Historical Romance Book Club discussion

559 views
The Ton > Almack's (General chat and socializing-all topics)

Comments Showing 601-650 of 1,228 (1228 new)    post a comment »

🐝 Shaz 🐝  | 1240 comments I am with you Lauren. But I might cave before it airs πŸ™„πŸ˜‚


message 602: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
A list: 30 Hot Historical Romances to Light Your Fire in 2021

https://www.goodreads.com/blog/show/2...


message 603: by Lauren (new)

Lauren | 1425 comments Thanks for the list Sandra!


message 604: by Sam I (new)

Sam I AMNreader | 611 comments Hitting this thread with the year's final Mountain Climbing Challenge /pick it for me.

Check it out if you're interested in knocking off some TBRs.

https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...


message 605: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
QUIZ: WHICH JANE AUSTEN VILLAIN ARE YOU?

https://bookriot.com/jane-austen-vill...

I'm Lady Catherine de Bourgh, Boring!!! Eheheh!!!


message 606: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments I'm Mr. Wickham. :D This was fun. Thanks for sharing.


message 607: by Mariana (new)

Mariana | 2692 comments I am Mr. Willoughby.


message 608: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Ohhh, I would to be Mr. Wickham, eheheh!!


message 609: by Cynthia (new)

Cynthia Miller (clm1743) | 18 comments hi! I am Lady Catherine de Bourgh :)


message 610: by Ida (new)

Ida (ida_my) | 62 comments Lucy Steele here, I haven't read sense and sensibility so I'm not sure what that says about me...


message 611: by Lauren (new)

Lauren (laurenjberman) | 584 comments I also got Lady Catherine, lol!


message 612: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new)

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
Ida wrote: "Lucy Steele here, I haven't read sense and sensibility so I'm not sure what that says about me..."

Lucy Steele is an interesting character. She is a pretty, cunning character, but doesn’t have much polish. She befriends Elinor (the main character) and then entrusts with a secret that she knows might cut Elinor deeply, which it does. Ultimately she is a social climber and is looking out for herself. She uses characters innate qualities against (like honor) to get what she wants.

Have you seen either the 1995 movie or the 2008 series?


message 613: by Ida (new)

Ida (ida_my) | 62 comments Thank you :)
Does not sound like a person I would like to be like, but I guess that is why she is in there :D

I haven't seen any of the series/movies either. I will read (or watch) it when I finally finish North and South (It is taking me sooo long).


message 614: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new)

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
Ida wrote: "Thank you :)
Does not sound like a person I would like to be like, but I guess that is why she is in there :D

I haven't seen any of the series/movies either. I will read (or watch) it when I fina..."


I don’t think any of the villains are ones to emulate or be like, lol. I don’t think S&S is as easy to read as some of Austen’s others, but Elinor is probably my favorite heroine. She is very resilient. The movie is among my favorite adaptations in general, very good but it takes plenty of liberties too.


message 615: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
About Pride and Prejudice, did you prefer the BBC serie from 1995 or the movie from 2005? Mainly Mr. Darcy's character?


message 616: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments Oh, that's hard!


message 617: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Missy, not if your profile photo answers the question, eheheh!


message 618: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments lol I was going to answer 2005.


message 619: by Ida (new)

Ida (ida_my) | 62 comments I'll watch the S&S series or movie then :)

I prefer 1995, Kiera Knightley annoys me (don't know why, she is probably a lovely person) and I like Colin Firths Darcy :)


message 620: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
My problem with the 2005 version, despite being hard making a comparative between a TV series and a movie, is Mr. Darcy... I don't even know the name of the actor in the movie but Colin Firth will be forever The Mr Darcy! And I love Lizzy in the 1995 version.


message 621: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
I went looking for the actors in the 2005 movie and I really like so of the actors in the movie. So, maybe I should see the movie again ;). Mr. Wickham is Rupert Friend more enjoyable than the 1995 version, eheh


message 622: by Lauren (new)

Lauren (laurenjberman) | 584 comments Sandra wrote: "Colin Firth will be forever The Mr Darcy!."

Yes, he will!


message 623: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Ida wrote: "I'll watch the S&S series or movie then :)

I prefer 1995, Kiera Knightley annoys me (don't know why, she is probably a lovely person) and I like Colin Firths Darcy :)"


Joanna Loves Reading wrote: "Ida wrote: "Lucy Steele here, I haven't read sense and sensibility so I'm not sure what that says about me..."

Lucy Steele is an interesting character. She is a pretty, cunning character, but does..."


Ida wrote: "I'll watch the S&S series or movie then :)

I prefer 1995, Kiera Knightley annoys me (don't know why, she is probably a lovely person) and I like Colin Firths Darcy :)"



message 624: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Ida, I agree with both your preferences. For me, I don't think Kiera was pretty enough to play Lizzy. And neither was the guy who played Darcy (can't think of his name) handsome enough. Actually, he looked rather goofy. But that is just my opinion. I thought both Jennifer and Colin were perfect casting.


message 625: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Joanna Loves Reading wrote: "Ida wrote: "Lucy Steele here, I haven't read sense and sensibility so I'm not sure what that says about me..."

