A Fractured Light (A Beautiful Dark, #2) A Fractured Light discussion


62 views
Asher or Devin?

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cat No, I don't want you to tell me who you like better, because then this will turn into a fan girl war of OMIGOD! Jacob VS. Edward, Peeta VS. Gale, Alex VS. Julian. . . blah, blah, blah.

What I do want to know is what everyone thinks about Skye's final decision. Obviously, she's a mix of the light and dark, so in the end, do you think she'll pick Asher, Devin, or reject both of them? Who she'll pick, not who you want her to pick...


message 2: by Cat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cat Vyshu wrote: "i actually think she will either be alone or find someone else. at the end of the first book, i was sure it was gonna be asher, but then she broke up with him and i really don't think they'll get b..."

Really? That's sad. I thought she'd eventually end up with Devin for some reason, because even though she loved Asher, throughout the series, she kept feeling attracted to Devin even when he'd tried to kill her and etc.


Lissa I think she will pick Asher. In most books it's usually the guy who she's attracted to first or who she's with first, and then something happens and they "break up" or something happens that keeps them apart and then they're back together. In this book I think something might happen with Skye and Ian, but nothing serious. I still think she will go back to Asher in the end. As for Devin I think she's only attracted to him, but that's it nothing more. She might love him too but not as much as Asher.


Heather Williams I may be on my own here but I don't think she'll end up with Asher or Devin or end up alone. I think she'll end up with Ian. It just seems like there's more to him than just the friend who's always had feelings for her. Maybe he's a rouge too, idk. But there's something more there.


Darkphoenix I would prefer if she either ended up with someone new or Ian since both Asher and Devin wanted her with ulterior motives (fight with us and help us win the war and blah blah) it will be nice to see her with someone who wants her and not her powers.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

i don't like either of them that much. Devin is too...well aloof. he's like a lost puppy. Asher is like the party guy at school, and neither of them actually love skye. They just want her powers. i hope there's a new guy in the series or something cuz neither of them seem fitting. :/


message 7: by Cat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cat Honestly, I've read waaaaaaaay too many love triangle young adult fiction book is have a good grip on this!


back to top