Fabian’s review of The Handmaid's Tale > Likes and Comments
368 likes · Like
The first review I've ever read of this which has made me want to read it. it's a surprising talent, making me want to read Atwood. She and I have such a troubling relationship.
Neal wrote: "The first review I've ever read of this which has made me want to read it. it's a surprising talent, making me want to read Atwood. She and I have such a troubling relationship."
Really? None of her books have disappointed me (yet), and most of them I give 5 stars to! Have you read the Maddaddam Trilogy? Such a strange, amazing series.
I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in her ideas and presentation. I'll finish it eventually, I'm sure, but it often frustrates me how very little mystery there is in her books given she also writes poetry. I keep reminding myself of Alias Grace, which was my first book by her and one helluva good one at that. But I've changed a lot as a reader since enjoying that one, and I'm just not sure how it would stand in my estimation anymore...
Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in ..."
Wow, that's very surprising to hear. I also loved The Blind Assassin as well--its as superb as Alias Grace. I will admit that its a goal of mine to read all of her novels. As a huge fan of that art (more so, Im afraid, than poetry), I think she may just be my favorite Canadian writer of all time.
I loved this book. And I agree with your Coen brothers analogy. Spot on!
Dorothy wrote: "I loved this book. And I agree with your Coen brothers analogy. Spot on!"
Thanks! f
Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in ..."
have you read atwood's 'surfacing'? https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4...
it's one of her best, imo. i like her s/f novels better than most of her others; 'surfacing' is an exception.
i once spoke with a local [ sask.] school librarian when atwood's name came up - a recent award or honour - and the librarian said, 'margaret atwood - you know, that boring canadian lady'.
Fabian, Ive procrastinated on reading this for - what? - maybe 20 years? Im in. Super insights!
Roberta wrote: "Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on ..."
WOW! Everyones a critic! (Obviously.) And yes, I HAVE read Surfacing, check out my review of it. I thought it was magnificent, which is not out of the ordinary for the BCD ("Boring Canadian Lady").
Anne wrote: "Nice review, Fabian, of a book that garners such a wide spectrum of opinions."
Thank you, Anne! f
LeAnne wrote: "Fabian, Ive procrastinated on reading this for - what? - maybe 20 years? Im in. Super insights!"
LeAnne: Read, read read! A MUST
I have it in my library, unread. Your excitement over this is contagious, and definitely convincing (especially as I loved Zamiatin's We). Thanks for the insight!
Ana-Maria wrote: "I have it in my library, unread. Your excitement over this is contagious, and definitely convincing (especially as I loved Zamiatin's We). Thanks for the insight!"
Yes Ana-Maria! Handmaids Tale is definitely a must for any member of the literati!
what do you mean by "mirrors thd treatment of women in the middle east"?
Ayala wrote: "what do you mean by "mirrors thd treatment of women in the middle east"?"
As second class citizens. Second to men.
In complete agreement
I don't much care for dystopias, and a man-hating dystopia was too much for me. The quality of writing kept it from being a "one star", but the hit-me-over-the-head plot required a significant downgrade. Felt like I had to cue up the end of "Planet of the Apes" (movie) and cleanse my palette by Heston shouting "You damned dirty apes!"
I agree with this review because I had the same reaction to the end of the story and the main norms in the society. My favorite part is the ending when it gives you hints of everyones relations and then makes it so you want to read more.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Neal
(new)
Aug 10, 2016 12:11PM
The first review I've ever read of this which has made me want to read it. it's a surprising talent, making me want to read Atwood. She and I have such a troubling relationship.
reply
|
flag
Neal wrote: "The first review I've ever read of this which has made me want to read it. it's a surprising talent, making me want to read Atwood. She and I have such a troubling relationship."Really? None of her books have disappointed me (yet), and most of them I give 5 stars to! Have you read the Maddaddam Trilogy? Such a strange, amazing series.
I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in her ideas and presentation. I'll finish it eventually, I'm sure, but it often frustrates me how very little mystery there is in her books given she also writes poetry. I keep reminding myself of Alias Grace, which was my first book by her and one helluva good one at that. But I've changed a lot as a reader since enjoying that one, and I'm just not sure how it would stand in my estimation anymore...
Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in ..."Wow, that's very surprising to hear. I also loved The Blind Assassin as well--its as superb as Alias Grace. I will admit that its a goal of mine to read all of her novels. As a huge fan of that art (more so, Im afraid, than poetry), I think she may just be my favorite Canadian writer of all time.
I loved this book. And I agree with your Coen brothers analogy. Spot on!
Dorothy wrote: "I loved this book. And I agree with your Coen brothers analogy. Spot on!"Thanks! f
Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on the bone" in ..."have you read atwood's 'surfacing'? https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4...
it's one of her best, imo. i like her s/f novels better than most of her others; 'surfacing' is an exception.
i once spoke with a local [ sask.] school librarian when atwood's name came up - a recent award or honour - and the librarian said, 'margaret atwood - you know, that boring canadian lady'.
Nice review, Fabian, of a book that garners such a wide spectrum of opinions.
Fabian, Ive procrastinated on reading this for - what? - maybe 20 years? Im in. Super insights!
Roberta wrote: "Neal wrote: "I've read the first two. I enjoyed the first one and the second for the most part - I don't think that I've ever read a book so quickly - but ultimately I find Atwood a little too "on ..."WOW! Everyones a critic! (Obviously.) And yes, I HAVE read Surfacing, check out my review of it. I thought it was magnificent, which is not out of the ordinary for the BCD ("Boring Canadian Lady").
Anne wrote: "Nice review, Fabian, of a book that garners such a wide spectrum of opinions."Thank you, Anne! f
LeAnne wrote: "Fabian, Ive procrastinated on reading this for - what? - maybe 20 years? Im in. Super insights!"LeAnne: Read, read read! A MUST
I have it in my library, unread. Your excitement over this is contagious, and definitely convincing (especially as I loved Zamiatin's We). Thanks for the insight!
Ana-Maria wrote: "I have it in my library, unread. Your excitement over this is contagious, and definitely convincing (especially as I loved Zamiatin's We). Thanks for the insight!"Yes Ana-Maria! Handmaids Tale is definitely a must for any member of the literati!
what do you mean by "mirrors thd treatment of women in the middle east"?
Ayala wrote: "what do you mean by "mirrors thd treatment of women in the middle east"?"As second class citizens. Second to men.
In complete agreement
I don't much care for dystopias, and a man-hating dystopia was too much for me. The quality of writing kept it from being a "one star", but the hit-me-over-the-head plot required a significant downgrade. Felt like I had to cue up the end of "Planet of the Apes" (movie) and cleanse my palette by Heston shouting "You damned dirty apes!"
I agree with this review because I had the same reaction to the end of the story and the main norms in the society. My favorite part is the ending when it gives you hints of everyones relations and then makes it so you want to read more.
