen (new)

Kristen | 1392 comments Read 15 volumes of manga that feature couples that argue and/or deny their feelings for each other. Examples: Maid Sama, Love Com and Inuyasha.

Tell us what you are reading for this challenge here!


message 2: by Aurora (new)

Aurora Majority of the series I read end up with arguing couples, lol!


message 3: by Jean (new)

Jean (otakumom) Aurora wrote: "Majority of the series I read end up with arguing couples, lol!"

I second that LOL ;)


message 4: by Jean (new)

Jean (otakumom) Here's what I've read so far

Volumes 4 - 12 of Nana. And I consider Nana and Ren to be the couple denying their feelings for each other or the couple in conflict.
Nana, Vol. 4 (Nana, #4) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 5 (Nana, #5) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 6 (Nana, #6) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 7 (Nana, #7) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 8 (Nana, #8) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 9 (Nana, #9) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 10 (Nana, #10) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 11 (Nana, #11) by Ai Yazawa Nana, Vol. 12 (Nana, #12) by Ai Yazawa


message 5: by Juvia (new)

Juvia (juvia_winter) | 195 comments Would Skip Beat count for this challenge?


message 6: by Jean (new)

Jean (otakumom) ♥Jamie♥ wrote: "Would Skip Beat count for this challenge?"

I would say so. Ren fights his attraction to Kyoko and Kyoko is deliberate obtuse about it even though she senses something.

Yea... definitely denying their attraction couple.


message 7: by Selena (last edited May 18, 2013 09:18AM) (new)

Selena Pigoni (sailorstar165) | 2027 comments Mod
I'll give it a shot, but I'm not sure how much of my manga will count. XD

1. Tramps Like Us, Volume 1 by Yayoi Ogawa 2. Maid Sama!, Volume 10 by Hiro Fujiwara 3. Kamisama Kiss, Vol. 10 by Julietta Suzuki 4. Alice in the Country of Clover Cheshire Cat Waltz, Vol. 4 by QuinRose 5. Kieli, Vol. 2 by Yukako Kabei 6. Cat Paradise 2 (Cat Paradise, #2) by Yuji Iwahara 7. A Bride's Story, Vol. 4 (A Bride's Story, #4) by Kaoru Mori 8. Kobato., Vol. 6 by CLAMP 9. Pandora Hearts, #14 by Jun Mochizuki 10. Shugo Chara!, Vol. 3 Can a Bad Guy Turn Good? (Shugo Chara!, #3) by Peach-Pit 11. Ouran High School Host Club, Vol. 7 (Ouran High School Host Club, #7) by Bisco Hatori 12. Fullmetal Alchemist, Vol. 04 (Fullmetal Alchemist, #4) by Hiromu Arakawa 13. Skip Beat!, Vol. 7  by Yoshiki Nakamura 14. Fruits Basket, Vol. 3 (Fruits Basket, #3) by Natsuki Takaya 15. Alice 19th, Vol. 6 Blindness (Alice 19th, #6) by Yuu Watase

(I'm counting "Tramps Like Us" because Sumire's obviously got something for Momo but doesn't realize it in general)
(Kansuke has a bit of a Tsundere approach to his crush on Sakura in Cat Paradise)


message 8: by Jean (new)

Jean (otakumom) 狼陛下の花嫁 1 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #1) by Mato Kauta 狼陛下の花嫁 2 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #2) by Mato Kauta 狼陛下の花嫁 3 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #3) by Mato Kauta 狼陛下の花嫁 4 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #4) by Mato Kauta 狼陛下の花嫁 5 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #5) by Mato Kauta 狼陛下の花嫁 6 (Ookami-Heika No Hanayome, #6) by Mato Kauta

I read these volumes that were sitting in my collection for awhile. My interest waned since it felt that the story was going in circles but it is really cute. Totally denial of feelings on the part of Yuurin. Haku is aware of his affections for her but doesn't aggressively pursue it. It's actually kind of a weird situation truthfully.


message 9: by A.C. (new)

A.C. Harrah | 434 comments So I just want to clarify something: Does a manga count if the couple gets together right away, but are constantly at odds with each other? Just to give an example, pretend Kagome and Inuyasha became a couple in the first volume of Inuyasha and continued to bicker about things such as letting others join their group/how best to handle certain situations. Would they still count for this challenge or would they be disqualified because they never denied their feelings?

Sorry if this sounds like a stupid question but out the examples that I've read it seems like denial is almost necessary to distinguish the aforementioned couples as "arguing couples" since almost every couple argues at some point.


message 10: by Kristen (new)

Kristen | 1392 comments That's totally fine. I'd say it counts.


message 11: by Juvia (last edited May 08, 2013 05:00AM) (new)

Juvia (juvia_winter) | 195 comments Here are my reads for this challenge:
1. Skip Beat!, Vol. 6  by Yoshiki Nakamura 2. Skip Beat!, Vol. 7  by Yoshiki Nakamura 3. Skip Beat!, Vol. 8  by Yoshiki Nakamura 4. Skip Beat!, Vol. 9  by Yoshiki Nakamura 5. Skip Beat!, Vol. 10  by Yoshiki Nakamura 6. Skip Beat!, Vol. 11  by Yoshiki Nakamura 7. Skip Beat!, Vol. 12 by Yoshiki Nakamura 8. Skip Beat!, Vol. 13 by Yoshiki Nakamura 9. Skip Beat!, Vol. 14 by Yoshiki Nakamura


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

My list:

1. Mixed Vegetables, Vol. 5 (Mixed Vegetables, #5) by Ayumi Komura 2. Rasetsu, Volume 1 by Chika Shiomi 3. Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, Vol. 3 - Disciple (Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, #3) by Yuu Watase 4. Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, Vol. 4 - Bandit (Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, #4) by Yuu Watase 5. Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, Vol. 5 - Rival (Fushigi Yûgi The Mysterious Play, #5) by Yuu Watase


message 13: by Kristen (last edited May 10, 2013 07:25PM) (new)

Kristen | 1392 comments 1. Oresama Teacher , Vol. 2 by Izumi Tsubaki 2. Oresama Teacher , Vol. 3 by Izumi Tsubaki 3. Oresama Teacher , Vol. 4 by Izumi Tsubaki 4. Library Wars Love & War, Vol. 9 by Kiiro Yumi 5. Until the Full Moon, Volume 1 by Sanami Matoh


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

I counted Fushigi Yugi since Yui likes Tamahome but Tamahome isn't interested. I'm considering unrequited love as part of this challenge, partly to open up the amount of manga everyone can read. So, it can be bickering couples, couples who deny their feelings, characters with feelings of unrequited love, or characters that are unsure of their feelings.


Iesha (In east shade house at...) (emberblue) | 378 comments Does this include Blood plus???


back to top