David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite! discussion
This topic is about
Requiem
Buddy Reads!
>
Requiem Buddy Read!
date
newest »
newest »
Karen wrote: "44% - Hana did what?!?!? [spoilers removed]"
Yeah, I almost missed it! It was just a couple of lines and I almost glossed over them lol! Crazy right? And you're spot on about Fred, but wait, it gets even better at what a great guy he is lol
Yeah, I almost missed it! It was just a couple of lines and I almost glossed over them lol! Crazy right? And you're spot on about Fred, but wait, it gets even better at what a great guy he is lol
David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up 
[bookcover..."UGH, Boundless was another one that disappointed me! LOL! I'm on a roll with that!
Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up 
[bookcover:Breaking Poin..."Oh I so want to read The Way We Fall. I have an ARC of The next one that the publisher sent to me but I never got to it :(
David wrote: "Lol I love you guys :) I know, I know, I'm a sap, but Truly, you all mean a lot to me and make my life more enriched than it would be if I didn't know you.
Always up for a buddy read with any of ..."
Thank you David, that was really sweet! This group is just full of awesomeness!
Always up for a buddy read with any of ..."
Thank you David, that was really sweet! This group is just full of awesomeness!
David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up

[bookcover..."
What do you mean it was "Manufactured?"

[bookcover..."What do you mean it was "Manufactured?"
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up

[bookcover..."
I also have the second book, The Lives We Lost, but of course, I have to read the first one first lol!

