Poll

Pls help! I want to read The Dark Artifices by Cassandra Clare, but do i need to read The Mortal Instruments to understand it? I really don’t want to

Idk
 
  59 votes, 53.2%

Yeah :(
 
  38 votes, 34.2%

Absolutely no!
 
  14 votes, 12.6%


Poll added by: Carolina



Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

thewindsofthenorth Well, it really would make more sense, lots of characters appear and the worlds are strictly interconnected and on the timeline they happen at the same time. But it’s not really necessary to understand the story.


Kae | reads.with.kae It will make so much more sense if you do! Those characters show up in the back half of TMI and it gives a lot more background about them. But I do understand it’s a hassle


message 3: by Merle (new)

Merle they are set in a timeframe exactly after each other, so it makes so much more sense to read first TMI and then TDA
I also personally read The Infernal Devices after TMI and before TDA in order to not get spoiled... but yeah it's a hassle.
If you know you never want to read the other series, go and start with TDA, you will understand the plot with no problems, but you will miss out on easter eggs etc


message 4: by Carolina (new)

Carolina Moncayo Kae :) wrote: "It will make so much more sense if you do! Those characters show up in the back half of TMI and it gives a lot more background about them. But I do understand it’s a hassle"

Ugh and the sibling plot in the Mortal Instruments?? I’m just really not in the mood to read them, they’re so long and I already watched the show and movie 😭💀 if that works HAHA


Kae | reads.with.kae Carolina wrote

A respectful hard pass on the tv show 😂🙅🏼‍♀️
I’d say I’d you’re familiar with some parts of it, skim through that
And then if you haven’t read TID, also read those because they’re so good
The background info will make things so much better I promise



Sima Khairullah I would say instead of reading TMI to understand TDA search the internet for some information or watch spoilery reviews just don't read TMI, i cant recommend it to anyone 🥲


message 7: by Carolina (new)

Carolina Moncayo Kae :) wrote: "Carolina wrote

A respectful hard pass on the tv show 😂🙅🏼‍♀️
I’d say I’d you’re familiar with some parts of it, skim through that
And then if you haven’t read TID, also read those because they’re..."


I read TID and I loved them, I just don’t want to read TMI because it’s too long and just no hahahaha


message 8: by Carolina (new)

Carolina Moncayo Aurora ✨ wrote: "I would say instead of reading TMI to understand TDA search the internet for some information or watch spoilery reviews just don't read TMI, i cant recommend it to anyone 🥲"

I’ll read a summary of each book and that’s it 🤠


message 9: by Natasha (last edited Jun 14, 2022 11:09AM) (new)

Natasha  Leighton The last TMI book, City of Heavenly Fire introduces alot of the main characters of TDA and alot of their character arcs revolve around dealing with the big events of that book so if you really don’t feel like reading the whole TMI series I’d at least read that one.


message 10: by Sima Khairullah (last edited Jun 14, 2022 08:59AM) (new)

Sima Khairullah Carolina wrote: "Aurora ✨ wrote: "I would say instead of reading TMI to understand TDA search the internet for some information or watch spoilery reviews just don't read TMI, i cant recommend it to anyone 🥲"



that is sure for better, hope you enjoy TDA <3



message 11: by Casey (new)

Casey The mortal instruments are soooo good and you will like the dark artifices way better after reading TMI. Plus you understand the characters more and know some of them from TMI


victoria (lorcan’s version) TDA is my favourite cassie clare series, but i'd say to read both TMI and TID because the characters from both series are mentioned and show up in this book. I think it just makes the reading experience much more enjoyable when u know the people that r showing up and u understand the jokes about certain families, like the Herondales.


message 13: by Noe✨ (new)

Noe✨ The fun thing about the whole shadowhunter world is that all the books are connected somehow. In TID the characters are mentioned in TMI and TDA and you could spoil yourself TID. And like some comments say characters from TID are introduced in the last book they are right! In my personal opinion, I prefer TID and TDA compared to TMI. So if you want you can read the first two and just read summaries of the mortal instruments if you want!


back to top

all polls
create a poll
widget

zoe 11 books
50 friends
voted for:
Idk


Andrew 323 books
129 friends
voted for:
Yeah :(


Ino☾ 304 books
698 friends
voted for:
Idk


the.james.bookshelf 229 books
680 friends
voted for:
Absolutely n


claire feldmann 638 books
155 friends
voted for:
Idk


Sella! 178 books
713 friends
voted for:
Idk


Sophie 412 books
649 friends
voted for:
Idk


Sima Khairullah 1036 books
2183 friends
voted for:
Absolutely n


Elizabeth 125 books
320 friends
voted for:
Idk


brooklyn ꫂ ၴႅၴ 458 books
812 friends
voted for:
Idk


Lex &#x1f1f2;&#x1f1fd; 829 books
1497 friends
voted for:
Yeah :(


Millie 320 books
937 friends
voted for:
Idk


bobbie 613 books
5064 friends
voted for:
Absolutely n


vicky 303 books
1271 friends
voted for:
Yeah :(


jane 1524 books
1868 friends
voted for:
Idk


ousha 446 books
851 friends
voted for:
Idk


voted for:
Idk


reen 137 books
70 friends
voted for:
Absolutely n


aim 967 books
1005 friends
voted for:
Idk


Maddison 223 books
1976 friends
voted for:
Idk


Denise 336 books
157 friends
voted for:
Idk


aditi ⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ 1202 books
611 friends
voted for:
Yeah :(


Rachel ☆ 1022 books
96 friends
voted for:
Idk


harlie brown 1114 books
9 friends
voted for:
Idk


Aran :) 664 books
54 friends
voted for:
Idk


Wilo❀ 124 books
850 friends
voted for:
Idk


SK 2558 books
4929 friends
voted for:
Idk


gum 622 books
114 friends
voted for:
Absolutely n


Ann 81 books
237 friends
voted for:
Yeah :(


voted for:
Idk


More...