Historical Romance Book Club discussion
The Ton
>
Almack's (General chat and socializing-all topics)
message 1051:
by
Missy
(new)
Dec 31, 2023 05:05PM

reply
|
flag

I recently saw a notice that the Gilded Newport mystery series is going to be made into movies by Hallmark. The first one, Murder at the Breakers is going to premier in February. These are period movies and should have some romance in them too. I've read the first book and hope to get to the rest. Am looking forward to seeing the movies.


https://youtu.be/I3NUJdohOo8?si=lU3UA...

https://youtu.be/QkCD64x5BUA?si=p8ek-...

It will premiere next Saturday, February 24th at 8:00 PM (Pacific Time in the USA) on the Hallmark channel.
Loveuary preview - https://www.hallmarkchannel.com/loveu...
Loveuary movie schedule - https://www.hallmarkchannel.com/loveu...
Sense & Sensibility preview - https://www.hallmarkchannel.com/sense...

It will premiere next Saturday, February 24th at 8:00 PM (Pacific Time in..."
Thanks Missy going to check it out
I saw two of the movies Hallmark created to Loveuary, An American in Austen and Love & Jane, I confess they didn't hit the mark. Nice but not great. I think my expectations about Jane Austen movies it's always very high, so...

I thought we were going to get some more new historical romance series. When they made the Bridgertons.
These producers have No imagination. If they still keep going back to the classics. Which they will probably ruin by going away from a proper historical context.

I thought we were going to get some more new historical romance series. When..."
Reinventing the wheel..tends to get a bit boring. You are right ..no imagination😊

I thought we were going to get some more new historical romance series. When..."
I agree. Let's see some new HR series from some of our fav writers' books, like Lisa Kleypas or Eloisa James or Jennifer Ashley etc. I did not enjoy the 2022 movie version of Persuasion. Let's see something new!

If they are doing historical it needs to be historical 🙄🤷♀️


I thought we were going to get some more new historical rom..."
i agree! great point!
i get that Austen & the Brontes are classics but there are sooo many other books that I think we contemporaries feel are classics for our generation.
GoodReads publish a list 108 New Romance Recommendations for (Nearly) Every Kind of Reader
https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...
Here are some themes explored
- I go weak in the knees for second-chance romance
- I love a romance where the complication is TIME ITSELF
- I'd like to read a historical romance NOT set in Regency or Victorian England
- OK, but don't leave us Regency/Victorian romance readers hanging!
- I'm a sucker for a contemporary Jane Austen retelling!
- Show me some protagonists in their 40s, 50s, 60s, and beyond, please!
Seems nice to explore and had some new books to our TBR! What do you think?
https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...
Here are some themes explored
- I go weak in the knees for second-chance romance
- I love a romance where the complication is TIME ITSELF
- I'd like to read a historical romance NOT set in Regency or Victorian England
- OK, but don't leave us Regency/Victorian romance readers hanging!
- I'm a sucker for a contemporary Jane Austen retelling!
- Show me some protagonists in their 40s, 50s, 60s, and beyond, please!
Seems nice to explore and had some new books to our TBR! What do you think?

So I took a chance while flicking through channels and came across Sense & Sensibility as part of the Hallmark Loveuary...why did I put myself through so much torture. 😬 Didn't care for it at all and I should have been punished 🤣

https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...?..."
Hi Sandra...I tapped into that and came away with some interesting reads for my TBR.

@Sandra, the names for each theme are creative! "I'm really into neighbors who bang" made me laugh. Thanks for sharing.

@Debby, I caught the last half of the movie. I was wondering why it was fast-paced before I realized that they have to fit as much material as they can into approximately 2 hours.
I love the accent of the actor who played Colonel Brandon. *swoons* I was more interested in his romance and wished it was the main romance in S&S.
I never understood the appeal of Edward Ferrars (Elinor's love interest). At one point, Marianne compared his choices to that of John Willoughby, so I guess that was what Jane Austen intended for Edward. Whether I liked him as the hero or not, I still got teary-eyed during the proposal scene.
This is the third adaptation of S&S that I've watched. It was okay, I guess.

https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...?..."
cool.

