Harry Potter discussion

316 views
Characters > Voldemort or Umbridge?

Comments Showing 51-66 of 66 (66 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by LiMaB (new)

LiMaB I have to agree with a few people on here. I loathe Umbridge much more. Voldemort never was secretive about his plans, his evilness. Umbridge on the other hand is scarier in my opinion. She is someone who fakes being nice, who would be perfectly fine in the eye of many people. You would only see her true self if you spend a lot of time with her, or if you are hated by her. People like that make me feel uncomfortable. I would rather have an amazingly evil character who is quite open about it than the pink creature from hell that came in form of Dolores!


message 52: by Bianca (new)

Bianca I think Voldemort is more evil. But at least he was honest about it. You knew what you could expect. Umbridge hid her evilness and you never really knew what she was up to. And that's why I despised her more.


message 53: by Jojobean (new)

Jojobean Umbridge hands down. At least you know voldemort hates you


message 54: by Kaitlin (new)

Kaitlin | 8 comments Umbridge, hands down.


message 55: by Gabby (new)

Gabby | 31 comments Umbrigde


message 56: by Majo (new)

Majo 2411 | 20 comments Voldemort forever because Umbridge is a b**ch


message 57: by Kaitie Reads (new)

Kaitie Reads  (kaitiereads) 100% Umbridge. She was vile.


message 58: by Shania (new)

Shania .V | 1 comments I want to say Umbridge yet Voldy got a bit Moldy because of his father and guess how that turned out. (hint: A lot of dead people)


message 59: by Tiffany (new)

Tiffany Farfan | 1 comments As to who I hate more: Umbridge. She represents an oppressive government that is at root the true cause of issues within society. The ones who keep their hatred secret and when in power abuse it completely and are willing to turn a blind eye to things that don't go with their POV. At least with Voldemort you know you're getting a murderous psychopath. Umbridge is much harder to take down because taking her down doesn't eliminate the true problem which is much scarier in the long run.

Who I'd rather face in battle: Umbridge 😅 At least I'd have a chance against her. Voldemort would murder me in an instant.


message 60: by MJ (new)

MJ  | 25 comments Umbridge was way worse, and in my opinion, she had more depth. However, Voldemort had a crazy backstory that I really adore.


message 61: by Chase (new)

Chase Cummings | 11 comments Voldemort. Umbridge is so so so so so so so bad! I kind of like Voldemort.


message 62: by Chris (new)

Chris Parker | 3 comments You can find people like Voldemort and Umbridge in the real world. However, Voldemort was fascinating to watch and hear. Umbridge was too close to real life.

And people will say, "Well, she didn't murder anyone." Umm...did these people forget that she had Harry attacked by Dementors? And didn't she abuse the students? AND didn't she have Hagrid attacked too?

I'm sure, if she could get away with it, she would murder people with her own wand.


message 63: by Katharine (new)

Katharine Vann (katharinevann) | 5 comments Voldemort was better. He had more backstory than Umbridge. She was just evil and annoying.


message 64: by [deleted user] (new)

Voldemort. Umbridge is just.. 😬 at least i would die fast i guess. lol!


message 65: by [deleted user] (new)

Yasmin wrote: "Umbridge is the devil just because she fakes being nice. Add up to your malice, woman! Voldemort is honest about how much he wants to kill Harry. Plus, he always waits to try after exams so Harry c..." Aww such a sweetie!


message 66: by Ruthie (new)

Ruthie | 20 comments I don’t like either of them but I can’t stand Umbridge. I don’t really know why but I just found her so deceiving and annoying. Voldemort’s backstory gives him a little explanation for why he’s evil but Umbridge is just plain nasty for no known reason.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top