Team Edward discussion
Should Stephenie Make More Twilight Books From More Point-Of-Views?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Michelle
(new)
Mar 26, 2009 07:04PM
I bring this up because I would like to hear the story from more sides than Edward's and Bella's. Please comment!
reply
|
flag
I think they should make a book in Renesmee's point of view. Like maybe her life with Jacob...That would rock.
Yes, Reunesmee's would be good.
I love your ideas for different points of views; if I understand correctly point of view from secondary charatcters. I think too many things might be reiterated and/or loose the dynamics of the original story of Bella and Edward. I have read a few series that spin off and dive into the secondary characters and they rate lower than the originals in all cases.
I really like the Renesmee idea. I have been thinking about it ever since I finished BD. I don't think it should be the fourth book from her perspective, I think it should be it's own book - a continuation of the Saga.
I vote for Carlisle. Carlisle seems like a reservoir of knowledge just waiting to be tapped. I would really like to read his whole story, but I would settle for a Twilight retelling from a more mature perspective.I would also love to know Edward's story, pre-Bella. I'm really pretty sick of Bella (to be honest, it's probably because she embodies the teen-craze with this series...but that's beside the point).
It's pretty likely (in my opinion) that Meyer will continue the series from Renesmee's perspective. Not sure if I would read it. She's probably be just like Bella, maybe a little edgier.
I agree, learning about Edward before Bella might be interesting. And yeah! Carlisle is a great idea. I would love to read about him. His story seems so interesting - there's so much there!I don't think Renesmee would be very much like Bella. She seems much more assertive, strong, outgoing...and almost cocky. She also seems much more advanced mentally. Her situation is so different I'm curious about how she'll handle the problems she's faced with. (I'm not saying Bella's dumb, just that Renesmee's make-up is obviously different and allows her more supernatural intelligence/alertness.)
Yes, Stephanie HAS to be the only writer that has had me that hook ed on their books. OMG i loved them soooooooooooooooooooooo much if u know what i mean! I went 3 Days without sleeping just to read it. If Stephanie Meyer writes a new book, I will write her a letter telling her that she is a genius for writing twilight! I LOVE TWILIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jb wrote: "i think they should branch on a totally different character, a new character. that somehow intertwines with the cullens."That would be nice...but maybe a little contrived. I guess Renesmee is supposed to fill those shoes.
yea definatly they should do more but thats the best books i have ever read ever
Evelynn wrote: "I vote for Carlisle. Carlisle seems like a reservoir of knowledge just waiting to be tapped. I would really like to read his whole story, but I would settle for a Twilight retelling from a more m..."oh! oh! Carlisle would b awesome! edward pre bella would b cool too... not so much renesmee. idk, it mite b cool, but mite b lame 2.
i hav heard of it but its not ture well i thing but there is a book of edwards veiw of twilight i kno CUUL azZZZZZ man i hav read it on line it roXXXXXs u should read it like big time bro!! lol
Michelle wrote: "I bring this up because I would like to hear the story from more sides than Edward's and Bella's. Please comment!"Nicolerenee55 wrote: "I love your ideas for different points of views; if I understand correctly point of view from secondary charatcters. I think too many things might be reiterated and/or loose the dynamics of the ori..."
i think it sould only be on the point of views for bella, edward,renesme, and maybe jacob but idk if it would be all that intresting b/c of the chapters of breaking dawn on jacobs point of view was really boring
Evelynn wrote: "I vote for Carlisle. Carlisle seems like a reservoir of knowledge just waiting to be tapped. I would really like to read his whole story, but I would settle for a Twilight retelling from a more m..."midnight sun is on edwards point of view so i'm pretty sure she's going to do edward and renesme. and maybe jacob
u know she can change the entire story if she wanted to cus its just a ruff draft + what the people say is pretty funny
omg if she did renesme that would be cool
MIDNIGHT SUN! I need to read it...but if it is not published I swear Im going to kill Stephenie Meyer!
Michelle wrote: "I bring this up because I would like to hear the story from more sides than Edward's and Bella's. Please comment!"Yes she should do more views. Besides bella's.
carslile and omg i need to get breaking dawn i know who renesme is but i wish i didnt my friend thought it was resemee
yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssss
I totaly think from Alice's would be cool. She's like WAY better than Bella and it would be cool to see what she thnks of everything. Renes would be cool but just in another book. I don't think they would do one in Carlisle's because he is too much of a father figure but i think it would be interesting. No Jacob plz. He will just be all hung up over Renes.It was anoing enough when he was in love with Bella.
I agree. Alice would be awesome. So would Carlisle, and I sooo want Midnight Sun to come out, to c Edwards POV in Twilight. It would also b cool to c what he was like pre-bella, and during New Moon. Jacob would be stupid... so would Renesmee, sry but i don't like her that much. she's cute and awesome and all but... kinda stupid. i blame the too much of a happy ending on her.
