Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (Harry Potter, #6) Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince discussion


1714 views
Would you rather???

Comments Showing 1,351-1,400 of 1,410 (1410 new)    post a comment »

message 1351: by Amanda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amanda Broom

WYR have Remus, Severus, or Sirius as a father?


message 1352: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna Sirius.

WYR take Divination or Ancient Runes?


message 1353: by Cathy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cathy divination!

WYR have swan or a phoenix for your patronus?


message 1354: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna Hogwarts: A History once. Much as I love to read, I won't read 10 textbooks. One's enough to read cover to cover. Whew!

WYR have Grawp or Dobby as a brother?


Prashamsa dobby without a doubt.
WYR have a porcupine or guinea pig for a pet?


Hermione Granger Oh God... Probably Lupin. I just want to give him a hug-
Snape too, but I'd be too scared to give HIM a hug lol
WYR have the wand, the cloak or the stone?


message 1357: by Karl (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karl Dark Arts

Do you think McGonagol was more powerful than voldemort?


message 1358: by Eleanor Rigby (last edited Jul 16, 2013 05:12PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Eleanor Rigby I love McGonagal, but voldemort was deffintaly more powerful.

WYR have the marauders' map or the invisibility cloak?


message 1359: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna This question is familiar. . . ;)

I would take an invisibility cloak.

WYR Snape or Lily come back to life?


message 1360: by Lily (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lily snape

WYR have crooksanks or scabbers as your pet?


Hermione Granger CROOKSHANKS. Of course.

WYR face a Hungarian Horntail or take moaning myrtle to the Yule ball?


message 1362: by Saima (new) - rated it 4 stars

Saima Siddiqui Face a Hungarian Horntail :P

Daily Prophet or The Quibbler ?


message 1363: by Amanda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amanda Daily Prophet

WYR Date Cedric or Victor Krum?


Hermione Granger Cedric!! <3...:(
Wyr be trapped in a room with Belatrix or with Umbridge?


message 1365: by Amanda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amanda NONE lol um.... Umbridge

WYR have to fight and defeat the giant spiders(ew) or the ogres?


Hermione Granger Ughhh... Spiders I think. It would very satisfying :)
Be surrounded by inferi (who would drag you into the water and drown you) or by dementors- with no wand? ~shiver~


message 1367: by Amanda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amanda NONE once again lol Inferi I hate dementors!

WYR Be looked in the eye by the basilisk or be eaten by Arragog(the spider?)


Hermione Granger Looked in the eye by a basilisk, I think... It would be quicker and less painful.
Eek these are getting very gory lol

Wyr be taken to Azkaban or face Voldemort?


message 1369: by Amanda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amanda Face Voldemort

WYR be Neville's frog or Ron's Rat? Here's a happier one lol


Hermione Granger Haha. Well I think if rather be Scabbers- it must be awful being Nevilles toad, seeing as Trevor was always trying to run away from him... He'd loose me. At least Ron would be faithful lol

So wyr take baby Norbert or tame a Blast-Ended Skwert? Haha sorry this ones not so cheerful


Prashamsa take baby Norbert
WYR puke slugs or eat nosebleed nuggets?


Hermione Granger DOUBLE UGHH
Umm nosebleed nougats... Just so long as there's a remedy lol

Wyr be locked up with Lockharts or with Professor Trelawny?


Prashamsa Professor Trelawny, would be fun to hear about how i am going to die and stuffs ;)
wyr marry someone like lockhart (full of himself) or someone like umbridge (plain evil)?


Hermione Granger That's just plain mean!! Lockhart I guess... He IS supposedly handsome...:)

Wyr ride buckbeak or a thestral through a storm?


Prashamsa buckbeak... did you add the 'through a storm' part because my question was mean? lol.
ok here goes sth cheerful...
WYR live in hogsmeade or diagon ally?


Hermione Granger Haha YESSS revenge is sweeeeeeeet :)
Oh I WISH! Any one would do... Probably Hogsmeade though... It such a cute lil town

Here's something nice- would you rather get a Ten-Second Pimple Vanisher or a Patented Daydream Charm?


