Tangled in Tinsel (The More the Merrier, #1)

by Trilina Pucci

I swipe a champagne from him, rushing out, “I’m so sorry for what’s about to happen,” before I down the glass and switch it out with the other one in his hand. He’s staring at me, probably about to ask what the hell is wrong with me, when we’re suddenly surrounded. At least, that’s what it feels like. Because my favorite set of eyes…all four of them…are staring directly at me.

“Hi, I’m Christopher, Samantha’s—” But Reed cuts him off with a singular, “Nope.” I smirk, putting my hands on my hips. “What are you guys doing here? I’m on a date.” Christopher raises his hand as if to claim the title, but Jace lowers it for him. Alec crosses his arms, glancing at the guys before he narrows his eyes on me. “You left us. We want an explanation.” Heat rises through my body. Are they fucking kidding? “Wait a minute. How did you know I was here?” Alec grins, looking at Reed who lifts his chin toward my sister, saying, “I follow her on Instagram.” Damn you, Elle. I will kill her later. Alec’s unwavering glare calls to me, locking my gaze back on him. “Well?” he presses. “Well, what?” I snap back. His giant body feels foreboding as he takes a step closer. “We left our annual New Year’s party to come here. We left a hundred or so guests, for an answer, gorgeous, and we’re not leaving until we get one.”

“You didn’t ask me to stay. It’s that simple.”

“What if we ask you t...

“You all but did ask me to leave.” My eyes connect with Cole’s. “You walked me to the door. Told me to leave the shirt on the bed. Nobody said anything when I said there wasn’t a reason for me to stay…that was your cue, dickheads.”

“Christopher, I can understand your confusion. Let me explain for our Samantha. I don’t know if you know, but my sunshine here is a huge slut. Massive.” Reed smiles down at me, and I try my level best not to do it back. So he keeps talking, “She’s got a body count like Mortal Combat. We’d probably be hard-pressed to fit them all in this room. So four guys was a cakewalk. The only problem is we’re not done.”

“I answered your question. Now answer mine. Why are you here?” Reed draws his bottom lip between his teeth before I feel his fingers lift my chin. “We did. You weren’t listening. We’re asking you to leave with us.”

“We like you, Samantha. And we want you. We’re fucking idiots for not telling you that, but there was shit we needed to work out. Negotiations so to speak.”

“What can I say, negotiations were intense.” He starts toward me. “Because they were about something we all feel equally passionate about…someone we all want very much.”

“But I don’t want another weekend. I want a chance at forever. And that’s unrealistic.”

“We were one weekend and one weekend only,” I yell. “That’s what you said.” Nine. Reed comes to my side, taking my hand. “Sunshine, when are you going to realize we always want what you want?” Eight. Jace sweeps my hair off my shoulder, staring back with pleading eyes. “Say yes, cutie.” Seven. I’m shaking my head. “This will be doomed from the start. What are we supposed to do? All date?” Six. Alec cradles my face. “Why not? We’re in to see where it goes if you are.” Five. My heart is racing. The guys are surrounding me. Waiting for me to say something. Four. But if I say yes—it’s too complicated. Too hard to navigate in the real world. Sooner or later, someone will get jealous. Or what if I fall for one of them more than the others? Three. I don’t want to have my heart broken. Let alone by four guys. Two But if I say no… …I wake up tomorrow without them. “Yes. I say yes.” One. I yell it over the music, barely able to get it out before I’m attacked. Balloons and confetti fall around us as kisses cover my face, neck, and hands. I laugh, trying to get my bearings, and like the anchor he is, Cole puts his hand around my throat, locking my eyes on his. “The shiner was the price I paid to be first.”

Standing in the middle of the room are Jace, Reed, Alec, and Cole—wearing only boxer briefs and Santa hats. All of their delicious muscles are on display, beckoning for my tongue.

“Wanna let us tangle you up in some tinsel?”

“Cutie, we planned something special for you tonight.”

“More than Magic Mike—Santa edition?”

“Now you’ve done it. We’re gonna make you work for it tonight.”

“You, sunshine, have been a very bad girl. You made a mess all over my fingers. Forgot to ask nicely and decided to be a smart-ass at the start. So now I think we should teach you some manners. But don’t worry, tonight I’m going to make you come all over my dick. Then I’m going to feed it down your throat so you can taste my cum with yours.”

“And you’ll drink every fucking drop like the pretty slut you are.” “Oh my fucking god.”