Lucy Steele is an interesting character. She is a pretty, cunning character, but does..."



message 626: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Joanna, Well, bummer. I have to disagree with your assessment of Lucy Steele. For me, she is silly, frivilous, and is completely "out to lunch" as far as intelligence goes. But then, wasn't her characterization spot on when it comes to young, marriagable aged young lady during the Regency period? Their every thought centered on finding a husband. Preferably rich, but not necessarily set in stone. Actually, almost any man would do because the thought of ending up an old maid would be a fate worse than death. She was so feather-headed that she truly did believe her so called "engagement" of long ago to Edward was valid! She was also annoyingly silly. Gossip to her was like cream to a cat. She LOVED sharing secrets and she didn't seem to care who she shared them with. Didn't she even share her "secret" with Edward's hoity sister? But again, this is just my opinion.


message 627: by Lauren (new)

Lauren | 1425 comments I loved the 2005. That's probably bc I saw it first. Matthew Macfadyen was in Pilliars Of The Earth as Prior Philip . I fell in love with his understated acting. If I had seen Colin Firth first I might feel differently.

In all honesty, we will probably be discussing the same topic in ten years when Hollywood comes out with 2 more Pride And Prejudice movies. I'm just happy they haven't touched 1995 Sense And Sensibility yet.


message 628: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Dearest Ladies, I've been a member of Goodreads for quite a while, but have never commented until now. My comments are merely my own and not meant to offend anyone. I am also a writer, mostly of Historical Romances. However, right now I am working on four novels at once. Two are English Historical Romances, One Contemporary Romantic Suspense, and one (please don't laugh) Vietnam War novel. No romance in that one. My Historical Romances are in various forms of the eternal Cinderella story. I do have an author page on facebook, "Judy's Works In Progress," in which I have posted the 1st and some 2nd chapters as well as a couple of scenes from what I am working on. If interested, I would love for you to check out my page and......PLEASE leave a comment, good or bad, as to what you think. I was published long, long ago, but am trying to make a come back.


message 629: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Lauren wrote: "I loved the 2005. That's probably bc I saw it first. Matthew Macfadyen was in Pilliars Of The Earth as Prior Philip . I fell in love with his understated acting. If I had seen Colin Firth first I m..."

Yes, maybe, the problem is that, each one we saw first, but to reinforce my love for Colin Firth's Darcy, we don't have other movies, playing characters inspired in Mr. Darcy made with the actor from 2005, eheheh!!

Lauren, I'm joking!! I also love the entire serie, the sisters, the family and the surroundings from the 1995 version, but obviously the serie is more complete than the movie.


message 630: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Judith wrote: "Joanna, Well, bummer. I have to disagree with your assessment of Lucy Steele. For me, she is silly, frivilous, and is completely "out to lunch" as far as intelligence goes. But then, wasn't her cha..."

I don't remember very well Lucy Steele character but I have the same idea about that character.


message 631: by Sandra (last edited Oct 19, 2021 03:21PM) (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
And what about Sanditon??? Did you saw the serie??


message 632: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new)

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
Judith wrote: "Joanna, Well, bummer. I have to disagree with your assessment of Lucy Steele. For me, she is silly, frivilous, and is completely "out to lunch" as far as intelligence goes. But then, wasn't her cha..."

I don't think it's a bummer to have different opinions :-). It's been awhile since I have read the book, but it is one of my favorites. I am sure that I don't have it quite right, though. I do not get the impression that she is book smart or intelligent in a philosophical sense. She does come off as silly, but I do think she is cunning in an opportunist sense. Maybe not the most cunning character ever, and certainly she makes what seems to be a misstep with telling Fanny. However, it's hard to argue with the results (view spoiler)Really, I marvel out how everything ended up the way she wanted. Pure dumb luck? Maybe, but I think there is a fair bit of cunning to the character.


message 633: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Yes, I watched Sanditon. And from the first episode, I began planning my schedule around that next segment, and the one after that, and the one after that. I even purchased the entire first season of Sanditon! Now, I'm able to watch it at will.


message 634: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Joanna Loves Reading wrote: "Judith wrote: "Joanna, Well, bummer. I have to disagree with your assessment of Lucy Steele. For me, she is silly, frivilous, and is completely "out to lunch" as far as intelligence goes. But then,..."


message 635: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new)

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
Lauren wrote: "I loved the 2005. That's probably bc I saw it first. Matthew Macfadyen was in Pilliars Of The Earth as Prior Philip . I fell in love with his understated acting. If I had seen Colin Firth first I m..."