[bookcover..."I also have the second book, The Lives We Lost, but of course, I have to read the first one first lol!
Karen wrote: "44% - Hana did what?!?!? [spoilers removed]"
I know, right? It goes into more detail in the short story, Hana
I know, right? It goes into more detail in the short story, Hana
Karen wrote: "Wow, so excited that our buddy read thread exploded!!! Now I just have to actually finish Requiem so I can read all the spoilers!!! You guys are all amazing for joining in! I can't wait to see..."I already read Requiem and I have very mixed emotions about it, that ending, ugh, I just want an epilogue. I don't feel that is too much to ask for! But I would love to read Unwind! I have that book sitting in my currently reading list (but plan to start in the next couple days).
Jenny wrote: "David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."
Here's one of many articles on the subject. I just hate to support the man who's exploiting young authors. But I do like the series so I'm torn! I didn't hear about this until after I'd read the first two books :(
http://m.guardian.co.uk/books/2010/no...
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."Here's one of many articles on the subject. I just hate to support the man who's exploiting young authors. But I do like the series so I'm torn! I didn't hear about this until after I'd read the first two books :(
http://m.guardian.co.uk/books/2010/no...
Jenny wrote: "David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."
Here's one of many articles on the subject. I just hate to support the man who's exploiting young authors. But I do like the series so I'm torn! I didn't hear about this until after I'd read the first two books :(
http://m.guardian.co.uk/books/2010/no...
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."Here's one of many articles on the subject. I just hate to support the man who's exploiting young authors. But I do like the series so I'm torn! I didn't hear about this until after I'd read the first two books :(
http://m.guardian.co.uk/books/2010/no...
The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."
You're killing me lol!
[bookcover:Unravel Me|13104..."You're killing me lol!
David wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up
..."LOL! Sorry....just my opinion tho, remember that. You liked Requiem more than I did!
Oooh, disagreement between Brooke and Lolita, I love it! Jenny and I can be the tiebreakers! LOL
PS-Brooke, I don't think you're that harsh, there's nothing wrong with having an opinion ;)
PS-Brooke, I don't think you're that harsh, there's nothing wrong with having an opinion ;)
David wrote: "Oooh, disagreement between Brooke and Lolita, I love it! Jenny and I can be the tiebreakers! LOLPS-Brooke, I don't think you're that harsh, there's nothing wrong with having an opinion ;)"
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, that's for sure! LOL!
I am happy to see there are others who liked it more. I did give it a 4, just didn't think it was as good as the first two.
David wrote: "Ok well that's not bad then, but it would be tough to follow up the first two!"Yeah, I liked it, just wasn't totally happy with the end. But I loved the writing.
Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR). My thoughts (view spoiler)
Karen wrote: "44% - Hana did what?!?!? [spoilers removed]"I think there's a possibility that he's not completely...you know. that.
David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "David wrote: "Jenny wrote: "I have a whole bunch of books I need to read, I'll just list them here quick in case anyone wants to buddy up
[bookcover:Un..."I think guys, you shouldn't just get affected with these kind of reviews...
Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR)."And with that. I'm kinda expecting more fan fic coming out. ahaha
Reymart wrote: "Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR)."
And with that. I'm kinda expecting more fan fic coming out. ahaha"
Yea, probably lots of fan fiction coming! (Wish I was a writer!). :-) That was an interesting world!
And with that. I'm kinda expecting more fan fic coming out. ahaha"
Yea, probably lots of fan fiction coming! (Wish I was a writer!). :-) That was an interesting world!
Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR). My thoughts First of all, I'm so happy that Lena reunited with her mom and they became close again..."
Aww yayyyy!! I'm so glad you liked it! I agree with everything you said (especially the bits about Raven although like you, I didn't read the novella), except the thing about Alex's response to Lena's attempt to get moving back in the same direction. It's funny that in the only one who thinks Alex was completely in the wrong there and I'm a guy haha! For me it was just because I thought Lauren Oliver wrote Lena's speech so beautifully there that I found myself tearing up and my heart swelling and then Alex totally shut her down and didn't even act like it was a hard thing to do. I was like Argfhghrhggrggfr!!!!
Lol :)
Aww yayyyy!! I'm so glad you liked it! I agree with everything you said (especially the bits about Raven although like you, I didn't read the novella), except the thing about Alex's response to Lena's attempt to get moving back in the same direction. It's funny that in the only one who thinks Alex was completely in the wrong there and I'm a guy haha! For me it was just because I thought Lauren Oliver wrote Lena's speech so beautifully there that I found myself tearing up and my heart swelling and then Alex totally shut her down and didn't even act like it was a hard thing to do. I was like Argfhghrhggrggfr!!!!
Lol :)
The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "Ok well that's not bad then, but it would be tough to follow up the first two!"Yeah, I liked it, just wasn't totally happy with the end. But I loved the writing."
I actually loved the ending. Although there were some small things that could've been done better to build more up to the ending.
Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR). My thoughts First of all, I'm so happy that Lena reunited with her mom and they became close again..."COMPLETELY agree about Julian. And David - my husband would never be anything like Alex either. He'd probably say the same thing as you! I got the best one ever : )
Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR). My thoughts First of all, I'm so happy that Lena reunited with her mom and they became close again..."
YAY!!! I'm so glad we both loved it! I gave it the same rating!
I agree with everything but Raven, but I read the short story, which was really good! I didn't really like Raven in Pandemonium at all either!
YAY!!! I'm so glad we both loved it! I gave it the same rating!
I agree with everything but Raven, but I read the short story, which was really good! I didn't really like Raven in Pandemonium at all either!
Jen wrote: "Karen wrote: "Finished! I loved loved loved it and really loved the ending! I'm rating this a 4.5 (5 on GR). My thoughts First of all, I'm so happy that Lena reunited with her mom and they beca..."
Hehe that makes me happy to hear!
Hehe that makes me happy to hear!
David, you're just a one of a kind type of guy! Or, make that two of a kind, since Jen's husband is like that too!! Both keepers!! ;)
Most of the time I like to make comments that are funny, snarky, or just plain weird. However, for this book I will write like I have some sense. Alex: very frustrating character who broke my heart over and over. I understood his actions although it did not ease the pain of them.
Lena: love her! Smacking the **** out of Hana made my day.
Hana: at first I didn't like reading about her, but as the book progressed I realized the necessity of it. What she ended up doing at the end gained her pimp status in my book.
Julian: kept drawing the short straw, poor guy.
Everyone else had a role and played it even if it was tragic, brave, or just plain stupid.
Oliver did not end the book in a traditional sense. What she did instead was transfer power and complete control to her readers. We are able to make what we want to happen, whatever ending brings us the greatest joy and satisfaction. Personally, Lena and Alex ended up together and I was able to envision a beautiful reunion all on my own. For others, they wanted it in print. I think if their reunion had been in print I'd have given it 5 stars. Xoxo everyone and off to the next buddy read. P.S.-David we appreciate you too and think you're awesome! :)
David wrote: "Awwwwwwwww
*big red blushing*
Some would just call me weird :P"
That's not a bad thing to be weird! Most of us book lovers are, I think! I know I am! :)
*big red blushing*
Some would just call me weird :P"
That's not a bad thing to be weird! Most of us book lovers are, I think! I know I am! :)
Simone wrote: "Most of the time I like to make comments that are funny, snarky, or just plain weird. However, for this book I will write like I have some sense.
Alex: very frustrating character who broke my hear..."
Aww thanks, right back at ya! And thanks for your comments, I think you bridged the gap people those who loved the ending and those who hated it!
Alex: very frustrating character who broke my hear..."
Aww thanks, right back at ya! And thanks for your comments, I think you bridged the gap people those who loved the ending and those who hated it!
Books mentioned in this topic
Boundless (other topics)Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
More...





I would love to read Unravel Me with Jen and Jenny and anyone else who wants to join in. David and I have been talking about buddy reading Hunger for a while too! And I think there's a few for Boundless, it looks like. I haven't read any from that series yet but you guys go for it!!
So many books, so little time!! Hahahah... I'm off to read more of Requiem!