“No. Me. Fuck me,” I pant, but Reed doesn’t relent, so I amp up my tempting, “Fuck my ass, come all over it. I’ll let you lick it off me while I suck Jace off. He can deep-throat me, so I choke on his dick. Please. I’ll let Alec and Reed fuck my pussy together. Oh god, please.”

“You wanna be Daddy’s dirty slut?” He smears the leftover over my lips. “Then you’ll earn it.”

“Bad manners deserve a spanking. Is that what you need? So that you can remember them again, baby.”

“I will light that pretty little ass up until your cunt drips down your fucking leg…” Everything pulses, especially my clit. “Now say yes, and I’ll let Alec clean it up?” “Yes,”

Alec pats his thigh, catching my attention. He’s calling me to him, telling me where to drape my body so Cole can punish me.

“That’s mine. And Reed’s… Cole’s, and Alec’s. If you want to use something that belongs to us, you have to ask permission. And you don’t have that. Do you, cutie?”

“We’ll make it feel so good, baby. Just trust us.”

“On your knees, Samantha… Don’t you want to crawl to him, baby?”

“Shh,” he soothes, running his fingers up my spine, “I’ve got you. If it’s too much, you just say stop and nobody will fucking touch you, gorgeous.”

“Open your mouth,” Jace directs. “Get it wet for me.”

“What do you say, Samantha,” Cole grinds. “Please.” “Wrong.” Another slap to my ass, and the guys become even wilder. Alec’s grip on me is going to leave a mark, and I’m clawing the arm of the chair because Reed and Jace are fighting for my mouth. They’re trying to fill it as spit gathers around the tips. “Oh fuck. That’s it, you fucking whore. Suck us both. You want to swallow that cum, sunshine.” Cole’s hand lands on my ass, again and again, fucking me harder and harder. I’m screaming around Reed’s cock, and Jace tugs his shaft in front of my face. We feel unleashed and unrestrained.

“What do you say, Samantha. What the fuck do you say,” as

you,” I exhale, “I say thank you.” “That’s our—Good. Fucking. Girl,” Cole bellows before lifting me to stand. He throws me over his shoulder as the others fall in, and I’m carried to the bedroom. “Now you get to come, baby”

“Gorgeous, I have something for you. I know you’re nervous about having us fucked that sweet pussy at the same time. You might talk a big game, but I’m going to help you back it up.”

“Use it on her until she can’t take anymore. Until she squirts, then we can fuck her into heaven.”

“Fuck, I want to see you squirt, see you all over my cock tonight,” Reed groans

“And you’ll get me, sunshine. This one sucks on your clit.”

“That’s it, gorgeous,” Alec praises. “You’re so beautiful. Every hole filled and fucked.”

Reed is fucking me without mercy, pounding into my pussy, stretching it for his cock. And Cole’s gripping my shoulders, ramming into me with his thick shaft, filling my ass as his body smacks into mine. Jace grinds into my mouth, his words heavy and deep.

“I’m almost there, cutie. Suck it. That’s it. Suck my cock. Let me fuck that throat. Oh fuck. Yes. I’m gonna fill your goddamn mouth with cum. Oh fuck. Oh fuck—” Jace grabs my face, pressing his dick deep to the back of my throat as warm cum spurts. My body explodes.

I feel Cole grips my ass before he growls, “You fucking take it,” before he bites my shoulder, coming inside of me. But I’m still exploding. My eyes roll back, and I gasp for air. Cole pulls out with a groan, and my screams turn into an unintelligible string of moans. How is this possible?

“Let us take you somewhere you’ve never been.” Reed’s voice cuts in, “I told you I’d make you feel so good. You’re a perfect little whore. Let us fuck you like one.”

I almost lose consciousness because both men, two rock-hard cocks, press inside my pussy.

“Oh fuck. You’re perfect, baby,” Alec moans as Reed’s words grind out through his teeth. “Yes, take it, you fucking slut. Gimme that pussy.”

“I want this pussy greedy for us. You don’t let a drop out, gorgeous.”

I blink, seeing Reed half-hard, glistening with his, Alec’s, and my cum, so I push myself up and bend over, taking his sensitive cock in my mouth. “Oh fuck.” He shudders. “Marry me.”

“You said you’d make me taste our cum. A promise is a promise.”

“Who’s taking her to Vegas? Because I call dibs,”

“The fuck you do,” Cole growls, “I got punched in the eye once for dibs… To call her yours would cost you an arm—”

“And a leg,” Jac...

“Hey, we love you. Forever.” “And always,”

Because he reaches inside, turns on the water, and winks at me as he says, “For old time’s sake?” while pulling the showerhead down.