Colin or Luc?

[Veronica]

colin :P

[Ferdy]

Colin..I hated Luc for so many reasons.

[Ferdy]

Nicole wrote: "okay, I have to ask why do you hate soo much?"

I hate Luc because I'm not convinced that he loves Mo, he only wants her because she took over Verity's destiny and all he cares about is his destiny with the 'vessel'.. so if Verity hadn't died he wouldn't have looked twice at Mo, he would have been happy with Verity.

More longer and spoilery answer (there's spoilers from all 3 books in my answer..so if you've not read the other two, you might not want to read it) :D

(view spoiler)[ 1. Luc used to date Mo's dead best friend, Verity, they were actually meant to get married. Mo's just second best.
2. Mo being with Luc was huge a betrayal to Verity, she knew how much Verity loved Luc but she didn't respect Verity enough to not date him.
3. If Verity hadn't died, Luc would never have even been interested in Mo.
4. The only reason Luc wanted Mo was because Mo happened to inherit Verity's destiny. He didn't choose Mo, if someone else had gotten Verity's powers he would have been all over them.
5. Luc set Mo up to die in the 2nd book because it was what the council wanted..he didn't care that Mo would be harmed and could be killed. He claimed to love her yet he still orchestrated events so that Mo would have to sacrifice herself for magic. And Mo just brushed him almost killing her under the carpet. What happens the next time he's asked to put her in danger for magics sake? Love didn't stop him last time so why would it stop him again? He'd just throw her to the wolves again.
6. Luc kept choosing his magical duties over Mo.
7. I wasn't convinced of Luc's love for Mo at all — he just wanted her because they were 'bound' together.

I was also disappointed that Luc's relationship with Verity and Niobe wasn't really cleared up. Did Luc love Verity? How serious was he about her? Did he only date Verity because it was destined or did he have genuine feelings? Did he used to have a thing for Niobe?
I just find Luc to be very slimy and manipulative..he's good with words but his actions towards Mo paint a very different picture from what he claims to feel for her. (hide spoiler)]

[Veronica]

agree with Ferdy. I don't like luc either. he regards Mo as an object and does not really love her like Colin does.