Poll

65493
Is listening to music while reading distracting?

It depends on the kind of music
 
  1917 votes, 38.2%

yes
 
  1500 votes, 29.9%

kind of
 
  607 votes, 12.1%

no
 
  525 votes, 10.4%

I do it all the time!
 
  475 votes, 9.5%


Poll added by: Jade



Comments Showing 51-100 of 126 (126 new)


message 51: by Becky (new)

Becky G I can only read in silence or to very soft classical music that I don't know.


message 52: by Brandon (new)

Brandon I listened to ADTR and Emery with my headsets while tackling Steven Erikson and Glen Cook.


message 53: by David (new)

David I got into a weird rut where I had trouble reading for as long a stretch as I used to, and then I started putting on classical music (mostly Chopin and Beethoven) and it's helped a lot. I always have it on while reading now. When I'm writing I also usually listen to music (typically metal, prog-rock, or post-hardcore instead of classical and it's been going on for a lot longer).

By brain left to fend for itself in a silent room is a far bigger distraction to reading than any music. Can't shut the thing up. I need to have a show or something playing in order to fall asleep as well.


message 54: by Kaitlin (new)

Kaitlin I like listening to music that kind of goes with the book I'm reading. Sort of like every movie has it's soundtrack, every book does too.


message 55: by Paven (last edited Dec 16, 2014 06:30AM) (new)

Paven Thomas It's interesting to hear music while reading :)


message 56: by Katy (new)

Katy H Mark wrote: "I listened to the Moulin Rouge soundtrack while reading One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest and it's created some interesting mental linkages between those two things. Typically, I try not to be listen..."

The same thing happened to me except it was a Wynonna Judd cassette tape and Chain Letter. This was in the early 90's, to the best of my recollection. Now every time my mom (or anyone else) plays that tape, I think of a certain part of the aforementioned book so, no more music + reading for me. I'm just as easily distracted by classical music since I have a bit of an obsession with picking out all the different instruments. Particularly violas and cellos. I suppose there are worse compulsions...


message 57: by Katy (new)

Katy H Brad wrote: "It depends on what music you listen to. I normally listen to Khachaturian, Lalo, Sibelius, Suk, and the like, but they tend to be too distracting. I generally listen to some calm Debussy or Bach pa..."

Debussy and Bach would totally distract me! I've tried to use both to help me sleep but after all my years in orchestra, I hear that & immediately started counting/listening for "my part". Then I just want to get up and play!


message 58: by Katy (new)

Katy H Kadi wrote: "I can't listen to music while reading, it's so distracting. I can listen to a track of 'white noise' though, which helps, as it blocks out all other noisy distractions so that I can focus on my rea..."

I often have white noise on while I read too. Just no music or TV, and preferably no talking. I'm apparently very sensitive! LOL (Yet I can listen to an audio book - with the white noise still going - read a {knitting} pattern, and knit all at once.) I'm just a bit strange...


message 59: by Erik (new)

Erik Depends on both the music and the book. Sometimes music is all I need to get deep into the book and get emotional about it. But sometimes it happens so that music is the worst distraction ever and I really can't listen to anything while reading. The books which need lots of thinking are one of those which don't let me listen to anything. Easy reads, however, are the exact opposite. They kind of even need music.


message 60: by M. (new)

M. P. Depends. I've found orchestral music without lyrics to be the best for me. Listening to words I can understand distract me from what I'm trying to read.


message 61: by Malisa (new)

Malisa If you mean the book distracts me from the music, then yes! :P


message 62: by Ben (new)

Ben Camfield Depends!
I like listening to The XX whilst reading


message 63: by Cille (new)

Cille When I read a book I'm going so much into the character I forget I even hear music :)


message 64: by Zach (new)

Zach I was listening to dub reggae while reading all your comments and I think I read them pretty fast and made my account so I could post this comment. And I don't have to flip my tape yet. King Tubby. Good reading sounds. Who the he'll asks Google if you can read and listen to music hahahahaha. Just try it bro.


message 65: by Joshua (new)

Joshua cool


message 66: by Joshua (new)

Joshua hihihihihihihi


message 67: by [deleted user] (new)

