Poll

Do you like reading the book before or after seeing the movie?

Sponsored by The Woman In Black Challenge

Before film
 
  19034 votes, 79.6%

Both
 
  3474 votes, 14.5%

After film
 
  1404 votes, 5.9%


Poll added by: Goodreads



Comments Showing 101-105 of 105 (105 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 101: by Edward (new)

Edward Hill Ricki wrote: "By reading the book before seeing the movie, I get to see the characters how I imagine them."

same here


message 102: by Cody (new)

Cody Jones This can go both ways for sure. If you see the movie first, you aren't likely to be taken through such a great adventure, rush, adrenaline a good book can take you through. Plus, you are limiting creativity that develops in your brain when you read a book for the first time. However, if you watch some movies first before some books, you can understand some of the directors changes and appreciate the furthered knowledge of someone's point of view of a story that you know you will be reading in a few days. I say both are required to expand you knowledge. However, reading the book first is always a safe bet for any reader.


message 103: by Pam (new)

Pam Must read the book first


message 104: by Ike (new)

Ike Amanda wrote: "I never enjoy the movie if I read the book first. It's always a HUGE let down."

I agree. That is why I enjoy the book more. The book can take you places. The movie is the directors thoughts on a screen for other people to watch. I am not saying this is true for all movies, but The book is better.


message 105: by Lynn (new)

Lynn Ike wrote: "Amanda wrote: "I never enjoy the movie if I read the book first. It's always a HUGE let down."

I agree. That is why I enjoy the book more. The book can take you places. The movie is the directors ..."


I generally agree but found "The Martian" to be an exception to the rule. I didn't care for the change at the end but I'd heard beforehand that the change had been made and I didn't find it significant to the plot.


1 3 next »
back to top

all polls
create a poll
widget

Michelle 671 books
2003 friends
voted for:
After film


Tabitha 5970 books
200 friends
voted for:
Both


Tobe 3348 books
42 friends
voted for:
Both


Fiza 572 books
47 friends
voted for:
Before film


Labeebah 1174 books
23 friends
voted for:
Before film


Amanda 553 books
21 friends
voted for:
Before film


Cassy 129 books
0 friends
voted for:
Before film


Teresa 106 books
1 friend
voted for:
Before film


Dorothyann 4 books
6 friends
voted for:
Before film


Rea 43 books
0 friends
voted for:
Before film


X_stephen_x 775 books
3 friends
voted for:
Before film


Melissa 2449 books
211 friends
voted for:
Before film


Danielle 397 books
34 friends
voted for:
Before film


Marion 1978 books
50 friends
voted for:
Before film


Claudia 50 books
91 friends
voted for:
Before film


Jessica 88 books
15 friends
voted for:
Before film


Ivan 360 books
91 friends
voted for:
After film


Gabby 147 books
28 friends
voted for:
Before film


Alejandro 949 books
177 friends
voted for:
Before film


Geodi 107 books
19 friends
voted for:
Before film


Janie 100 books
105 friends
voted for:
Before film


Mari 79 books
13 friends
voted for:
Before film


James 1231 books
2 friends
voted for:
Before film


Brock 102 books
0 friends
voted for:
Both


Joe 825 books
16 friends
voted for:
Before film


Erin 284 books
15 friends
voted for:
Before film


Frances 434 books
11 friends
voted for:
Before film


Mary Lou 102 books
0 friends
voted for:
Both


Christy 29 books
0 friends
voted for:
Before film


Kristin 433 books
25 friends
voted for:
Before film


More...