Prashamsa Ten-Second Pimple Vanisher. i can daydream quite well on my own. lol.
WYR date fred or george?


Hermione Granger Good choice :)
Aww! I don't know... Fred I guess.... OH Freddie no...I miss you :( <3

Wyr play keeper of seeker?


Prashamsa both are so full of responsibilities. keeper i guess, i can count on the seeker if i screw up.
WYR be good at potions or transfiguration?


Hermione Granger Transfiguration!!! All the way!

Wyr be an animagus or metamorphosis? (Like Tonks)


message 1381: by Autumn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Autumn Animagus!

wyr be in Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff?


Hermione Granger Oh Ravenclaw of course! I AM in Ravenclaw....(pottermore...:) )

Would you rather fly on a broomstick or apparate?


message 1383: by Autumn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Autumn I'm Slytherin :)
Apparate, can't stand heights.

Wyr eat berty bots every flavor beans or use tooth flossing stringmints


Hermione Granger Oh haha slytherin a good too... But not as good as Ravenclaw. GO RAVENCLAW
Really? But it's such a horrible feeling, like you're suffocating! Well, if you're afraid of heights I guess you wouldn't mind...
Umm I think Bertie Botts- then at least you have a chance to get a good flavor...

Wyr meet Peeves or The Bloody Baron?


message 1385: by Autumn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Autumn If I do so recall Ravenclaw is in last place for the house cup :)

Bloody Baron, I'm Slytherin so I think I'm safe :)

WYR marry Neville or Malfoy?


Hermione Granger Well we have better things to think about that childish competitions! :)
Yeah the Bloody Barons supposed to be ok to Slytherins- as is the GreyLady...
Oh! That's really really hard!! I mean bet I could turn Draco good- he always did have that side to him... Neville would just be a pain. No offense, I love Neville! But you know.... Good question

Ok, wyr get lost in the forbidden forest or in a knockturn alley?


message 1387: by Autumn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Autumn Haha.
Forbidden Forest. At least there could potentially be some nice centaurs there or something. The chances of Hagrid finding me in Diagon Alley is very slim.

WYR trade places with Ginny or Lavender?


Hermione Granger Haha true...
Ohh!! Well I wouldn't want to be with Harry... But who wants to be Lavender?!?
Ginny, I guess... At least she has a happy ending.

Wyr join the DA or the Order?


message 1389: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey Hermione wrote: "Haha YESSS revenge is sweeeeeeeet :)
Oh I WISH! Any one would do... Probably Hogsmeade though... It such a cute lil town

Here's something nice- would you rather get a Ten-Second Pimple Vanisher o..."


ten second pimple vanisher!!!!!!!!!!!


Hermione Granger Hey Casey!!
Haha yeah that would solve most of my problems in life...:)


message 1391: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey thts one of the good things abt growing up.. cant wait for no more pimples!!!!:)


Hermione Granger Ah I can barely even imagine it.., but you can't talk, miss ABSOLUTELY NO ACNE


Hermione Granger Well I guess we could all do with that ten second pimple Vanisher... Or at least those of us who are more like Eloise Midgen than we like to admit...

Well what WOULD you rather? DA or the Order??


message 1394: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey hmm, thts hard.. prob DA cuz its just so awesome


message 1395: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey aww thnx, but i def hv my pimply days!


Hermione Granger Oh yeah totally... Ahh what wouldn't I give to join...
Now your turn! Write a question!


Hermione Granger Huh. Some people are lucky :(


message 1398: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey ok.. wld u rather meet professor McGonnagal or professor snape?


Hermione Granger Eek. I don't know... McGonagel probably, I wouldn't know how to handle snape...

WYR get to the castle via boats on the lake or by the thestral carriages?


message 1400: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey i dunno, id actually kinda like to meet snape, knowing wht i kno abt him...

thts a good one! i think by carriage, considering tht they arrive and night and its freezing cold!


back to top