I can't read well without Jazz/Classical in the background.


message 68: by Jewel (new)

Jewel Thompson I listen to movie and tv scores while reading(BBC's Sherlock, Lord of the Rings, etc.) Classical is always a good option too.


message 69: by Kasia (new)

Kasia No! Honestly, it's all about focus. I find music kind of blocks out outside noise (cars, tv if you live with someone, kids playing, people talking) I do admit, sometimes I break for a few seconds out of reading and sing a bit


message 70: by Anna (new)

Anna Maybe classical or jazz, but other than that, it's impossible for me to listen to music (or anything for the matter) while reading.


message 71: by Elena (new)

Elena Salvatore If I listen to music while reading, I start singing the lyrics and have my mind on the music and don't even understand what I'm reading... :/


message 72: by Calyx (new)

Calyx Music with no lyrics work on me, and it can be anything like classical, acoustic, EDM, etc.
But once lyrics get in a song, even if it's just a single word repeated throughout the song, BAM!
My eyes glaze over from the words in front of me.

I find myself pausing any lyrical music whenever I come across any interesting article online even, and it's so annoying!


message 73: by Mac (new)

Mac I like music with no words


message 74: by MollyRN (new)

MollyRN I can not listen to music with lyrics. My go to is Pandora's Indian Flute Music.


message 75: by Mary (new)

Mary Alex It really depends on my mindset that day. Sometimes I get distracted with my favorite artists playing. Other times I don't. It alk depends on my mood.


message 76: by Mekiah (new)

Mekiah Johnson it depends


message 77: by Sam (new)

Sam I found that listening to music with lyrics can be distracting for me, however, music without lyrics, such as, instrumental or ambient, do not distract.


message 78: by EsmΓ©e (new)

EsmΓ©e Silence can make me uncomfortable, so I prefer to listen to instrumental or classical music at a low volume. It's soothing and adds some background noise. :)


message 79: by Ella (new)

Ella J. Smyth Can't do it. I've got real concentration issues and if my mind catches onto a hook in the music, that's it. I'll sing or hum along and it pulls me straight out of the story. If I miss music, I know that the book isn't good enough :)


message 80: by Laura (new)

Laura Can almost always read with instrumental music playing. Can only listen to music with words if I don't know the lyrics because I will just think about the song


message 81: by Xette (new)

Xette I can't really hear anything when I'm reading lol so it's not a distraction, hell, I don't even bother listening to one.


message 82: by Heather (new)

Heather Largin Depends on the music. Spotify has an awesome reading soundtrack. Awesome for the days when the house is too loud. Put on my headphones and start to read and I'm in my book for hours.


message 83: by Foxylula (new)

Foxylula Listening to meditation music helps me concentrate, but any other type of music is too distracting (especially if there's singing in it).


message 84: by Mark (new)

Mark I can't concentrate on a book if I'm listening to music, even if it's just one song on loop. I don't understand how people can do it :P


message 85: by Dorian (new)

Dorian Jandreau I cannot read at all if there is ANY kind of noise... Music is apogee of noise. Either reading or either listening to music. It's impossible for me to put these things together.


message 86: by K.G. (last edited Sep 10, 2017 11:27AM) (new)

K.G. I can read while listening to classical music and some jazz, blues and soft rock but usually prefer nothing on for concentration. ACDC and Guns & Roses just doesn't work while reading.


message 87: by Jack (new)

Jack Dinsdale Usually it has to be non-lyrical, if it has lyrics I start focusing on the words. But some songs just don't get me distracted.


message 88: by Sivani (last edited Feb 13, 2018 10:17AM) (new)

Sivani Madhurima i listen to linkin park on loop while i do anything including reading and studying.


message 89: by Heather (new)

Heather Largin I can only listen to classical music while reading.. I live in an upstairs apartment and my downstairs neighbor has his tv super loud all the time which is a huge distraction.. It’s nice that I can turn my classical music on and avoid the distraction! Other than classical music I can not listen to any other music as it is a distraction!


message 90: by ElsaMakotoRenge (new)