There is a 2008 BBC mini series of Sense and Sensibility. Andrew Davies wrote the screenplay, and he is also associated with 1995 P&P and Sanditon.


message 636: by Judith (new)

Judith Conklin | 14 comments Joanna, Oh, I agree that Lucy was a bit cunning. Finding, catching and managing to hold on to a potential mate back then was a cut throat business for an unattached miss. I did not find Edward all that appealing (at least for me), but hey, a bird in the hand, etc. Except, of course, when you are holding a sparrow when out of the blue an eagle comes along. Can't really blame the girl for exchanging a poor vicar for a monied gentleman.


message 637: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Did you read Sanditon? Wich version?

There are some book versions with Andrew Davies part (I presume) and some continuation from another writer.


message 638: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new)

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
Sandra wrote: "Did you read Sanditon? Wich version?

There are some book versions with Andrew Davies part (I presume) and some continuation from another writer."


I haven't read any version. Will look into it though.


message 639: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
Thanks Joanna!


message 640: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Moreira | 1121 comments Mod
If you need some help with your searches of HR ;)

HOW TO FIND A ROMANCE NOVEL BY DESCRIPTION

https://bookriot.com/find-a-romance-n...


message 641: by Lauren (new)

Lauren (laurenjberman) | 584 comments Has anyone see some of the new movie versions of Austin's books? The one the immediately comes to mind in Persuasion with Rupert Penry Jones.

I adore the 1990s one with Kieren Hinds and Amanda Root and somehow never imagined Captain Wentworth as a blond :)


Mamacita aka MawMaw  (mamawantsbedtimestory) | 417 comments Sandra wrote: "If you need some help with your searches of HR ;)

HOW TO FIND A ROMANCE NOVEL BY DESCRIPTION

https://bookriot.com/find-a-romance-n..."


I can't find the thread where Recommendations or Help...I can't find the name of a book.

Besides Fires of Winter (Haardrad Viking Family, #1) by Johanna Lindsey by Joanna Lindsey, does anybody have any recommendations on a book that has a Norse setting?


Mamacita aka MawMaw  (mamawantsbedtimestory) | 417 comments Disregard above ⬆️




message 644: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments Just wanted to share some trailers.

The Hating Game (no date yet just "coming soon")
https://youtu.be/0D2sJiseGQA


The Gilded Age streaming on HBO on January 24th
https://youtu.be/ZYBuU32B8PI


message 645: by Jenna (new)

Jenna | 217 comments thanks. i saw that Hating game trailer the other night on youtube.
gilded age looks interesting-something my mom would enjoy.


message 646: by Lauren (new)

Lauren | 1425 comments The Gilded Age looks good! I love to learn about other era's. I love history especially on eras I have rarely read. Thanks Missy for the links!


message 647: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments You're welcome. 😊


message 648: by Jan (new)

Jan (jan130) | 2701 comments Thank you Missy. Both look pretty good. I see the Gilded Age one is from the people who made Downton Abbey.


message 649: by Missy (new)

Missy | 1485 comments Hi, everyone,

I'm not sure how many of you follow the Bond Street thread in this group for free ebooks and ebooks on sale, so I wanted to share on this thread as well, so you don't miss out on BOGOs for Jennifer Ashley's ebooks and audiobooks on Kobo and Barnes and Noble. I copied and pasted her newsletter below for more detail.


From Jennifer Ashley:
BOGOs!

I wanted to alert you to several Buy-one, Get-one deals I have going on right now for my e-books and audio books at Kobo and Barnes and Noble.

At Kobo

At Kobo, a large number of my e-books are Buy One Get One Free until Dec 31. You'll see a tag on the ones that are on offer, and the discount is applied at checkout. (Available in Canada, the U.S., the U.K., Australia, and New Zealand.)

Essentially, almost all romances published by me are in the Kobo promo: Riding Hard, Shifters, Mackenzies, and all my Christmas Titles! (Please note any of my books published through Berkley are not available in this promo).

In addition many of my audiobooks at Kobo are on sale! Again, the discount is taken at checkout. (And again, if a Berkley book, not in the promo)

To find the books, simply go to https://kobo.com and search for Jennifer Ashley. You can choose filters to show only audio books or only e-books, as you like.

Barnes and Noble

At Barnes and Noble, I have a Buy One Get One 50% off for my holiday e-book titles: A Mackenzie Family Christmas, Fiona and the Three Wise Highlanders, Snowbound in Starlight Bend, and A Shifter Christmas Carol.

You won't see a discount marked, but it is taken at checkout.

(If you prefer print books, I apologize. These promos are e-book only, and I unfortunately have no control over that.)



message 650: by Jenna (new)

Jenna | 217 comments Missy wrote: "Hi, everyone,

I'm not sure how many of you follow the Bond Street thread in this group for free ebooks and ebooks on sale, so I wanted to share on this thread as well, so you don't miss out on BOG..."


thx for the head's up!


back to top