One year later, Chevie was convicted in the 1996 triple homicide of a young family, including an eight-year-old girl, and sentenced to three consecutive life sentences. I know them, Keyes said. I grew up with them. Tammie was stunned. The Kehoes were terrifying. She wanted to know: Were you friends? Were they part of your church? Were they violent? Did you believe the same things? Did you ever do anything bad with them? Keyes would only give Tammie vague answers and shoulder shrugs. He made it very clear: I don’t want to talk about this. And not wanting to get into a fight, Tammie let it go.
