Breaking Dawn
discussion
Breaking Dawn. Alice's Vision.....to Aro.
message 51:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Nov 23, 2012 11:04AM
The very end with just Edward and Bella was so beautiful. It made me cry like a baby.
reply
|
flag
OMG I'd love for there to be a sixth film and/or a fifth book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i flipped out and screamed a little then she said,"Thats your future." and laughed/shook
Jessica wrote: "OMG I'd love for there to be a sixth film and/or a fifth book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
Yeah that would be so cool. She needs to write a book about Jacob and Rensemee.
Yeah that would be so cool. She needs to write a book about Jacob and Rensemee.
For those of you questioning about the vision and the half breed and wolf...She could see it from the vamps pov. if you remember the minute Jacob tore its head off, and ran you saw them leaving but didn't follow any further. Explination: She was channeling the vamp attacking Jacob, not actually the wolf or half-breed. :)
Peace wrote: "if jake is werewolf then he must have imprint on ren she is half vamp/human type of thing. i wonder how would if they did have kids one day?"
Well, if they were to have kids the child would be 1/4 vampire, 1/4 werewolf, and 2/4 human.
Well, if they were to have kids the child would be 1/4 vampire, 1/4 werewolf, and 2/4 human.
Dawn wrote: "For those of you questioning about the vision and the half breed and wolf...She could see it from the vamps pov. if you remember the minute Jacob tore its head off, and ran you saw them leaving bu..."but even if she was channeling the vampire, she still wouldn't have been able to see anything. When Bella jumped off the cliff in New Moon, she saw her fall into the water, but she didn't see Jacob at all. That's why they thought she died.
When I saw Jane running, I was like KILL HER!!!KILL HER!!! Kill every Volturi there is for killing Carlisle, Jasper and the wolves.
Julie wrote: "When I saw Jane running, I was like KILL HER!!!KILL HER!!! Kill every Volturi there is for killing Carlisle, Jasper and the wolves."yeah omg that was my favorite part of the scene, it was my favorite good character vs. my favorite bad character. i was like, 'YOU GET HER, ALICE! FOR JASPER!" it was SO... I don't even have a word for it. amazing? intense? amazingly intense?
it was like when Molly Weasley killed Bellatrix Lestrange
Peace wrote: "so alice can only see some part, from ren but not the rest of the pack?"i'm honestly not trying to be offensive at all, i swear to god, but have you read the books? it seems like you're confused by a lot of what we're talking about. oooo have you only seen the movies? that's understandable. most of my friends have only seen the movies.
Kenzie wrote: "i flipped out and screamed a little then she said,"Thats your future." and laughed/shook"lol when i went, everyone in the theater had that reaction
I hope she surprises us all with another saga... I would love to to see Bella and Edward in their new relationship and Renesme and Jacob...Being have vampire and Human is quite a unique story...
Smeesh wrote: "Julie wrote: "When I saw Jane running, I was like KILL HER!!!KILL HER!!! Kill every Volturi there is for killing Carlisle, Jasper and the wolves."yeah omg that was my favorite part of the scene, ..."
Like when Molly killed Bellatrix! That's it! That intense feeling!
yeah, like, 'i-love-both-characters-but-DIE-BITCH' kinda thing
Donnica wrote: "I hope she surprises us all with another saga... I would love to to see Bella and Edward in their new relationship and Renesme and Jacob...Being have vampire and Human is quite a unique story..."
what about Vampire Diaries
Jessica wrote: "OMG I'd love for there to be a sixth film and/or a fifth book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"robert pattinson wouldn't lol he hates the movies
OMG I was freaking out. It was a huge plot twist even if you read the book. They all died and I was like THIS ISN'T SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN. It was awesome. I wish they had focused more on Seth and Leah in the movie though. We only got to see the back of their heads for 12 seconds. So then how would other viewers have known those wolves were Seth and Leah when they died? Still great tho. Best Twilight movie, hands down.
