Make Me Hate You
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between June 19 - June 20, 2025
1%
Flag icon
“This is me saying that I would set myself on fire to bring light to all of the dark places within you.”   – Beau Taplin
1%
Flag icon
I didn’t know a heart could break like that. I didn’t know it was possible to feel every sensation of your chest splitting wide open, of your heart bleeding out, without a single puncture wound being made.
5%
Flag icon
I didn’t know what it was to be wanted so desperately that each kiss felt like a fire searing every inch of skin covering my bones. I didn’t know what it was to tremble and shake, to be lowered back into pillows and sheets with hands so careful and confident that every other thought left my head completely. I didn’t know what it was to feel a mixture of extreme passion and somehow familiar safety all at once, to succumb to something so forbidden, and to love it like nothing I’d ever loved before.
11%
Flag icon
He was something between the boy I used to love and the man I’d never know, familiar and unreachable all at once.
11%
Flag icon
That’s what his gaze did to me, what it always had done. It stripped me bare.
14%
Flag icon
Except that she’d just asked me to dance with her brother, and the last time he’d touched me, I’d been so burned I still hadn’t fully recovered.
15%
Flag icon
And the moment our skin made contact, a flood rushed through me. It was searing hot. It was icy cold. It was all-encompassing and enough to send a wave of chills down every inch of my body as he pulled me closer, pulled me in, wrapped his other hand around my waist and settled his dark eyes on mine as we started to sway. I swore I’d never see that boy again, and now he had me in his arms — just like he did that night so long ago.
18%
Flag icon
All I wanted in that moment was to burn my graduation gown and the picture of me and my mother on my bedside table and the memory of Tyler’s hands on me and the entire town of Bridgechester, too.
18%
Flag icon
“You’re always beautiful. How’s my girl today?” My heart fluttered at his response, as it always did when he spoke to me. He revered me like a queen, it seemed, always showing me kindness and care. I’d never dated anyone like him, where there were no games, no pretenses of trying to play hard to get. We knew from the moment we met that we liked each other, and we didn’t bullshit. We dated, and became exclusive after a week, and from that moment on, I never had to wonder what I meant to him. Healthy relationships were weird.
18%
Flag icon
“I said win her over, not make her second in line to marry you if I don’t.” We both laughed at that, but I didn’t miss the way his forest green eyes watched me, curiously — like he was wondering if I’d been thinking about us like that. Thinking about marriage. Jacob and I had only been dating for a little over seven months, but I knew after just three that he was serious about his intentions with me. Whereas I was intent on going slow, having fun, enjoying just dating, I could feel his need for more as time passed. He’d casually brought up what kind of ring I would want, how I would want to be ...more
20%
Flag icon
Tonight is the joint bachelor-bachelorette party, and we have a lot to do.” “Joint parties, huh?” Jacob smiled. “Can’t bear to be parted from Oliver for even one night.” “We have the most fun when we’re together,” she said easily, as if nothing else made sense. “Why wouldn’t we want to celebrate our wedding together as opposed to being apart?” Jacob smiled even more genuinely then, and his deep green eyes found mine, like he understood completely.
22%
Flag icon
It reminded me of high school, sneaking wine coolers from her mom’s stash and dancing in her backyard or out on the dock by the lake. It reminded me of long, hot summer nights in the pool with her and Ty, staying up until the sun rose again, the days blurring together. And it made my chest hurt with the longing to go back to those days, to that specific day, and to never cross the line with Ty. I wondered what it would have been like if Morgan would have been in her room that day my mom left, if I would have found her instead of Tyler, if nothing would have ever changed between us. I stopped ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
23%
Flag icon
And when I looked at him, every thought I’d been trying to shake off came back full force. I looked into the eyes of the man I didn’t know, of the boy I used to know better than anyone, of the friend I’d lost. Of the friend who’d hurt me.
26%
Flag icon
And that I thought back to him, too — to that day in his room, to the way his skin was hot and sticky with sunscreen, to the way his lips were warm on mine, to the way it felt to be touched by him. But what was the point? He hadn’t been able to heal the wound my mother left. No one could do that but me. And when it came to what happened between me and him, it was even more pointless to bring up. Because he’d taken it all back. He’d said it was a mistake, that he was sorry, that he never meant for it to happen. A day that had killed me and also brought me to life within hours meant nothing to ...more
29%
Flag icon
Tyler’s eyes were a golden-brown in the evening light, a shade I hadn’t seen in years. I remembered it though. I remembered the way those little flecks of gold lit up when the sun was angled like this, from summer nights so long ago that they seemed like another lifetime.
