The Rory Gilmore Book Club discussion
Gilmore Girls Discussions
>
Dean, Jess or Logan?
Defenetly Jess! from the beggining I felt like they were soulmates. There just weren1t the same kind of connection between Rory and Logan, even though I really liked me. Rory and Dean were not for one another. Dean was toxic, tbh.
okay jess is definitely the best one but I don't think rory deserved him. honestly she was kind of spoiled so i think her and logan match well. but jess is my fav character of the 3 for sure. although i am def down to debate this
Jess, because I think they worked so well together.
jess’s personality in dean’s body
Logan, and I'll tell you why.He keeps her on her toes. There's never a dull moment with him around, every moment is a thrill. He truly loves her, and shows his affection. He is a bit immature... (oh, who am I kidding? he's VERY immature) at some times, but honestly, who isn't? There's just something exciting about that whole relationship.
I don't really like Dean. I feel like that whole relationship was toxic. I didn't think that they really had that much chemistry. It just seemed forced... And then that whole thing with Lindsey... *shudder*
Jess... well, I have mixed feelings about Jess. At first, I didn't like him at all. His attitude is really off-putting. I know some girls really dig the bad boy thing, but I don't. As we started to see a nicer side of him, though, I started to warm up to him. But still, I don't think he's the right match for Rory. He may have cared about her, and yes, he got her to snap out of her "sloth" phase after the boat incident, but he didn't treat her the way she deserved. Maybe in later years, if he matures enough like we started to see in AYITL, but for now, I still say Logan.
Jess 100% I wanted him and Rory to end up together. I do love Logan though, but i'll always be team Jess.
Jess The one who really loved her .
logan 100% but maybe grown up jess...
Hands down Jess! Dean was the perfect first boyfriend for Rory, but she needed more.
Jess came along at the right time for her; he matched her intelligence and challenged her mentally and emotionally.
I thought very little of Logan.
Margie wrote: "https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM8YE4SNt/ here's Joey's opinion on Logan lol"Ha Ha Ha This was a great and funny clip.. love it
Helloooo LOGAN. Dean was a jerk, and a HUGE red flag. Jess was unpredictable and quite honestly, a lot. Logan was Rory's person. He pushed her, but not too much and he helped her grab the world by it's balls. Love love love.
Jess for sure. He understood her and although he was predictable he was respectful towards her and had a soft spot for her. I'm all for a bad boy that is soft for his girl though
Cindy wrote: "Margie wrote: "https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM8YE4SNt/ here's Joey's opinion on Logan lol"Ha Ha Ha This was a great and funny clip.. love it"
Oh yeah! Definitely agree with this one! Lol
jess because she was the best version of herself with him, she was bubbly and creative, and with logan, even tho he’s a bettter bf she was a train wreck lol
am i the only one who remembers jess ignoring rory when she said “no” to having sex?…. team logan all the way
Jess! Or Logan. But definitely not Dean.
I personally like Milo so Jess but Logan was the best for Rory.
Definitely TRISTAN , no one can convince me otherwise .
I would die for Jess. He’s the blueprint for any guy I ever liked.
jess!! i have to say that at the beginning of season 2 i didn’t like him at all but soon enough i realized that i was so wrong. he always understood rory and was the only one that shared her same interests so team jess till the end. even though i like logan so much, if jess didn’t exist he would’ve been my first choice for sure
Definitely Jess! It breaks my heart because I think they were perfect for each other at the wrong times😭 when they were young, Rory was way too good for him and when they grew up he was way too good for her:(((I think Logan was a great friend to Rory but I didn’t like them as a couple.
jess was her soulmate but it just never was the right time..but honestly i did like logan
i personally like jess a lot better bc he’s my type, but i think when they were older he was way too good for her. rory changed a lot after chilton and i think logan and her are much better together than her and jess would’ve been if they stayed together. so team jess for me but team logan for rory lol
Neither, team Tristan, still mad to this day that he didn’t have more of a story line even though it was the actor who left and he was supposed to have Logan’s story line
Team Jess all the way! Their relationship was just meant for one another...the only issue I saw was his uncle was Luke so Lorelai and Luke vs Rory and Jess
I feel like Logan is similar to Rory and they match well like that, but Jess complements her better and makes her a better person, 100% team Jess. But the fact Tristan never got a chance is evil smh
I’ll be honest I’m a huge Jess fan I swoon every time he’s on tv 😳 but then I think to myself would I have dated Jess if I were Rory? The answer is adamantly no. Even future Jess, who is my favourite part of GG, is a no for me because I could never date someone if they had tried to cross my boundaries like that no matter how far in the past. I think it’s best to view Rory’s relationships as a what-not-to-do guide. And that’s not even mentioning all of her own dysfunctional habits.😅