Darlene =) wrote: "OMG I was freaking out. It was a huge plot twist even if you read the book. They all died and I was like THIS ISN'T SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN. It was awesome. I wish they had focused more on Seth and Leah..."
Yeah I completely agree. I cried like a baby at the end when Bella shared she memories with Edward. It was so beautiful.
Yeah I completely agree. I cried like a baby at the end when Bella shared she memories with Edward. It was so beautiful.
i love the parts at the end of part one and part two when it goes through bella's memories. and i like how they incorperated the actual book in it as well, when they showed the last sentence in the book, and also all the names
I started freaking out as soon as Carlise died, I started screaming "THIS WAS NOT IN THE BOOK,YOU BASTARDS" When Jasper died I was on the verge of tears but trying to hold myself toegether becaus I was in Public. The when Seth died I busted into tears & started sobbing along with my best friend. We just sat there crying & holding each other.
Smeesh wrote: "yeah, like, 'i-love-both-characters-but-DIE-BITCH' kinda thing"I mean, Bellatrix was always just so cool, with her evil laughing, long nails, and the corset-thing, but she DESERVED TO DIE!!!
Ditto Jane, with her cool red eyes, the little figure, small hands, and that angelic expression.
oh, really? strange... did you not stay to the end of the movie? it was a part of the last scene.
Peace wrote: "it very tragic when it was going go bad but it was all just vison that alice had, sigh of releaf that it wasnt going to happen.."When I found out it was fake I was stunned then I let out some relief laughter
Peace wrote: "i saw how they made it. it was all in the inside, when they film the battle part.."what do you mean by 'inside'? like, inside information? or do you mean it was filmed indoors? because that usually happens with movies.
Yeh I think thats what she means, inside in a "green room" set. And yes, that does usually happen with movies. :)
yeah, most of the time twilight is shot indoors. in eclipse, when they're on the mountain, you can actually see the green walls xD
really?!! I'll have to remember to look for that the next time I watch it!!
Селеста wrote: "So you watched the movie. And i might add, i did scream when they killed Jasper, and when Seth died. And I cried when lea died, and...and..and. I also screamed when Carlisle when after Alice and he..."That part did happen in the book. Page 738, It's on her blog
Селеста wrote: "So you watched the movie. And i might add, i did scream when they killed Jasper, and when Seth died. And I cried when lea died, and...and..and. I also screamed when Carlisle when after Alice and he..."That part did happen in the book. Page 738, It's on her blog
Haidi wrote: "really?!! I'll have to remember to look for that the next time I watch it!!"well, you can see outlines, which is basically the same thing. it so obvious that it's a green screen. which doesn't stop Eclipse from being my favorite book, but still.
...james? that was waaaay back when- like, 2008 or something. lol did you mean jasper? i was freaking out SO MUCH in the theater. i was sort of in denial, and i wasn't fully comprehending the deaths. i was just sort of in shock, frozen.
before watching the movies, I heared rumours about how the filmmaker didn't ended up the film the way the book is, that they made it different from the book. so when i finally watch it and see the Carlisle-unheaded scene, I just like, oh, so the rumour IS TRUE, and then Jasper die, and Seth, and Leah, and then I was like, okaaaayyy, how much are they will make it different anyway?? and then turns out that it was just Alice's vision, and I feel like I've been deceived.
hey so i noticed an error with this whole vision alice had. Alice CANNOT WEREWOLVES IN HER VISIONS! So how was she able 2 see Seth and Leah and stuff? Doesn't make any sense.
that's what we've been trying to figure out in these 3 pages of comments
Peace wrote: "later on i realised it was only just dream."*vision
Chasta wrote: "So, my girlfriends and I all went to see the new Twilight movie like we always do. It has become more of a reason just to get together over the years rather than a love of the movies. We are fans o..."I am so glad someone brought this up. I have been frustrated by it all. How all of a sudden she can see the wolves and reneesmee. That part confused the heck out of me. Even in the books she has never been able to see them. A definite goof on the directors part. I still loved the movie though.
