The Almond Tree The Almond Tree question


122 views
The Almond Tree
Lynda Lynda Feb 05, 2013 05:20PM
Has anyone else read this? I would love to hear your thoughts on it. It certainly made me think differently about the people of Palestine.



When was it sent out? Why don't you give me your address and I'll send you another copy just in case. I'd rather be safe than sorry. Have a great day.

Michelle


Lynda, yes I read this book from start to finish this past saturday. I love historical fiction, and this book was sent to me ( thanks Michelle)right after I completed reading The Book Thief. So it felt like a continuation of sorts. The story follows a logical pattern, from childhood to adulthood of the protagonist. Its very credible, and unlike the Kite Runner, did not present Arabs as a backward people. I like a book that has characters with redeeming qualities, and which does not force me to suspend belief/reality. I hope the the author writes a folowup from the eyes of an Israeli boy.

Without being too political, I had an aha moment when i read your comment
" it certainly made me think differently about the people of Palestine". In my view, all people should have a land to call their home country...to identify themselves...to be. When that is threatened, things go sideways. But there many sides to the Middle East story :)

Michelle presented one side in this powerful novel..I anxioulsy await her other take.

11232952
Becky I read Almond Tree and The Book Thief together also and enjoyed the different perspectives
Nov 20, 2013 07:33PM · flag

The author really does attempt to put the reader in all shoes so as to see all sides. I think for me, even though the book was filled with sadness and despair, there was a feeling of hope that kept radiating throughout.


Casey (last edited May 29, 2013 03:15PM ) May 29, 2013 03:14PM   0 votes
I received my free copy from the giveaway and was so glad I got the opportunity to read it! It was very intense and I found myself unable to put it down. Unfortunately, obligations like silly jobs kept me from reading it in a day :P. But I found it provocative and gave me an insight into a harsh life that I might otherwise not see. I think it is a great book and would recommend it to any of my friends. Definitely an eye opening read.


I got the book as a give away. I could not put it down & plan to share with friends. I kept telling my kids how Blessed we are. Sleeping in a tent was not a fun option for these families, or eating rice & almonds for dinner. Awesome job. Thanks Michelle


I really liked this book, got me thinking!!


Yes, read it - from my review (see below)
I was curious although sceptical of The Almond Tree. But I finished it and can safely say that I liked it. The author tackles a difficult subject and does it quite well. If indeed the events described in the book reflect the reality in this part of the world, we have a thing or two to seriously think about and we need to be more vocal, more active on the issues.
Very well written, I was immediately taken into the story. It became a bit ... long but still interesting as the perspectives change.
A great read and very good first novel.


I got this book The Almond Tree as a giveaway and like others have commented makes me view the Palestinian people differently, especially those who are caught in the middle of this conflict. Very well written and sobering to read about these type of events.


I wanted to read this book when I read the description and was lucky enough to receive it on a Goodreads giveaway. It has one of the most harrowing beginnings I have ever read in a book--I remember thinking to myself--is the author really going to do that to us, and at the beginning of the book? Little did I know, more of that was to follow. The notes say that the author has been carrying around the seeds of this story from a real-life incident and I can well imagine carrying around something similiar to the first pages of the book for a lifetime, and having to share it. I can't say I always enjoyed it, because it is so heartbreaking so much of the time, but brought it to my book club and shared it with members (one of whom has it now) because I thought it was well-written, confidently handled, and contains characters and a story that will stay with you for years. Recommend it to anyone.


The book makes you think, but do not forget, it is only one side, and that one side does not fairly present Israel's dilemma.

F 25x33
Chickenlips422 I am interested in what were the inaccuracies that you saw in the presentation of the story about Israel that made it one sided or unfair ?
Sep 24, 2013 04:15PM

Catherine (last edited Sep 24, 2013 07:42AM ) Jun 23, 2013 02:58PM   0 votes
I read this book which I won through the First Reads program on Goodreads. I would have never picked it up on my own, so I am very glad I did win a copy. I found The Almond Tree very hard to put down, as the story kept me on the edge of my seat. The story educated me about the Mideast,an area I have never had much interest. The characters will always stay with me and teachings of the father to his son were not lost on me. I think this is perhaps one of my favorite books. 5 Stars from me!


I received it as a giveaway and just finished it this week.

I loved it, you can see what I thought on my blog http://wwww.toodlesbookclub.blogspot.com

kay


This was one of the best books I ever read. Very well written and not a boring moment.


it is a good book to recommend to public .the word used is quick easy to understand


I was lucky enough to get this book in a giveaway. I think it is excellent -- well written and provides an enlightening perspective on a major question about humanity. For sure read it


I read and loved the book Lynda, and it led me to do some research on Corasanti, and the inspiration for the book. Having done this, I've discovered that the book is much more than Novel, despite being such a fine example of one, but is instead a plea for fairer treatment of the palestinian people, and an attempt to redress the occidental view of Palestine and its people
Read It mate, It's well worth it; if you do I'll bet that you'll be back on here commenting on how much you loved it.


Lynda, yes I read this with book from start to finish this past saturday. I love historical fiction, and this book was sent to me ( thanks Michelle)right after I completed reading The Book Thief. So it felt like a continuation of sorts. The story follows a logical pattern, from childhood to adulthood of the protagonist. Its very credible, and unlike the Kite Runner, did not present Arabs as a backward people. I like a book that has characters with redeeming qualities, and which does not force me to suspend belief/reality. I hope the the author writes a folowup from the eyes of an Israeli boy.

Without being too political, I had an aha moment when i read your comment
" it certainly made me think differently about the people of Palestine". In my view, all people should have a land to call their home country...to identify themselves...to be. When that is threatened, things go sideways. But there many sides to the Middle East story :)

Michelle presented one side in this powerful novel..I anxioulsy await her other take.


I'm still waiting for my giveaway copy.
Is it good?
What do you think about it?


I read The Almond Tree in January, and it stays with me still. It's a brutal and heartbreaking read at times but I would recommend it to anyone. Amazing book!


I haven't recieved it till now.. :'(... *sniff*


back to top