This trial, like many RCTs, faced the problem of noncompliance, when subjects randomized to receive a drug don’t actually take it. This will reduce the apparent effectiveness of the drug, so we may want to adjust the results to account for the noncompliers. But as always, confounding rears its ugly head. If the noncompliers are different from the compliers in some relevant way (maybe they are sicker to start with?), we cannot predict how they would have responded had they adhered to instructions.