i think Alice still can't see Renesmee and werewolves, but for the sake of the movie, I dont think it'll gonna looks good on scene, because Jacob has already said that the pact will join the fight, and indeed they've shown in the field, so if the battle begin and then Renesmee and the werewolves suddenly dissapear, it will totally looks weird and confusing, and clearly we will realise that it's just Alice vision, so it wont be suprising anymore
Afifah wrote: "i think Alice still can't see Renesmee and werewolves, but for the sake of the movie, I dont think it'll gonna looks good on scene, because Jacob has already said that the pact will join the fight,..."lol exactly: can't we just enjoy the movie, without getting mad at the people who made the movie? (lol no, this is Goodreads, remember?)
In regards to Alice's vision in Breaking Dawn Part 2 and her not being able to see wolves, I think that the only explanation for it is that Alice doesn't show Aro what we see in the movie. She probably mostly shows some of the fight (the parts that she is able to see with only vampires) and she ultimately shows Aro getting killed. Us seeing the wolves is just showing what really would've happened even though Alice can't see this herself, but I think the main gist of what I'm trying to say is that Alice only shows Aro the vampire stuff. Not the werewolf stuff. And everything else that we saw in the movie was just us getting to see what could have been.
Smeesh wrote: "Afifah wrote: "i think Alice still can't see Renesmee and werewolves, but for the sake of the movie, I dont think it'll gonna looks good on scene, because Jacob has already said that the pact will ..."yeaaaa,why bother arguing about something that doesn't really have a major effect to the movie?? just enjoy it
Селеста wrote: "So you watched the movie. And i might add, i did scream when they killed Jasper, and when Seth died. And I cried when lea died, and...and..and. I also screamed when Carlisle when after Alice and he..."YOU DEFINITELY NEED TO WRITE SPOILERS ON THE HEADING BECAUSE YOU JUST RUINED THE MOVIE FOR ME BECAUSE I READ YOUR DISCUSSION BEFORE I SAW IT! You shouldn't just assume that because someone has Breaking Dawn on one of their bookshelves that they've already seen the movie. It's quite insensitive and selfish.
WOW, looks like someone just got pissed off, LOL. Hmm, I think the fact that Селеста put a big picture of Aro at the beginning of the post is clearly point that this post wasn't about the books.
Dear Laura:We are sorry. Next time, look at the title, and if it's about something you haven't read/seen, don't click it.
Smeesh wrote: "Dear Laura:We are sorry. Next time, look at the title, and if it's about something you haven't read/seen, don't click it."
hear...hear...
but if we haven't read/seen it, it probably just make us more curious about the topic isn't it? hehehehh
s'called Hollywood, hun. They needed a fight scene for the movie, or else it wouldn't be interesting. I thought it was actually pretty clever, to make it Alice's vision. Wait, um... are you saying that movies shouldn't make you feel strong emotions? I have no comment.
Afifah wrote: "Smeesh wrote: "Dear Laura:We are sorry. Next time, look at the title, and if it's about something you haven't read/seen, don't click it."
hear...hear...
but if we haven't read/seen it, it probably..."
well, if the person was curious, it's their own fault, then. Curiosity killed... the, um, reader.
Smeesh wrote: "Afifah wrote: "Smeesh wrote: "Dear Laura:We are sorry. Next time, look at the title, and if it's about something you haven't read/seen, don't click it."
hear...hear...
but if we haven't read/seen ..."
Actually the cat was killed by the boy next door with the microwave, not curiosity. JUST KIDDING. lol. I knew prior to opening this thread that it was a SPOILER and I saw the thread in the discussion section, before I saw the movie. Therefore I knew if I opened it I was going to read spoilers, so I didn't. I waited until I saw it. Also if you have read the book you know Alice didn't have a vision she showed TO Aro. That was just in the movie.
exactly. do spoilers even count for movies? i guess so, but they aren't the same.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
