Poll
Harry Potter Or Twilight
Harry PotterJ.K. Rowling
TwilightStephenie Meyer
Poll added by: Azaria
This Poll is About
Comments Showing 1-48 of 48 (48 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jane
(new)
Apr 19, 2013 02:29AM
Yes. Just yes.
reply
|
flag
OMG THEY ARE SO MANY OF THIS POLLS! HP IS AWESOME!
Kaylee wrote: "Hasn't Twilight received enough hate? I don't understand why people take so much pleasure in disliking it."I think it's the fact that even more people LOVE it so much despite its lackluster quality that drives them to do so.
Voted for HP of course.
Harry Potter will always be in my heart, there is far more to the story than what Twilight offers. J.K.Rowling thought about every little aspect from the currency to the food they eat and the clothes they wear. She ensures that we are brought into the wizarding world and it truly makes me feel as if I'm a part of Harry's journey.
Only someone incredibly stupid could choose that piece of Sh*t Twilight over the incredible amazing Harry! And what the hell is so special about Twilight? I mean ... they're SPARKLING! That's just ... come on! I just wish the HP series never ended ... :(
Harry Potter. This should not even be a discussion.
Is this even supposed to be a contest?
Kimberly wrote: "Obviously Harry Potter!"I completely agree !!
Kimberly wrote: "Obviously Harry Potter!"I couldn't agree more!
Potterhead for life. i'll die from loving HP so much.here lies Julia, she ALWAYS loved Harry Potter
HP for me. Twilight never really caught my imagination - couldn't get past the first couple of chapters...
Kate wrote: "Hasn't Twilight received enough hate? I don't understand why people take so much pleasure in disliking it."People enjoy disliking it so much because of how unhinged some of the fans are (eg: attacking people who openly speak ill of the books) and how tasteless and unimaginative the series is.
I actually liked Twilight but it has nothing on Harry Potter in my opinion.
Shayne wrote: "I wish the HP series could go on.""Alas, the world is not a wish-granting factory"
there is no competition b/w meyer n rowling... Rowling is no doubt hell lot better thn alot of writers.
Why were these two even compared? Is it not obvious that HP is amazing whereas Twilight is not.
Twilight is limiting, Potter has a broad appeal.I tried Twilight but is is so annoying, Edward is quite old in a lads body, but behaves like a teenager in the throws of inexperienced first love, Bella is a soulless empty shell of a person; why would one let alone two people fall for her? The kids in Harry Potter are more emotionally rounded and the characters deeper.
Someone that compares Harry Potter and Twilight, clearly, does not know enough about both series -.-
No doubt it's Harry Potter. I grew up with it
* Harry PotterJ.K. Rowling
920 votes, 92.4%
TwilightStephenie Meyer
76 votes, 7.6%
That says it all ;D
920 votes, 92.4%
TwilightStephenie Meyer
76 votes, 7.6%
That says it all ;D
These results ring true. I personally don't think that Twilight should even be in the same poll as Harry Potter.
Harry Potter! Twilight could never be in the same league as Harry Potter! Compared to Harry Potter, Twilight is nothing!
CabinSixGryffindorEOW wrote: "These results ring true. I personally don't think that Twilight should even be in the same poll as Harry Potter."Amen! Truer words have never been spoken!
message 41:
by
Hailley Dawn--✖ When you love somebody, they'll always leave too soon ✖
(last edited Mar 14, 2015 09:24PM)
(new)
but why compare. theyre both good in different ways and nmeant for different audiences. *eye roll*[image error]src="http://www.google.co.nz/url?sa=i&...
Harry Potter. why is this even a question?
I don't understand why we're always comparing these two books. They are absolutely nothing alike, not even directed towards the same audience. I think we can all agree that Twilight isn't great, but that doesn't mean we should compare it to Harry Potter, because they aren't even remotely similiar.
