Mockingjay
discussion
who do u think killed prim
date
newest »
newest »
Betty wrote: "On the day the Capitol fell, did Coin know who Prim was?"As several people have rightly pointed out, Coin and Snow probably both knew about Prim being Katniss' sisterfrom the reaping at the start of Book #1. That was a goof on my part. I apologize.
its coin for sure that bitch
I still don't understand how Prim died. Can anyone please explain?:)
Tabitha wrote: "I still don't understand how Prim died. Can anyone please explain?:)"She got blown up
It was gale,didnt you read it?
Gale did because he was working on the bombs. Plus I just hate Gale. TEAM PEETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mockingjay11 wrote: "Gale did because he was working on the bombs. Plus I just hate Gale. TEAM PEETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Hey, I'm team Peeta, but it's so unreasonable to blame Gale. Does that mean that Snow wasn't responsible for Peeta's Hijacking? Does that mean that if I shoot someone, it's not me who killed him, it's the person who made the gun?
Hey Sheechiibii read the book again, Katniss said that Gale was on the hovercraft that killed Prim. Get your facts straight angel face.
Mockingjay11 wrote: "Hey Sheechiibii read the book again, Katniss said that Gale was on the hovercraft that killed Prim. Get your facts straight angel face."I think you should read the book again angel face. It does not say anything like that.
Yes it does I've read it 5 freaking times. Read the the last chapters again. I know what I'm talking about smart aleck
The Author killed her off.
Mockingjay11 wrote: "Yes it does I've read it 5 freaking times. Read the the last chapters again. I know what I'm talking about smart aleck"Obviously you don't know what you're talking about. It' does not say anything about Gale being on the hover craft. It doesn't say anything about who was on that hovercraft.
Seriously, read it again.
Mockingjay11 wrote: "Yes it does I've read it 5 freaking times. Read the the last chapters again. I know what I'm talking about smart aleck"Obviously you've misread it. Katniss doesn't know who was on the aicraft, she never even mentions who might have been on it. The only time she mentions Gale in connection to Prim's death is how he created the bomb. How could Gale possibly have been on that aircraft when he was with Katniss in the city?
Sheechiibii wrote: "Mockingjay11 wrote: "Yes it does I've read it 5 freaking times. Read the the last chapters again. I know what I'm talking about smart aleck"Obviously you've misread it. Katniss doesn't know who w..."
Actually i don't think he was with her at the time of the bombing. I think the peacekeepers took him before that.
Coin it was to convince her to vote for her as president or something after the war. It was gale's trap but coin used it and put a 14 year old girl who happened to be Katniss' sister on the from line. Is it not obvious enough?
I'm not going to argue anymore, believe what you want to believe.
To be honest, the whole book was an assault on my intelligence. It was forced and defied all logic and character building thus far. One thing that did not stand out like a sore thumb though was exactly Gale's involvement in Prim's death. When I first picked up HG, I instantly took a dislike to Gale (ever prior to Peeta's introduction) due to his rather ridiculous almost Trotskovite tendencies. This impression intensified as the series went on. I actually thing it was a rather logical conclusion for him.
I agree so much with you on Gale, Vita.
Mockingjay11 wrote: "I'm not going to argue anymore, believe what you want to believe."I'll believe what was actually said in the book.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
What I meant was that poisoning Prim would be obvious murder from inside District 13. Whereas with the aircraft crew (which really could be only 1 person) they framed the Capitol, so the crew blabbing is highly unlikely to happen since it would mean them admitting to killing their own people.