30%
Flag icon
Tyler laughed at the last of my message, but his eyes were light and playful when they met mine. It felt… good — to talk to him, to not be at each other’s throats. It felt warm and comfortable and right. It felt the way it used to when we were younger.
37%
Flag icon
All that mattered was that I locked eyes with Tyler Wagner, and I asked him the question that had kept me awake for seven long years. “Why did you ignore me the day after my mom left?” All the color drained from Tyler’s face, and for the longest time, he just stared at me, unblinking. Then, he blew out a long breath, shaking his head and tearing his gaze from me. “Don’t do this, Jaz.” “I deserve to know.” He sighed, his eyes falling to his sneakers, and I felt a mixture of anger and betrayal bubbling up inside me like a volcano. Suddenly, I didn’t want to be out here, laughing and reminiscing ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
39%
Flag icon
“I know what happened between you and Tyler.” All the color drained from my face. “I’m sorry I didn’t say something before now,” she rushed. “I just… he told me in confidence, and I knew you were hurt over your mom, and I didn’t want to bring up something that obviously meant nothing, and I figured you’d be embarrassed.” She kept going, but my mind was sticking on the words tumbling from her mouth at a hundred miles per hour. He told me. Meant nothing. Embarrassed. “… bring it up, you know? But then you guys just stopped talking, and you never came home, and I missed you and I missed us and I ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
40%
Flag icon
Tyler told Morgan. Morgan knew, all this time. And it was her who told him he was wrong, that he shouldn’t have done what he did, that I wasn’t ready. Was that why he took it back? Was that it all along? Did he tell me it was a mistake, that it didn’t matter, all because Morgan told him I wasn’t ready, that I wasn’t okay, that I wasn’t in the right head space to make decisions? And he had a crush on me? Why didn’t he ever tell me that? How did I never see it? Is everything I thought about what we were, about what happened between us, a lie? Question after question assaulted me, not just at the ...more
41%
Flag icon
Why did I never ask him? Why did I just run? Why didn’t I go back to him, hold his face in my hands, and demand that he tell me why he was pushing me away? Why didn’t I refuse to leave, refuse to accept that that night meant nothing to him when I knew it meant something to me? Another pang of guilt found me when I realized where my thoughts were wrapped up again. Because I understood why Tyler did what he did, but it didn’t absolve him in my mind. It pissed me off. I was furious for him, for me, for what we maybe could have had.
41%
Flag icon
“I also discovered today that I am a terrible person,” I whispered into the microphone. “I guess we all are, aren’t we? At least, when we really break ourselves down to the molecular level. When we push aside all the sunshine and bullshit, and look good and hard at who we are, at the decisions we make, at the things we feel — things we would never say out loud or confess to anyone else.” I shook my head, eyes losing focus where I stared at the shape of the recording, a flat line now that I wasn’t speaking, a little green spike when I began again. “Maybe, at the core of every human being, ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
43%
Flag icon
At that, I huffed, leaning over to snatch his wrist in my hand and tug him out the door. “Just come on.” That earned me a chuckle, and I felt that vibration all the way through my ribcage and to the very core of who I was. That dark, monstrous core.
44%
Flag icon
Maybe it was working. Maybe I could break down that barrier, after all. Maybe, we really could be friends.
46%
Flag icon
He stepped into me, and I swallowed, tilting my chin up as my heart pounded so hard that I knew he could feel it through the veins in my neck. I knew he could feel how I trembled under his touch, how I shivered from the rain and the wind and the tornado that he had always been in my life. Back away. Pull away. Stop this right now. But I couldn’t. I felt the heat of his breath on my lips, and I gasped, parting my own, feeling the most intense mixture of warning and desperation swirling within me that I had ever felt in my life. It was elemental, primal, powerful. Unstoppable. His hands slipped ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
50%
Flag icon
He smiled, but it slipped quickly. “You’re a warrior.” I chuckled, glancing out the window as Boston faded away and we continued south. “I don’t feel like a warrior,” I confessed. “Most times, I feel like a lost little girl, like I’m trying to find my way home but keep coming up short.” Tyler nodded when I looked at him. “I know that feeling,” he said softly.
50%
Flag icon
He paused, chewing the inside of his lip as he thought, and the way the sun came through the windows of the truck, the way his hair was disheveled and unruly, the way the Sagamore bridge sprawled before us, welcoming us to the Cape as it always did — it grounded me like nothing ever had before. My stomach tightened at the warmth of it, at being in a car with the boy I grew up with, heading back to a place where we had made so many memories.