ElsaMakotoRenge I listen to music all the time while reading. But it has to be something I pick myself (ie., something I like). If it's leisure reading anything is fine, Nightwish or Sonata Arctica or whatever included. In fact I LIKE to listen to music with earbuds while reading because it shuts out distractions.


message 91: by Kathy (new)

Kathy B I usually listen to music while reading because I don't like complete quiet. As long as I keep it low just for background sound I'm good (:


message 92: by William (new)

William Fisher I've got some technical Bach on and am just weighing up whether to pick up a book or not. Those notes are as individual as words I don't think the two are compatible.


message 93: by Aqsa (last edited Apr 10, 2018 08:50PM) (new)

Aqsa There are books that I read with the right song selection. I do it a lot. It's like the background music in a movie scene which tells you what mood everyone is in, and it works out great :)

Other times, I don't find the perfect song/s or the book has so much detail that I'd get distracted.


message 94: by [deleted user] (new)

The type of music I listen to depends on the genre of the book and whatever scene I'm going through. Stirs up emotions.


SHARLENE (MyBookishBehaviour) the only thing I can listen to while reading (on low volume):
https://youtu.be/2L9vFNMvIBE
And I play it on my TV often to keep me from being distracted by other things. ex: my phone. lol


message 96: by Leilah (new)

Leilah Personally I like it listen to music quietly in the background because i can't focus with blaring music nor can I focus in total silence.


message 97: by Sheyda (new)

Sheyda Dehghan Light musics help me to focus


message 98: by Rachel Adiyah (new)

Rachel Adiyah If it's downtempo music like Bonobo or Thievery Corporation, then I don't mind. But if you're going to blast pop music from a Fios music channel, then I couldn't focus.


message 99: by Kenneth (last edited Oct 24, 2018 02:13AM) (new)

Kenneth Music designed as game BGM are helpful. They are designed such that it does not grab your attention, and for some, they help you concentrate.

Personally, the worst choices are music that 1) have lyrics, 2) intended for attentive listening, or 3) changing, dynamic, or dramatic.

These criteria eliminate most classical music (excluding some forms of chamber), all pop, rock, and contemporary music.

Other alternatives to game BGM might include jazz chamber, techno (beware of the taxonomical genre), or noise rock/music.

I would recommend looping a song as it will become familiar and you won't focus on it.

Otherwise silence is the best.


message 100: by MoonstoneOwl (new)

MoonstoneOwl I prefer to use themed background ambience. Eg if I'm reading Harry Potter I can put on some Ravenclaw Common Room background ambience :)


back to top

all polls
create a poll
widget



Meghan 0 books
2 friends
voted for:
yes


Jamie 5 books
0 friends
voted for:
It depends o


James 535 books
27 friends
voted for:
no


Jill 133 books
3 friends
voted for:
I do it all


β™‘samiaβ™‘ 29 books
2 friends
voted for:
no


Kittie 0 books
1 friend
voted for:
I do it all




Kimerina 68 books
7 friends
voted for:
I do it all


Latte 1965 books
4 friends
voted for:
I do it all


RomcomQueen 16 books
0 friends
voted for:
I do it all


lilia 3 books
245 friends
voted for:
yes


Sarah ⚘ 4671 books
95 friends
voted for:
It depends o


Γ‰milie 536 books
6 friends
voted for:
yes


Ramneet 16 books
0 friends
voted for:
no


John 19 books
0 friends
voted for:
no


May 9 books
1 friend
voted for:
yes


Elliot 18 books
0 friends
voted for:
I do it all


roanita 486 books
15 friends
voted for:
It depends o


Kyla 125 books
0 friends
voted for:
I do it all


Colton 200 books
1 friend
voted for:
It depends o


Kristin 78 books
0 friends
voted for:
It depends o


Melanie 2661 books
311 friends
voted for:
yes


Ivan 206 books
10 friends
voted for:
yes


Oscaargh 38 books
3 friends
voted for:
kind of


Jada 86 books
1 friend
voted for:
I do it all


NT 85 books
0 friends
voted for:
I do it all


Sarah 22759 books
3123 friends
voted for:
yes


justina_ 90 books
4 friends
voted for:
It depends o


SK 2470 books
4969 friends
voted for:
yes


More...