Dungeon Calamity (The Divine Dungeon, #3)
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between October 18 - October 19, 2019
26%
Flag icon
Dale finally issued the orders.
Jeremy McLeod
Again, don't describe the dialog he JUST SAID. Lead with this or change it to a non-descriptive phrase, like, "he eventually said." We know they were orders. We were "there" when he gave them.
26%
Flag icon
in an enclosed area like the council room!”
Jeremy McLeod
Drop "in an enclosed area like." It's enough that it's the council room.
26%
Flag icon
when
Jeremy McLeod
as
26%
Flag icon
He slowly stopped panicking
Jeremy McLeod
Bit of an overstatement
26%
Flag icon
thread as
Jeremy McLeod
Comma between these words
26%
Flag icon
sputter and take in the whole scene.
Jeremy McLeod
Pretty sure he took in the full scene before that.
26%
Flag icon
“It. Ahhh. It worked.”
Jeremy McLeod
This is what ellipses were MADE FOR. "It... ah, worked?"
27%
Flag icon
There were many people that had arrived today, and the meeting had a far higher attendance than usual.
Jeremy McLeod
"Thanks to all the new arrivals, there were far more people in attendance than usual."
27%
Flag icon
but the noise was not fully silenced.
Jeremy McLeod
Yes, that's what "quieted a bit" means, thanks. Cut down on the redundancy.
27%
Flag icon
“How do you ever get things done?” She snorted rudely, looking at the others in her delegation with mirth. “This is ridiculous. A man can’t be in charge. We should go.”
Jeremy McLeod
Where the hell is this coming from? We're in the third book now and this is the first time you've mentioned any kind of matriarchical bias to any culture. reading on, obviously an amazon culture, but i shouldn't have to be confused for two pages. You could have someone lean over and whisper "she's part of the amazon delegation" or something just so it immediately makes sense.
27%
Flag icon
“Enough!” Frank bellowed, slamming his hand on to the table. “Elves! You got here first! State your reasons for attending this meeting. Please!”
Jeremy McLeod
Frank must have no points in diplomacy, because you don't angrily berate diplomats to state their purposes unless you're at war, even if you say please at the end. This should be Frank shutting down the quarreling, collecting himself, then politely asking the elves to proceed.
27%
Flag icon
about a heavily propagated
Jeremy McLeod
"an apparently reliable rumor"
27%
Flag icon
His eyes held no hint of anything but happiness as he was speaking.
Jeremy McLeod
This is just awkward writing
27%
Flag icon
The joyful face twisted into a hateful mask. “The Darkies? You went to them?”
Jeremy McLeod
I know they're bitter enemies, but I'd still have to assume that an ambassador for the HIGH ELVES wouldn't resort to racial epithets in an official meeting.
27%
Flag icon
Dale calmly replied as the High Elf seemed to be having a breakdown.
Jeremy McLeod
Comma after "replied"
28%
Flag icon
“They, at least, didn’t waltz in here and threaten to kill me! I’ll agree to whatever terms the Dark Elves negotiate on my behalf. Have fun with that! Good day to you!”
Jeremy McLeod
While emotionally satisfying, that was REALLY DUMB
29%
Flag icon
as they got jokingly dirty looks
Jeremy McLeod
If you MUST say that the dirty looks weren't serious, try "mock" instead of "jokingly."
29%
Flag icon
“How about snackies?” Stonewall giggled drunkenly, smacking his lips loudly after finishing his pint.
Jeremy McLeod
Is this guy an actual idiot or not? Half the time he talks normally, the other half he's Brick from Anchorman.
29%
Flag icon
Hansel bread? Khee-hee, Hansel Bread. Like gingerbread. Thatsh your new nickname.”
Jeremy McLeod
Where the hell did "bread" come from here?
30%
Flag icon
it seems you are a natural!”
Jeremy McLeod
This feels like it should have been among the first things said, not the last.
31%
Flag icon
make the arrow spin in place ten times faster than feathers allow for,
Jeremy McLeod
"…make the arrow spin ten times faster than the fletching alone,"
31%
Flag icon
Enchantment but
Jeremy McLeod
Comma between these words
31%
Flag icon
Next, he pulled out a small net that was sewn to be a bag filled with a plant.
