The Rory Gilmore Book Club discussion

5193 views
Gilmore Girls Discussions > Dean, Jess or Logan?

Comments Showing 651-700 of 703 (703 new)    post a comment »

message 651: by Nicole (new)

Nicole | 2 comments jess <3


message 652: by Laila (new)

Laila | 1 comments i love both jess and logan but i’m team logan. i loved grown up jess tho


Romy ˚୨୧⋆。˚ | 1 comments team Jess


message 654: by Disha (new)

Disha | 2 comments can I say Tristan???????


message 655: by Disha (new)

Disha | 2 comments if not then I'll settle for Jess!


message 656: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Pacaud (chermama30) Jess. I named my puppy Milo to show how much I love Milo Ventimiglia!


message 657: by cassandra (new)

cassandra logan 💗💗


message 658: by Jazz (new)

Jazz | 8 comments Team Jess his character development was amazing 👏
But I also Stan Logan and his friends they were amazing 🥹


message 659: by Isabeau (new)

Isabeau | 3 comments LOGAN


message 660: by Gina (new)

Gina (ginamusg95) | 2 comments Logan !!!


message 661: by Wiktoria_ak (new)

Wiktoria_ak | 1 comments idk jess and 1s dean


message 662: by Eva (new)

Eva Parente | 1 comments Jess hands down, unpopular opinion but I hated Logan lol


message 663: by esther (new)

esther (esther469) | 1 comments Definitely team Logan! He helped Rory live more and have more fun. He treated her so well! I know he made some mistakes, but so does everyone, right? I honestly think he was a good guy for her.


message 664: by Christina ♡ (new)

Christina ♡ (too_many_choices) Dean. Jess was okay, but Logan was an insufferable jerk. Can't stand him.


message 665: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (echo_books34) Jess !!


message 666: by Daniela °° (new)

Daniela °° | 1 comments LOGAN!!!! he treated rory so well and was always supportive. jess started acting like a jerk once they actually started dating and dean was controlling


message 667: by Maria (new)

Maria Mateus (_mariamateus_) | 1 comments Team Jess 100%!
Also Tristan had soo much potential!


message 668: by gaiet ☆ (new)

gaiet ☆ | 2 comments OMG JESS!!!🫶🏻🫶🏻


message 669: by Jazz (new)

Jazz | 8 comments What bout Tristan I was here for a enemies to lovers 💀😭


message 670: by mila (new)

mila | 2 comments Tristian or Jess


message 671: by Julie (new)

Julie | 1 comments Team Jess !!! I loved Logan but he wasn’t the perfect match for Rory and Dean was overall not that great with his girlfriends


message 672: by abigail (new)

abigail def Logan, Jess didn't treat her right I think


message 673: by Daphne (new)

Daphne Jess.
but Tristan had tons of potential


message 674: by Minka (new)

Minka | 3 comments Logan


message 675: by madi (new)

madi | 1 comments jess had his issues sure, but that character arc??? besides, he was the only one of them that really knew and understood rory, at least pre-season 6. unbeatable. team jess ftw.


message 676: by Ivy (new)

Ivy | 2 comments Literally Logan allll the way 🤭


message 677: by 13krista123 (new)

13krista123 | 3 comments Jess had so much personality and character development


message 678: by Helen (new)

Helen | 1 comments jess forever and always!!


message 679: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Runda literally team jess 100%

jess loved and cared for her the most. he was just with rory at the WRONG TIME while he was extremely vulnerable and sad. but jess and rory immediately clicked and i’m still convinced they’re both still in love.

dean was.. dean. he was so obsessive over rory, he didn’t let her breathe. and he was so insecure about her and jess which shows it all. he’s a horrible man and what he and rory did while he was STILL MARRIED is unbelievable. he manipulated rory into sleeping with him and then when he came home after doing it, he treated his wife lindsey badly.

i have nothing to say about logan. he was the person she didn’t need. but then again, he was the person who was there for her, and he supported her even when she was in the wrong.


aurora (taylor's version) | 5 comments Team Jess!!


cas ❤︎₊ ⊹౨ৎ | 1 comments Team Jess 🫶🏼


message 682: by Minka (new)

Minka | 3 comments Logan


message 683: by duda (new)

duda logan is and always will be my choice for rory. i think they were perfect together and i loved their dynamic and how they understood each other so well.


message 684: by Susan (new)

Susan Sanchez | 1 comments Team Jess!!


message 685: by Angeliki (new)

Angeliki Pampoutzoglou (angelapampou) | 2 comments Team Jess!!


message 686: by Ashley (new)

Ashley (ashleyreads101) | 1 comments I believed all her boyfriends could be very toxic at times, but I think my favorite boyfriend is Jess. not young Jess, older, Jess.


message 687: by Séville (new)

Séville | 3 comments team tristin <3


message 688: by Marina (new)

Marina (marinaaucontraire) | 7 comments Well, I understand everyone that chooses Jess but honestly, Rory doesn't deserve him. He's way too good for her.


message 689: by Marina (new)

Marina (marinaaucontraire) | 7 comments ┏━✦❘༻PetraPluto༺❘✦━━┓ wrote: "Marina wrote: "Well, I understand everyone that chooses Jess but honestly, Rory doesn't deserve him. He's way too good for her."

Yeah. Rory sucks and she doesn't Jess. Hell, I don't think she des..."


Actually I really liked Logan during the final seasons, especially the last one (the seventh, not AYITL, I hated everything about it).
I think he'd finally grown up and was genuinely a good bf for Rory, but well, ASP had to go and ruin everything on AYITL cause she always wanted Rory to get pregnant and Jess to be her Luke bla bla bla.

I particularly prefer to ignore AYITL but if we're taking it into account, then yes, Rory definitely does not deserve Jess. He's everything <3 and she's just boring and annoying.


message 690: by Marina (new)

Marina (marinaaucontraire) | 7 comments ┏━✦❘༻PetraPluto༺❘✦━━┓ wrote: "Marina wrote: "┏━✦❘༻PetraPluto༺❘✦━━┓ wrote: "Marina wrote: "Well, I understand everyone that chooses Jess but honestly, Rory doesn't deserve him. He's way too good for her."

Yeah. Rory sucks and ..."


I swear to you, I HATED it. I still cannot believe I lost about 4 hours of my life watching it. Of course I fast forwarded the musical scene cause I couldn't stand 15 minutes of that torture. Sorry XD

Well, at least we agree about Logan. He went back to being an asshole, and I loved him before... Thanks, ASP.


message 691: by Emma (new)

Emma Sedgwick | 6 comments everyone’s saying jess but logan is the right answer tbh


message 692: by Penny (new)

Penny | 7 comments Jess


message 693: by [deleted user] (new)

always been team jess, and ive been watching it since i was about 11 (20 now) it’s my fav show. (i love that everyone in this group loves GG, add me to become friends and talk about GG.


message 694: by mariana (new)

mariana marques | 2 comments Dean- first love
Jess- right person wrong time
Logan- soulmate
Tristan- right person not enough time


message 695: by frankie (new)

frankie (francoleby) | 5 comments proud to be team jess 🤭


message 696: by ester (new)

ester | 2 comments team logan


message 697: by molly (new)

molly morrow | 1 comments im team jess all the way


message 698: by annalise (new)

annalise | 3 comments team jess


message 699: by angie (new)

angie (zzangie) | 7 comments team jess all the way. dean is boring imo and all they do is kiss lol.


message 700: by trix (new)

trix (trixberesford) | 9 comments team jess for the win. dean is toxic af and i love logan but jess is just superior


back to top