Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (Harry Potter, #5) Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix discussion


761 views
Who did you want dead the most? Umbridge or Voldemort

Comments Showing 151-200 of 251 (251 new)    post a comment »

message 152: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa i think umbridge

i know voldermort is downright evil and cruel and bad and a cold murderer
but umbrigde was just so incredibly annoying and evil to harry and just seeing her gave me the creeps.
That stupid smile and laugh of here and just her voice, it annoyed the crap out of me and she was creepy.


message 153: by Marce (new) - rated it 5 stars

Marce Umbridge!!


Kelseyc Overall I wanted Voldemort dead but in that book....UMBRIDGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 155: by C. J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

C. J. Umbridge! >.<


message 156: by C. J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

C. J. Ruth wrote: "Well, I knew Voldemort had to last until the last book, so I wanted Umbridge to go first."

You put that exactly how I feel about it!


message 157: by Sophie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sophie Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!Umbridge!





I think I am a tad over enthusiastic about her death...


message 158: by Kenzie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kenzie umbridge otherwise there wouldnt be any more books following and there wouldn't have been a Dumbledore's army which in my opinion was a very important part of the book because then how would they try to rescue serious i thought that part sucked but it was a good part.


message 159: by Marie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Marie Hmm umbridge!


Crystal Huff M.R. wrote: "Erin wrote: "I hate the typical answer to this question, which is usually Umbridge, because I feel like there's this sexist assumption that being evil AND annoying AND female is a thousand times wo..."

Agreed!!! It has nothing to do with her sex... it has to do with her being so two faced!!! At least Voldemort didn't hide the fact that he was evil!!


message 161: by [deleted user] (new)

Isa wrote: "I didn't want both of them to die. I love evil people! But I have to choose someone, so I choose Umbridge. I don't like the color pink."
ha ha me neither.


message 162: by Ash (new)

Ash Honestly, Umbridge annoyed me way more than Voldemort ever did. I at least respected Voldemort for his fervor to gain power, and his sarcastic courtesy. Umbridge was just awful. I hated her.


Xanderlyn Umbridge!!!!


message 164: by Dusty (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dusty umbrige


message 165: by [deleted user] (new)

Umbridge!

Wait...what happens to Umbridge? Anyone know?


message 166: by Jose (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jose Rivera Umbridge, I still hate her so much. I will do the horseshoe noise around her without thinking.


message 167: by [deleted user] (new)

Love the horseshoe noise!


Chesky_division I hated Umbridge because she was bad all on her own. She could not even use being a deatheater as an excuse. What is even scarier is I know some one exactly like her right down to the knick knacks and toil in her class room. Every student that went to school with my boys that know our real life teacher feel that Umbridge was based on her...


message 169: by [deleted user] (new)

Chesky_division wrote: "I hated Umbridge because she was bad all on her own. She could not even use being a deatheater as an excuse. What is even scarier is I know some one exactly like her right down to the knick knacks ..."
Major O.o


Aaditya Mandalemula Definitely Voldemort. I want Umbridge alive.


Esha G. Solanki Umbridge - she is so mean and cruel.. although in our daily life voldemorts are easy to identify n hated, people like umbridge escape. n thats what i hate..


Nickisha umbridge


message 173: by Bofieb (new) - rated it 3 stars

Bofieb Umbridge. Oh gosh. Umbridge.


Wonderlandsays Umbridge, Umbridge, Umbridge. A thousand times Umbridge‼


message 175: by Star (new) - rated it 5 stars

Star Fouse Umbridge!


Emma Louise Gosh, it's like you all hate Umbridge or something...
Kidding! But really, Umbridge provides a ton of hilarious dialogue and PINK! Why want that to go?


message 177: by Jen (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jen Umbridge! Voldemort was at least interesting and smart, although evil. Umbridge was dumb and annoying!


message 178: by Star (new) - rated it 5 stars

Star Fouse Hated Umbridge...


message 179: by Lily (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lily I'd have to say Umbridge, she was way too annoying...


message 180: by Jenelle (last edited Mar 15, 2013 05:40PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenelle Definitely Umbridge. I think it's because she was such a sneaky, creepy sort of evil with this "mask" of prettiness and politeness that just made her evil seem so much darker.

Voldemort is the sort of villain we love to hate. Sort of like a Darth Vader. He's powerful, evil, and plans to rule the world! He has a certain charisma and presence, and we despise his wickedness, but we also sort of love him because without him there wouldn't be anyone for Harry to stand up to, and there wouldn't be a story at all. We also know that he will get his come-uppance in the end, and we are content to wait for the end of the story before that happens.

Umbridge, on the other hand, is the sort of villain we just hate. Plain and simple, she's almost worse than Voldemort simply because she is such a tiny blip in the grand scheme of the story, and yet she somehow manages to cause so much pain and havoc and get in the way constantly. There is a frustration that her character generates within the reader that makes you desperate to climb into the book and punch her in the nose. She is cruel and unkind and yet somehow she truly believes she is on the side of good (e.g. about to use the crucio curse on Harry to get the answers she wants). A perfect characterization of a person who is sold out for the motto: "The Ends justify the Means." There is nothing about her that is even remotely appealing, and that is why we cannot devise a punishment harsh enough for her.


message 181: by Cali (new) - rated it 2 stars

Cali Umbridge pissed the hell out of me. With all her stupid pinkness and annoying hair. DIE UMBRIDGE DIE.


Victoria Margate umbridge all the way!


message 183: by Ghitte (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ghitte Umbridge


message 184: by Akash (new) - rated it 4 stars

Akash Kulgod J.K.Rowling really wrote the character of Umbridge well....i mean for everyone to hate her..:0


Deeptanshu Definitely Umbridge.


message 186: by Mariam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mariam Umbridge...she topped the scale of cruel..........not far off from voldemort in my opinion


message 187: by Star (new) - rated it 5 stars

Star Fouse Calsi wrote: "Umbridge pissed the hell out of me. With all her stupid pinkness and annoying hair. DIE UMBRIDGE DIE."

ROFL! Well put Calsi.. well put...


message 188: by Eydís (new) - rated it 2 stars

Eydís Umbridge


message 189: by Parth (new) - rated it 4 stars

Parth Dhand Umbridge!!


message 190: by Lynx (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lynx UMBRIDGE!!!! GRRRrrrrr I hate her...


Carissa UMBRIDGE.


Shobana Elango Voldy!!


message 193: by Jayden (last edited Mar 22, 2013 07:06AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jayden Smith unbridge god if she wasn't delt with soon i was going to stop reaing the books

not to mention her whole pressence in the movie made my skin crawl


Jennifer Popescu umbridge def.


message 195: by Star (new) - rated it 5 stars

Star Fouse my HP Death list:

1. Umbridge
2. Moldy Voldy
3. Rita Skeeter


message 196: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Umbridge, wanted to do it myself


message 197: by Addie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Addie Well... This is a hard one. Well I wanted Voldemort dead because he was evil. Who doesn't want a baddie dead? And I wanted umbridge to die because she so fu*king irritating! And annoying! And girly! And controlling! And cruel! I could to on forever!!! But I'm fine with her a$$ being kicked. And for her to be a loser forever. Locked up and all. So in the end I think Voldemort because he has to die or the whole magic world will go to crumbles. Umbridge only makes a school miserable, not destroy the whole world so...


message 198: by Mary (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mary Rose Umbridge, burn her with all her pink ugly stuff.


message 199: by Grace (new) - rated it 5 stars

Grace I HATE both so... I say get rid of them!


message 200: by A.R. (new) - rated it 5 stars

A.R. Dean Umbridge!


back to top