51%
Flag icon
Now that we knew what we did, now that we’d cleared the air, now that I knew he wanted me back then just as much as I’d wanted him — it wasn’t the same. I couldn’t be just friends with him. And I couldn’t be more. Which meant we only had one option of what we could be. Nothing. And that word sank into my skin like a tattoo with each new mile we drove, until I could no longer ignore it or pretend it wasn’t true.
52%
Flag icon
“Okay,” I said, glancing at the waves crashing on the beach behind the cottage with a longing sigh. I hadn’t been back on the Cape since the summer before senior year when I’d come with Morgan and her family, and being back was already flooding me with memories of my last summer as a kid. My last summer with Morgan and Tyler. Part of me wanted to run to the beach, or to our favorite ice cream joint, or to the old lighthouse we loved to climb after dark. I wanted to run back in time, to that summer, to that girl I had once been. But Morgan’s mom was right — I was exhausted, in more ways than ...more
52%
Flag icon
Jacob was my person. He was my everything, and had been for months. How could I have lost sight of that? How could I have so easily let him slip from my mind, filling that space with the one boy I’d sworn I would forget? I wanted to cry. I wanted to scream. I wanted to throw myself out the window just to save everyone in my life from the disaster I’d become.
53%
Flag icon
I knew exactly how to move, how to rub my clit against the firm edge of the pillow just right. The orgasm was already building before even a full minute had passed, and I picked up the pace, desperate to reach my climax. Tingles shot like sparks in my chest, firing through my nervous system to every part of my body. Just a few more flexes and I knew I’d come. And as soon as the recognition hit me, my dream assaulted me like a whip, cracking against my back, my inner thighs, my heavy and swollen breasts. The pillow between my legs was suddenly Tyler, and a soft moan broke through me at the ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
53%
Flag icon
I sighed, shaking my head and climbing out of bed to clean myself up. After a short, cold shower and a fresh change of clothes, I crawled back into bed having convinced myself that it wasn’t a big deal. So what, I masturbated thinking of Tyler. People masturbated to things they couldn’t have all the time — to porn, to visions of their exes, to celebrities, whatever. It was completely normal, and it didn’t mean a damn thing. Somewhere between that thought and me slipping back into sleep, I thought I heard a thump against the wall lining my headboard, and a groan of a man giving into temptation. ...more
56%
Flag icon
It was too late. Those were the words that flashed like little caution lights in my mind as I ran, my legs burning, chest aching, breath coming shorter and shallower with every new step. It was too late to be out for a run on the beach. It was too late to be out and alone, period. It was too late to be awake when I had another full day of wedding activities tomorrow. And it was too late to ever have a relationship with Tyler Wagner.
56%
Flag icon
I’d woken with the determination to stay far away from Tyler, to let him go, to let the past go. And instead, I’d been forced to walk down the aisle to him, to pretend to be his bride, to let him take my hands in his and stare into my eyes and not say a single word but say everything I’d ever wanted to hear, too. It was impossible in that moment to not picture it, to not wonder what it could have been like, what we could have been like. And it knifed me open, right down the middle, spilling my guts with irreparable damage. I sucked in a harsh breath, running faster, as if that would help me. ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
56%
Flag icon
It was a fog impossible to fight through, but more than anything and at the root of it all — I hated myself. Because all it had taken to show my true, dark, and fucked-up morals was one trip back home. And one thing I knew for sure, one truth swimming low and acidic in my gut, was that I had to call Jacob tomorrow. And I had to break up with him. It didn’t matter that Tyler had a girlfriend, that our time had passed, that we would never be together. It didn’t matter that, surely, it was being here that was messing with my mind, and had I stayed in California, none of this would have happened. ...more
57%
Flag icon
And in that silent, dark moment on the beach, I felt the universe inside me shift. And I knew things would never be the same.
57%
Flag icon
Perhaps I’d sensed him, or always known he’d be there — like no matter how far or fast I ran, it’d always be him I’d come back to.