Jeremy McLeod
What? TERRIBLE desciption. "...pulled out a small, netted bag filled with leaves."
31%
Flag icon
that was
Jeremy McLeod
Unnecessary
32%
Flag icon
away by the piddling God
Jeremy McLeod
For all your references the clerics, priests, and celestial/infernal energy, you've barely even mentioned whether the dominant cultures are mono-or-poly-theistic. We have no dogma to reference, which makes it seem like this guy is just personally peeved about mortality.
32%
Flag icon
“Now, shall we begin!” he roared, not as a question but as a way to rile up the awaiting fiends.
Jeremy McLeod
Even if he's just whipping up the crowd, it's still a question, and thus REQUIRES A QUESTION MARK. If you just put their reaction right after "he roared," as in "…he roared, and their answering cries of 'sacrifice him!' were loud enough to shake dust from the ceiling."
32%
Flag icon
all, nay,
Jeremy McLeod
Semicolon after "all"
32%
Flag icon
the eagerly awaiting heart
Jeremy McLeod
Is his physical heart truly "eagerly awaiting?"
32%
Flag icon
The Master
Jeremy McLeod
Don't capitalize "the."
32%
Flag icon
maroon
Jeremy McLeod
I know maroon can look intimidating, but the WORD maroon does not. There are lots of cool-sounding color words (crimson? eldritch? arcane? sinister? puce? [kidding, don't use puce.])
32%
Flag icon
The person she was referencing was hidden behind a grove of trees
Jeremy McLeod
"The person she was indicating had hidden themselves behind..."
32%
Flag icon
Her frustration was boiling over with this maddening man!
Jeremy McLeod
Again, you haven't been writing in third person omniscient, so if you waant to talk about someone's reaction, you've got to do it from the POV of the chapter's narrative character (e.g. Dale, Cal, or Dani.) Also, don't use exclamation points in prose. It's amateurish.
32%
Flag icon
happily surprised by this development.
Jeremy McLeod
"pleasantly surprised by its increased efficacy."
33%
Flag icon
which
Jeremy McLeod
That, not which
33%
Flag icon
as the bowstring tried to send it off.
Jeremy McLeod
"…as soon as she released the bowstring."
33%
Flag icon
happily spouted,
Jeremy McLeod
You pick the weirdest adverb + speaking verb choices
33%
Flag icon
Impossibly, it twisted again, landing on its feet and seeming to glare at Rose.
Jeremy McLeod
You said it was knocked back, not into the air, so there's nothing to land from.
33%
Flag icon
array of potential movement,
Jeremy McLeod
Array implies multipl but movement is singular. Maybe motions instead?
35%
Flag icon
so I was confused.
Jeremy McLeod
Ok, Keanu. "…which meant something here wasn't adding up."
35%
Flag icon
Alter reality with the plants!
Jeremy McLeod
Alter REALITY? And with THE plants?
35%
Flag icon
for celestial sake!
Jeremy McLeod
See, Cal doesn't even use God for this, so why is the necromancer the only one talking about god?
35%
Flag icon
the intensive exhaustion I was feeling was trying to get me to pass on to eternal slumber.
Jeremy McLeod
The exhaustion was trying?
35%
Flag icon
‘I am creation! I am the brush that forms a line, the hammer that beats the iron, the chisel that shapes the stone. I am creativity, and insight, and thoughtfulness. To bring into the world, to make something new, is my purpose. Step on my path, join to me, and it will be your purpose as well.’
Jeremy McLeod
Nicely written.
35%
Flag icon
I am what brings together others.
Jeremy McLeod
Maybe "brings others together"?
36%
Flag icon
I am Kings and Queens.
Jeremy McLeod
What?
36%
Flag icon
Soon you will be telling me your Name, and we will be the best of friends!>
Jeremy McLeod
You really need to work on your confrontational banter
36%
Flag icon
again but
Jeremy McLeod
Comma between these words
36%
Flag icon
various
Jeremy McLeod
Magical? Just not various.
36%
Flag icon
as Dani became speechless.
Jeremy McLeod
Became speechless? You can do better.
41%
Flag icon
believe
Jeremy McLeod
Believed