Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4) Breaking Dawn discussion


270 views
Jacob and Renesmee

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re I thought I was done with the Twilight Series. I loved it, read the books atleast 5 times each, been there done that. But, the last scene in the movie (Breaking Dawn Part 2)REALLY moved me. I want to see the life of Renesmee and Jacob played out in a book, maybe a novella. I loved the movie, 1st time EVER a movie knocked the socks off a book for me. Well done Stephanie. I want more of Jacob and Renesmee. Am I the only one?


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

Noo!!!!! I think there needs to be a book about Jacob and Rensemee too. I just want to know what happen when Jacob till her about all the stuff between him and her mom. I also want to be there for there first kiss. I just really want more of Jacob and Rensemee so mad.


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah I never really like Jacob until he imprinted on Rensemee.


Libbie I couldn't agree more. That one flash scene at the very end when a grown Renesmee puts her head on his shoulder and his head leans in towards hers...utterly slayed me.

I've loved the idea of these two since the book came out...so much so, I wrote an entire fanfiction that took place 7 years after Breaking Dawn ended just to see it happen.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

:P


Laura There would probably be heaps of this stuff as fanfiction.


Libbie Laura wrote: "There would probably be heaps of this stuff as fanfiction."

Not that much, no. Unless something has radically changed in the fandom since I left it, the majority of Twilight fanfictions have the characters all human. And since Renesmee is nearly universally hated in the fandom, there's very little fic that includes her.


Libbie Peace wrote: "well u never know what happens after that.."

Search of fanfiction.net found over 100,000 Twilight fics with Bella's name; 5,000 with Renesmee's name, and only 2,100 of those also included Jacob's.

This is out of over 200,000 total stories under the Twilight category.


message 9: by Liv (new) - rated it 5 stars

Liv (LivTheBookNerd) i loved the books and i loved Jacob
i do think though that Stephanie should do another novella or BOOK SERIES of Renesmee and Jacob
that would be AWESOME


Angeline Joseph let's make a group for those of us who wants to have more books added up to the series ,mostly about Jacob and renesmee.Then maybe,just maybe, we can persuade Stephanie to write more books.


Swathika Manu how many of us have persuaded her for Midnight Sun? And is she writting it? NO!


Angeline Joseph Swathika wrote: "how many of us have persuaded her for Midnight Sun? And is she writting it? NO!"
But have you ever tried constructing a group about it?


message 13: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re I know! We are all disappointed that Stephanie has not chosen to complete Midnight Sun. Sometimes though a group discussion can cause or change an outcome.We can always hope.


Taylor O'shae Abby wrote: "Noo!!!!! I think there needs to be a book about Jacob and Rensemee too. I just want to know what happen when Jacob till her about all the stuff between him and her mom. I also want to be there for ..."
I was look at some stuff there will be another book :) *YESSSS


message 15: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re That would be interesting!! I think a book focusing on the two (Jac/Ren) would be sooo good!!


message 16: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re I briefly checked it out. looks like a lot of info on the site.


VIVI  GARCIA YEAH IT WOULD BE SO INTERESTING TO READ ABOUT JAKE AND NESSIE


message 18: by Maha (last edited Dec 13, 2012 10:48PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha Believe it or not, after watching the movie I started to day-dream about the possibilities of Jacob-Renesmee pair!!!
Its really funny, but I can't stop myself!


message 19: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re Yep!! I am with you guys!! Smile!!!


message 20: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha I've been thinking the same!
Well! one-third human, one-third vampire and one-third wolf might be the possibility!!
What do you all think?


Libbie Maha wrote: "I've been thinking the same!
Well! one-third human, one-third vampire and one-third wolf might be the possibility!!
What do you all think?"


I don't think so, since Jacob isn't a wolf. He's human with a shapeshifter ability...very different.

Personally, I think any children they have would probably carry the shapeshifter gene, and probably have some of Renesmee's vampiric qualities (long life, strength, speed.)

The one to ponder is if they had a boy, would the boy be venomous? (Nahuel said that his sisters weren't, but that he changed his aunt into a vampire.) Since boys are most likely to shift to wolf form (Leah being the first female wolf in known history.) Would a boy child be able to survive a shift into wolf form - something that would definitely be triggered by his grandparents/great aunts and uncles, if the venom in his own body is poisonous?


message 22: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha well! As for the 'venom' part, I would say, NO....
'Cuz, u see, either one must have venom in this part.... since Jacob is shape-shifter and Nessie is 'Non-Venomous' half Vampire, I am pretty sure that the child would have no venom....
And as for the earlier one, I didn't say he is a werewolf, I just said wolf....


