Shut Up & Read discussion
Archives
>
Breaking Dawn Part II
date
newest »



I thought it was a hilarious movie! And especially when (view spoiler) The whole theater groaned and was so disappointed!
Maddison wrote: "OMG the movie was truly epic! I saw it at midnight 3 days ago, the premiere, and because my country's the first to see the sun each morning, I would have been one of the first people in the world t..."
I know!! I haven't read the last book for a reason and the reason was I wanted to be surprised. I loved that (view spoiler) i really think this was the best out of all the 4.
I saw the midnight showing as well and it wasnt as crowded as I thought from the previous twilight movies I've been too.
I know!! I haven't read the last book for a reason and the reason was I wanted to be surprised. I loved that (view spoiler) i really think this was the best out of all the 4.
I saw the midnight showing as well and it wasnt as crowded as I thought from the previous twilight movies I've been too.


The movie was different from the book. It's too bad because up until this point they've stayed pretty close to the books, with a few exceptions. I don't know why they would change that now. Ratings I guess.

Sheri wrote: "The movie was different from the book. It's too bad because up until this point they've stayed pretty close to the books, with a few exceptions. I don't know why they would change that now. Rati..."
Well, I haven't read breaking dawn but I heard there was a twist and I saw an interview with stephany Meyer and they asked her is this going to be the end of Bella and Edward and she said for now......I'm taking a break. So my guess is there is going to be another movie hence the left opened ending.
Well, I haven't read breaking dawn but I heard there was a twist and I saw an interview with stephany Meyer and they asked her is this going to be the end of Bella and Edward and she said for now......I'm taking a break. So my guess is there is going to be another movie hence the left opened ending.

Until now I couldn't get over it. That unforgettable feeling. Among the four.. this was the best one.

I don't really expect movies to follow the books. I hope but I don't expect it. This movie didn't just not follow it, it changed pivotal events (like when Bella goes and gets the new identities for Nessie and Jacob). And there was no plot. Period. The entire movie could have been summed up in a single fight scene.
Sorry, I'm really trying not to rant. It seems the further I get from watching it, the worse my impression of it. Like I said, I was really looking forward to this one and am getting increasingly bummed that it was the only one I managed to see in theaters. I think I might have to avoid this discussion...






I was quite happy the way it ended.
What did you think?
Did the Director do the book justice?