@Missy..oh did forget about Col. Brandon and did love his voice. You are correct...they needed to crunch as much as they could in that small amount of time. I gess after sewing this adaptation im pretty spoined by the other two versions. 😊

Me either! Colonel Brandon is a much better hero. I'm not a fan of Marianne either. It would have been better if Elinor and Brandon had been the main couple. This is one of the reasons S&S is not my preferred Jane Austen book.
Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "Sandra wrote: "I saw two of the movies Hallmark created to Loveuary, An American in Austen and Love & Jane, I confess they didn't hit the mark. Nice but not great. I think my expectations about Jan..."
Ohhh, really? We don't have Hallmark Channel in Portugal, so I will have to wait until some PT channel buys it or appears on YouTube, but somehow I will not hold my breath... ;)
Ohhh, really? We don't have Hallmark Channel in Portugal, so I will have to wait until some PT channel buys it or appears on YouTube, but somehow I will not hold my breath... ;)
Missy wrote: "Sandra wrote: "GoodReads publish a list 108 New Romance Recommendations for (Nearly) Every Kind of Reader"
@Sandra, the names for each theme are creative! "I'm really into neighbors who bang" made..."
Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "Sandra wrote: "GoodReads publish a list 108 New Romance Recommendations for (Nearly) Every Kind of Reader
https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...-..."
I thought they here funny too, eheh, maybe we could use some for the next year BOTM's
@Sandra, the names for each theme are creative! "I'm really into neighbors who bang" made..."
Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "Sandra wrote: "GoodReads publish a list 108 New Romance Recommendations for (Nearly) Every Kind of Reader
https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...-..."
I thought they here funny too, eheh, maybe we could use some for the next year BOTM's
Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "Missy wrote: "Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "So I took a chance while flicking through channels and came across Sense & Sensibility as part of the Hallmark Loveuary...why did I put myself through so much ..."
Missy wrote: "Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "So I took a chance while flicking through channels and came across Sense & Sensibility as part of the Hallmark Loveuary...why did I put myself through so much torture. 😬 Did..."
I believe the hallmark movies have less than 2 hours, I wonder how can they put S&S in that time period... something like, "ups, it's over..."
Missy wrote: "Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "So I took a chance while flicking through channels and came across Sense & Sensibility as part of the Hallmark Loveuary...why did I put myself through so much torture. 😬 Did..."
I believe the hallmark movies have less than 2 hours, I wonder how can they put S&S in that time period... something like, "ups, it's over..."
Ohhh, I really have to read S & S again, my memory is a mess and I don't remember much of the story...


I love all of these as well as some of the later versions from the 2000s.
Debby *BabyDee* wrote: "@Lauren...I agree, Elinor and Brandon would have made a better couple in this story and Marianne was a bit annoying. I can watch S&S but it is not my favorite. My likes the 1990's versions of Persu..."
My fave off all times is Pride & Prejudice, from BBC, 1995
My fave off all times is Pride & Prejudice, from BBC, 1995

https://youtu.be/i2K7txJfKcs?si=Z-kKT...

https://youtu.be/eqqapM_Ce4w?si=KrL3d...

https://youtu.be/eqqapM_Ce4w?si=KrL3d..."
WOW! That trailer looked so good. Im in tp watch that one.

https://youtu.be/YDLO2De3zqQ?si=HeBHw..."
This one looks good also. Watching.


I am not having that problem but I may be using a different format.
I access it on my laptop through the Goodreads website. I don't use the app.
I am also assuming that you are talking about the "currently reading" shelf under "Book Shelves" (which is under "My Books") - that's what shows up on my website-based view.
Wish I could have been more help. Hope this gets fixed for you soon. Goodreads glitches can be so aggravating!
Books mentioned in this topic
Fires of Winter (other topics)Fires of Winter (other topics)
Isaiah & Isolde: A Pennyroyal Green Prequel (other topics)
My Lady Jane (other topics)
My Lady Jane (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Julie Garwood (other topics)Jennifer Ashley (other topics)
Johanna Lindsey (other topics)
Joanna Bourne (other topics)
Julie Anne Long (other topics)
More...