YA Buddy Readers' Corner ♥ discussion
GETTING TO KNOW YOU! :)
>
Random Share/Random Chat
If you have to choose, would you pick a good story with a bad writer or a bad story with a good writer? I've been thinking about this, has anyone considered it?
I think I'd give the good writer with the bad story a chance because I tried it the other way round and I just couldn't xD
What do you guys think?
Yeah, I'd go with good story, bad writer as well.To be honest, the first Harry Potter book.... Was it really that well written? I'm not saying it was bad, but it wasn't great either... That's just one example. Also, the writer can always improve, which Rowling is a good example of :P Haha
I don't know, maybe you guys are right. The thing is I really loved the ideas of books like Shiver, Shatter Me and Obsidian but the characters annoyed the hell out of me and at times the story itself got weird or stupid. But on the other hand, books like Hopeless, Crash, The Fault in Our Stars and The Hunger Games are not books I would pick up on my own because I didn't like the premise very much. I ended up liking all of them. So, I don't know if it's a matter of bad writers or I just don't know what's good for me xD
Every time i've read a bad book, which had good writing, it seems to have made the book drag more, because everything is described in more detail.
Abbie wrote: "Every time i've read a bad book, which had good writing, it seems to have made the book drag more, because everything is described in more detail."I hate that. I don't think it's necessarily "good" to describe every single thing. My favorite books are mostly shorter and more succinct. I read Daughter of Smoke & Bone because Laini Taylor is supposed to be such a great writer but I ended up hating the way it was written and didn't "love" it but fought my way till the second book which I absolutely hated :\
Abbie wrote: "Every time i've read a bad book, which had good writing, it seems to have made the book drag more, because everything is described in more detail."Agreed!
I read this one -
formatting and writing was absolutely awful, but the story was actully pretty good!
formatting and writing was absolutely awful, but the story was actully pretty good!
Good writter, bad story all the way. For exemple, I love the idea of most Jennifer l Armentrout and Abbi Glines's book(except the Vincent boys), but the writting in their books just keep me from enjoying the story. But I have to say, to me the author'S ability to writte interesting and complex character is a part of their writting and often to me the problem is in the characters. I could read an entire series with interesting characters even if I hate the storyline.
Mira wrote: "Abbie wrote: " I read Daughter of Smoke & Bone because Laini Taylor is supposed to be such a great writer but I ended up hating the way it was written and didn't "love" it but fought my way till the second book which I absolutely hated "I thought it was only me! I liked Daughter of smoke and bones after I was done with about 55% (or more, I don't really remember), but before that, I was seriously considering a DNF. I still haven't started the second book.
I hate Abbi Glines! All those amazing plots are wasted on her! I have yet to see a character that she wrote aren't wooden.
I vote for good writer, bad story. AT least I can stomach those.
Marie wrote: "Good writter, bad story all the way. For exemple, I love the idea of most Jennifer l Armentrout and Abbi Glines's book(except the Vincent boys), but the writting in their books just keep me from en..."Yes! Exactly! I think my main issue is in fact the characters. Characters make or break the story. You know I think this might have been my issue all along and I just didn't phrase it well. Thanks for doing that by the way xD I totally agree that if the characters are interesting, the book is interesting even if the story line is crap.
Samia wrote: "I thought it was only me! I liked Daughter of smoke and bones after I was done with about 55% (or more, I don't really remember), but before that, I was seriously considering a DNF. I still haven't started the second book..."Hahaha oh my god, I totally thought that too xD Everybody was raving about how great the writing of Daughter of Smoke and Bone is, and here I was trying to finish it like it was homework or something. I kind of liked the characters (which kept me going: Marie's point) but I wasn't a fan of the writing or the many many details or the multiple view points of characters I don't care about (that actually was in Days of Blood & Starlight not Daughter of Smoke and Bone though).
I loved the first half of daughter of smoke and bone, but the second half just confused the hell out of me! I had no clue what was going on!
@Abbie + @Sarah You guys didn't like it too? Haha x'D I thought you'd like it because you wouldn't really care how it was, you know, considering you read like lightening bolts :P
I read it ages ago, when I couldn't read so fast. i think it took me a couple of days and i was so confused! i am tempted to try it again though! especially as all three books are out now ☺
When you couldn't read so fast, it took you a couple of days? It took me a week to finish it xD You know I don't think really hated it so much when I read it, the second book really drove it home though xD
I think the second one would drive me bonkers. Book one was bad enough, it doesn't need middle book syndrome thrown on top of that!
