The Complete Liveship Traders Trilogy: Ship of Magic, The Mad Ship, Ship of Destiny The Complete Liveship Traders Trilogy discussion


15 views
Should I continue?

Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nocta (new)

Nocta Hi guys,
I have read The Farseer Trilogy some years back and now I'm reading The Liveship Traders Trilogy and I'm in the middle of the second book.
I liked the Farseer Trilogy because there was much tension and exciting stuff happened. I only didn't like the last part of the trilogy. The end was disappointing and not very well designed IMO.

Now, some years later, I'm halfway through the second book in the 2nd trilogy, as I said. I like the characters, they are very detailed and vivid. BUT: The story - it's boring.
Nothing ever happens. Sure, SOMETHING is happening but most of it is progressing very slowly and there is nearly no tension in it. No plot twists and nothing. I like the fact that it is so detailed and you can understand every decision of every character. Nearly feel what they feel and think what they think.
But I can barely read a chapter before I stop reading again for a while, because it feels like nothing is happening.
Maybe I'm too spoiled by other modern fantasy where nearly every time you turn the page something very important happens. The last books I read are all of the Brandon Sanderson books and The First Law Trilogy, so that is probably one cause :)

So here are my questions:
1. Will it get more exciting, and is this just a very slow progression to an awesome and exciting third part?

2. Will the next trilogy (Tawny Man) be more like the first books of the Farseer Trilogy?

If at least one of these questions has a positive answer, I think I'll read on but at the moment I am really considering to get a more exciting book.

Thanks for your advice in advance!


Samantha Martin I have to tell you, it's so worth it. I didn't get fully enmeshed into the series until I finished the second book. I usually can read a decent sized fantasy novel within a few weeks, but it took me four months to get through these first two books. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed every minute of it, and found the characters totally appealing in every way. Hobb leaves just enough to the imagination. I took my time, it was a slow burn. But within three weeks I had finished the very end of book two and all of book three and literally couldn't put it down. It's a total pay off, IMO. I hope you carry on!


message 3: by Kya (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kya Strong I enjoyed The Liveship Traders but you do have to persevere with it. My favourites, though, were the Farseer and Tawny Man trilogies (especially the latter!) I think reading them all helps round out the characters as different aspects are explored in the different books. I envy you! I must make time to read them all again!


back to top