With the benefit of hindsight, participants on both sides agreed after the war that the one-sided southern triumph in the first big battle “proved the greatest misfortune that would have befallen the Confederacy.” Such an interpretation has become orthodoxy in Civil War historiography.15 This orthodoxy contains much truth, but perhaps not the whole truth. The confidence gained by the men who won at Manassas imbued them with an esprit de corps that was reinforced by more victories in the next two years. At the same time the Union defeat instilled a gnawing, half-acknowledged sense of martial
...more