Sarah wrote: "ah, maybe that's it then, I've heard the second one was the worst one."I started reading it so looooooong ago. But it seems so big and has so many pointless descriptions and the story seems like it goes round and round and I have yet to find the courage (and patience) to try and finish it.
Inês wrote: "Sarah wrote: "ah, maybe that's it then, I've heard the second one was the worst one."
I started reading it so looooooong ago. But it seems so big and has so many pointless descriptions and the sto..."
That does not sound good!
I started reading it so looooooong ago. But it seems so big and has so many pointless descriptions and the sto..."
That does not sound good!
I've completely forgotten The unbecoming of Mara Dyer. I've read a lot of reviews and that helped. I can't remember the ending though. Would someone please write me a pm and spoil me? :P I have a buddy read on book two tomorrow haha.
I can never remember what happened in that book. I've read it twice and just cannot remember it at all!
Sarah wrote: "I can never remember what happened in that book. I've read it twice and just cannot remember it at all!"Ugh. This is always a problem to me, no matter how good or bad the book is.
... So
and
is a daily kindle deal today. But not
What's up with that?! I really want to read this series, but I won't buy them as long as I don't know whether I'll like the first book or not.
I loved it! I was mind blown at the end of it! To be honest, I can't even think too much about it, otherwise my brain would implode
Tatiana wrote: "I loved it! I was mind blown at the end of it! To be honest, I can't even think too much about it, otherwise my brain would implode"Haha I really really loved it too. But, there's just one thing (view spoiler)
Does anyone hear songs and then connect them to a story after you've read it? Like I keep listening to City of Angels by 30 seconds to Mars and all I can think is that it's perfect for the The Mortal Instruments. It is pretty much Jace. (And Will a bit from The Infernal Devices)
Does anybody want to be a co-blogger or know somebody who does? Here is a link for more info: http://wherebooksleadus.blogspot.com/...Don't worry, this isn't spam (in case you're thinking it is), Just thought this would be a good place to ask this.
@Andrea - Hmm. It's happened. Not often though.I feel weird tonight. Not sad, just kind of drained for energy. I think I'll just go to bed and try to see if I can read a little :)
So I'm reading this book
and I'm in the beginning and the MC has talked to, lets call it the love interest, for one time only and she doesn't know his name, now I'm in the part when he introduces himself lets see it.I don’t look back as Jett and I exit the bar and walk toward his car. “Also, although Laptop Guy is the name on my birth certificate, I go by Jett. It’s actually my middle name, but no one can pronounce my actual first name.”
please note the epic fail...
Now that Amazon has finally started operating in Brazil, I have to restrain myself to not buy every single book in there.
Hey everyone!
As I've had a reading slump for about two weeks, I decided that maybe what I needed was something that would push me to read more. Soooo... I decided I'd try the A Book A Week challenge! 4 books a month is quit a big deal for me as I'm a slow reader but we'll see!
As I've had a reading slump for about two weeks, I decided that maybe what I needed was something that would push me to read more. Soooo... I decided I'd try the A Book A Week challenge! 4 books a month is quit a big deal for me as I'm a slow reader but we'll see!
Andrea wrote: "Does anyone hear songs and then connect them to a story after you've read it? Like I keep listening to City of Angels by 30 seconds to Mars and all I can think is that it's perfect for the The Mort..."
I just get irritated by books which have the same name as songs,
- had the backstreet boys song stuck in my head for a week,
- linkin park,
- shoop, shoop song,
- cher, and the list goes on...
I just get irritated by books which have the same name as songs,
- had the backstreet boys song stuck in my head for a week,
- linkin park,
- shoop, shoop song,
- cher, and the list goes on...
Sarah wrote: "Good luck Alison!"
Tatiana wrote: "Good luck, Alison!"
Thank you!
Tatiana wrote: "Good luck, Alison!"
Thank you!
Books mentioned in this topic
Tales of Habib the Hoaxter: Sometimes Hoaxed, Always Good for a Laugh (other topics)Girl Against the Universe (other topics)
Vicious (other topics)
Love So Life 1 (other topics)
Skip Beat!, Vol. 1 (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Cambria Hebert (other topics)Cambria Hebert (other topics)
Laini Taylor (other topics)
J.D. Robb (other topics)
Nora Roberts (other topics)
More...






I agree! I can't believe he managed to get away with it all those times.