Percy Jackson Fan Club! discussion

194 views
Book Couples! > Thalia and Luke ((Sitting in a tree. K-I-S-S-I-N-G.....))

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
Put your comments here. :)


message 2: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments Search them up on youtube!


message 3: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Gross. Just gross. But I can actually see it.... Thankfully it never evolved from friendship!


message 4: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments ?


message 5: by T.J. (new)

T.J. | 58 comments Huh...I don't know...Weird, considering Luke is all evil and everything.


message 6: by T.J. (new)

T.J. | 58 comments *was evil.


message 7: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Greta wrote: "?"

I was talking about the Thalia/Luke relationship. Sorry :)


message 8: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Shruti wrote: "PERFECT COUPLE! BESIDES PERCABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Maybe if Luke wasn't the evil jerk face he is. But no not perfect at all, Thalia is a HUNTER! So I don't think she would ever break away from that.


message 9: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
Shruti wrote: "I'm talking about before that!!!!!!!!!!!! when thalia was alive! on the time when Annabeth, Luke, and thalia were on the run!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

I agree with that.


message 10: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Shruti wrote: "Saberin wrote: "Shruti wrote: "PERFECT COUPLE! BESIDES PERCABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Maybe if Luke wasn't the evil jerk face he is. But no not perfect at all, Thalia is a HUNTER! So I don't think she wo..."


Ok yeah if Luke hadn't turned evil and Thalia hadn't turned into a tree it wouldn't have been ad weird I guess.


message 11: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments If u look up the youtube videos you would change ur mind


message 12: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments Nodding me head You need to see it


message 13: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Shrishti~dance~freak wrote: "This is a weird, weird couple. I mean I Thalia+Luke has always been like Harry+Hermione for me!!!
Thalia+Leo is a better couple."


Thalia and Leo? I don't think so....... I honestly think Echo is going to make a reappearance.


message 14: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Echo is the nymph that was on the island with that guy ((narcissus?)) and all the other nymphs. She was cursed to always echo what people say. And I would like Thalia/Luke better than Thalia/Leo. But both of them is better than Thalia/Nico. I hate that paring...


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

Saberin wrote: "Echo is the nymph that was on the island with that guy ((narcissus?)) and all the other nymphs. She was cursed to always echo what people say. And I would like Thalia/Luke better than Thalia/Leo. B..."

Agreed! I used to love Thaluke, now I'm...meh. I can imagine Thalia liking Luke, and Luke liking Thalia, but...well. It's complicated.


message 16: by ЅᎯℬℰ (new)

ЅᎯℬℰ (doyouhearthepeoplesing) | 155 comments Thank you!


message 17: by Thalia (new)

Thalia Wilson (purplenails) | 15 comments I so wanted Thaluke to happen, but I guess Rick Riordan didn't! :)


message 18: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments I know!


message 19: by Greta (new)

Greta S. (daughterofHades) | 37 comments Thalia wrote: "I so wanted Thaluke to happen, but I guess Rick Riordan didn't! :)"

Check out the Thaluke vids1


message 20: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
Ikr? Thalia and Luke would've been cute together.


message 21: by Kaity (new)

Kaity (i-love-books-because-reasons) I kind of ship them, I just never really thought pf them as a couple.


message 22: by Disneyboy (new)

Disneyboy | 26 comments Yeah, even thou I think Luke loved Annabeth more.


message 23: by Kate (new)

Kate (percysfangirls) | 6 comments They only could've ended up together if Thalia didn't become a tree. If Thalia lived, Luke might not have turned bad and yeah. But I LOVE THALUKE OMG THEY ARE PERFECT ALTHOUGH I FEEL THAT LUKE LOVED ANNABETH TOWARDS THE END MORE BUT THALIA MORE AT THE START. BUT WHATEVER SINCE DEMIGOD DIARIES I WILL NEVER NOT SHIP THALUKE.


message 24: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
I support Thaluke. :3


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
It would be the worst thing EVER!! Not only is Thalia a huntress Luke is a total EVIL JERK if Thalia ever did date (which I mentioned before she doesn't) she would deserve someone WAY better maybe someone who I dunno DOES NOT TRY TO KILL PERCY JACKSON!!! The day Thaluke is a reality is the day I stop reading Rick's work NO THALUKE EVER!!!!!!


message 26: by shrish (new)

shrish (orshay) But Luke isn't evil... He wasn't in the end, at least...


message 28: by Thalia (new)

Thalia Wilson (purplenails) | 15 comments THALUKE!


message 29: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
I ship Thaluke. Maybe if Luke hadn't been manipulated by Kronos, it would've been possible. Then again, if he hadn't, Thalia would still be a tree. :/


message 30: by Izzy (new)

Izzy (izzyrose13) Yes! I ship it!!!!!!


message 31: by Sadieeeee (new)

Sadieeeee (sadieperson) | 119 comments Maybe yes maybe no I’m not sure


message 32: by Sadieeeee (new)

Sadieeeee (sadieperson) | 119 comments Actually THALUKE


Kat(Taylor’s Version) | 15 comments Noooo. Theyna 4 life


message 34: by [deleted user] (new)

Okay I'm totally just throwing this out there but, I think for Annabeth to accept her feelings for Percy Luke had to die. And was he really bad?? (I still hate him for what he did to Annabeth)
He said they would be a family.


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

He died when he gave his body to Kronos.


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

I have to, and every time I read it, I still hate him. But now that I understand it, I kinda feel a little sorry for him.
Also, has anyone but me ever noticed how much he and Jason look alike?


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

Do you think he wound up in the fields of punishment? Or the fields of Asphodel? I almost hope he's in Elysium.


message 38: by [deleted user] (new)

True.


message 39: by [deleted user] (new)

Who is Connor Bailey?


message 40: by abby (new)

abby chambliss | 145 comments no. just…just no.


message 41: by abby (new)

abby chambliss | 145 comments also luke isn’t exactly alive…


message 42: by Quinn (new)

Quinn Iannotta | 104 comments Omg I love Land of Stories it would so funny if Connor and Percy met


message 43: by PJO 4 ever (new)

PJO 4 ever | 101 comments ??


message 44: by PJO 4 ever (new)

PJO 4 ever | 101 comments lol


message 45: by [deleted user] (new)

deleted user wrote: "He died when he gave his body to Kronos."

Think of it this way. What if he didn't consent to give his body up to Kronos. What if he wanted to turn back in the titans curse but couldn't. Because it even said that Hermes despised Annabeth for not taking up Luke's offer of running away with him in like the last OLYMPAIN.


back to top