Libbie Maha wrote: "well! As for the 'venom' part, I would say, NO....
'Cuz, u see, either one must have venom in this part.... since Jacob is shape-shifter and Nessie is 'Non-Venomous' half Vampire, I am pretty sure ..."


She herself isn't venomous, but who's to say if she had a male child, he wouldn't be if he carried over her vampiric traits?

Genetics. It's all fun until you get a headache.

(And I didn't say werewolf either, because he isn't one. I was merely pointing out that the child wouldn't be one-third wolf because Jacob isn't *any* part wolf.)


message 24: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha I think I got what u said....
May be, as u say, if the gene do work in that way for a male child, it would really be fun...
A shape-shifter as well as a 'Venomous' half vampire.
That would be a critical part!


message 25: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha You mean, a part vampire, a part human and a part wolf!!!
That would be hard I guess.
The Voltori, they are not ready to accept a half-vampire-and-half-human.
If such outcome is possible, then they will dine every Cullen... :(


message 26: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha We can't be sure unless Stephanie takes a decision, I fear!


message 27: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha Yes, I am waiting for that. Pray that she writes the novel for J&R. 'Cuz, I am praying, friend!


Haley Faith hey i dont know if ya'll know this, but they are making a movie about Jacob and Renesmee, but personally i did not like how they got together.


Haley Faith it just kinda freaked me out.


Libbie Haley wrote: "hey i dont know if ya'll know this, but they are making a movie about Jacob and Renesmee, but personally i did not like how they got together."

...who is making a movie about Jake and Renesmee?


Shade' Wilkins I love Jacob and Renesmee relationship. Right now he is the protector and in the future he's the soulmate. One thing I want to know is what their baby would be like. Renesmee is a human/vampire, but imagine human/vampire/wolf.Either way the child will be so unique. There has to be another book and movie. It just has to go on.


message 32: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha Haley wrote: "hey i dont know if ya'll know this, but they are making a movie about Jacob and Renesmee, but personally i did not like how they got together."

Well! I hope what you posted is true.


message 33: by Leah (new)

Leah People say it's creepy... but you know, I think it's completely normal for an old dude werewolf to have a thing for a baby. I mean, i've read tons of books where that happens


message 34: by Re (new) - rated it 5 stars

Re Shade' wrote: "I love Jacob and Renesmee relationship. Right now he is the protector and in the future he's the soulmate. One thing I want to know is what their baby would be like. Renesmee is a human/vampire, bu..."

I know, it really does sound cool. But, will Stephanie be willing to accomodate our desire to see Jacob and Renessmee in a book? We are her fans, and I hope so, but I do not have great expectations. I would prefer a book as opposed to a movie, (but my favorite would be both) because in a book the dialogue can be great, due to no constraints on time.


message 35: by [deleted user] (last edited Jan 01, 2013 10:46PM) (new)

Peace wrote: "just a thought i wonder what would everyone think about ren and jake kid, would look like, when its get older.?"

It'd probably be the most unbelievably adorable kid you've ever seen. And the prettiest/handsomest person around.


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

Truetrue.


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

How do you know they can even HAVE kids?


Donna i want there to be a movie about them, and i wanna see when and how wolf boy tells Nessy about him and her mother. also about how her dad and him hated each other and at one point wished each other dead. that's a WTF moment


Rebecca First, I thought the whole thing between Jacob and Renesmee was cute, but I changed my mind.. I just find it disturbing. Jacob stops growing, right? So he can wait for Renesmee.. But even if he doesn't grow in body, he'll grow in mind. So he will always be mentally older then her.
Still... I think his relationship with Renesmee is healthier than Bellas and Edwards.. But that's just my opinion ^^"


Melina I want a new book and movie!!


Shade' Wilkins Re wrote: "Shade' wrote: "I love Jacob and Renesmee relationship. Right now he is the protector and in the future he's the soulmate. One thing I want to know is what their baby would be like. Renesmee is a hu..."

well, i saw an interview where she was saying she's just taking a break for now. Because the series is so great she may just think of her fans. Also, if there was another movie she would have to see if the same actors would be willing to do it all over again, because it would be very disappointing to finish with different actors. :) my fingers are crossed


Shade' Wilkins Peace wrote: "Shade' wrote: "I love Jacob and Renesmee relationship. Right now he is the protector and in the future he's the soulmate. One thing I want to know is what their baby would be like. Renesmee is a hu..."

:) hope so


message 43: by Maha (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maha Peace wrote: "i wonder if sm will write a shot story about them somwhere?"
My opinion is that a novella is not enough for Jacob and Renesmee


message 44: by Kate (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kate i thought about them hating each other's scent! hahaha but i want to see more of them.. what about the ending? it's unfair stephenie!


back to top