Fantasy Book Club discussion
General fantasy discussions
>
The Third Book In A Series
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Paul
(new)
Dec 15, 2012 06:41AM

reply
|
flag




I agree that self-contained books are good, but only if the author can make me see how it is all part of a grander story. Sometimes the author just doesn't pull that off.


What if the author had several planets with different races on which to write about?

I don't read that kind of series, as having to explain the back story again and again strikes me as poor writing. Series such as Foreigner, Raksura, Karavans, and Wars of Light and Shadow have authors that assume you are bright enough to start the series at the beginning.

I've read many series where the original is great, perfect and complete, and then the author goes back to it some time later, like it's a cash cow at that point. Asimov's later Foundation books, and Dave Duncan's Handful of Men series, weren't like this, since the original series had a flaw the authors were trying to address, but the later Well of Souls books by Chalker never appealed to me. I like it when an author ends a series with some foretelling of how the characters continue, so further books don't need to be written.
