Under this scenario, we wouldn’t expect to see species falling into a nested hierarchy of forms that is recognized by all biologists.2
I still don't understand why God would make everything randomly for each new creation he made. That sounds a lot more like what we should expect from evolution - randomness and lack of organization. By the way, why was there only one common ancestor? If life randomly happened from primordial soup once, shouldn't it have happened countless times? Did the first life event create something perfectly? Shouldn't it have created millions if any? What are the chances it just created one living thing and from that, everything else was created? Sounds very magical.
