David’s review of After Virtue > Likes and Comments

Thanks for taking the time to summarize with such care. This is a hugely important book you obviously read attentively. I'm going back to try to understand MacIntyre's criticism of Aristotle's "metaphysical biology."

One glaring omission from MacIntyre's work is a discussion of Hegel--who had his own criticisms of Kantian morals and emphasized the imporance of Sittlichkeit and the social dimension of morality in exactly the way MacIntyre has. Also, Kant's idea of a duty to oneself gets short shrift.

Thanks again, David.

Simply amazing review. I was getting bogged down reading this book but this inspired me to pick it up again.

Fantastic review.

Wow

I keep returning to this summary after finishing a section to do a review and order my thoughts. What an excellent resource. Thank you so much for the time you took to put this together.

Yes thank you David. Wish you your best

Wonderful review

A good short summary, but without reviewer's subjective opinion I can't see why he gave four stars out of five.

Bravo and thanks 🙏🏿

Impressive review! Thank you David