57%
Flag icon
“You okay?” Something of a laugh left my nose at that, and then my eyes welled with tears. I shook my head, casting my gaze over the dark water again. “No,” I whispered, and the fight was useless against the first two tears that fell hot down my cheeks. “I am far from okay.” Tyler pushed off the banister at once, his arms reaching for me, but I backed away like he was poison, nearly falling in the process. He stopped, holding up his hands as I crossed my arms over my middle. “Don’t,” I warned, shaking my head. “Come here.” “Please, don’t touch me.” “How can I not?” he asked, stepping toward me ...more
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
57%
Flag icon
“Please,” I begged, fisting my hands in his shirt to hold him closer but still trying to shove him away. “Please, just make me hate you.” Tyler’s knuckles found my chin, and he tilted it until I was staring up at him through wet lashes. Just the sight of the pain in his eyes made another surge of emotion assault my chest, and I winced, rolling my lips to fight off more tears. “Only if you make me hate you first.” Tyler stilled when the words came from his lips, and I tilted my head, confused. But before I could ask him what he meant, he grabbed my chin and crashed his mouth to mine. That kiss… ...more
58%
Flag icon
When we were alone, he stood across from me, chest heaving, eyes devouring me like he was a wolf and I was his prey.
58%
Flag icon
The first time Tyler touched me, all those years ago, it was with gentle reverence. He’d handled me like a girl with a broken heart, which was exactly what I was. His kisses had been slow and soft, his hands hesitant and trembling, and I could still remember the look in his eyes when he laid me back and entered me for the first time. They were wide, careful, sensitive, longing and pure. But Tyler didn’t take me gently tonight. Tonight, he punished me with every kiss, with every bite, with every tight grasp. It must have been true, what he’d said on the beach — he wanted to hate me, too. And I ...more
59%
Flag icon
“No,” he commanded. “Don’t get shy on me now, Jazzy. I want to see you. Open those legs for me.” Fuck.
59%
Flag icon
I moaned at the sight of him stripping off his shorts and freeing his erection. It sprang forward, thick and long, and when he wrapped one fist around it with his eyes still watching me, I panted, my hand sliding down to rub my aching clit. “Jesus Christ,” he said, still stroking himself as he moved toward me. “You were touching yourself like that last night, weren’t you?” My hand stilled, just for the pause of shock registering through me. He smirked, still moving slowly toward me. “You fucking were. I heard you, your deep moans and hushed cries of pleasure. I thought it was a dream, but it ...more
59%
Flag icon
“Fuck, it’s hot how turned on you are right now.” “Please, Tyler,” I begged, and I swear, I’d never begged for anything in the bedroom before in my life. But I needed him, and I didn’t even know what I needed first — his fingers inside me? His mouth on my clit? His cock buried so deep I could see the stars? I wanted it all, all at once. I needed him to consume me like a black hole. I desired nothing more than to die by his touch.
60%
Flag icon
I trailed my fingers up to his tip, spreading the bead of pre-cum there over the sensitive skin before I wrapped my fist around him again and felt him flex into it. “That’s it, baby,” I whispered against his mouth. “Fuck my hand like you fucked your own last night.”
60%
Flag icon
“Please.” Another plea. Another desperate call to fill me, to claim me, to ruin me. And this time, he answered.
60%
Flag icon
We hadn’t even thought about a condom, hadn’t even considered that it could ever be anything but just all of him inside all of me. Raw. Bare. Violent.
61%
Flag icon
Tyler slowed then, filling me softly and purposefully, inch by blissful inch. And when his thumb pressed hot and hard into my clit, circling it in time with his thrusts, I came fast in a throbbing, pillow-biting, all-encompassing explosion of stars. That orgasm wasn’t just physical, though I felt it invading every centimeter of my skin, my muscles, my nervous system, my being. But it didn’t stop there — it seeped into my heart and into my soul like a hot, persistent flood, filling every crack and hole and hollow emptiness. It was complete and total devastation. And I was bound to him.
61%
Flag icon
I knew his hands would bruise my hips, that his teeth had left marks on my neck, that I’d forever feel an emptiness from where he was inside me now — but I didn’t care. I loved it. I craved it. I wanted more, more, more — all of him, all of this, all of us. It was wrong. It was betrayal. It was everything we were never supposed to do. But when Tyler thrust into me again and again, then three final, hard times, filling me up completely before he pulled out and stroked his orgasm out until it spilled hot on my ass, I knew we’d take whatever punishment, whatever hell we’d wake up to the next ...more
61%
Flag icon
Tyler Wagner was in bed with me, and everything about waking up next to him felt good and right and real.
61%
Flag icon
“Fuck, Jasmine,” he said, touching places on my neck, my collarbone, my hips and thighs. “God. I’m so sorry. It looks like I fucking mauled you.” I blushed, giggling and wrapping my arms around his neck. His brows were still furrowed when he met my gaze, but I just reached up to press my lips to his. We both inhaled at the contact, sweet, content sighs coming from our chests in the next breath. “It was the best mauling of my life,” I whispered.
« Prev 1