Andy Weir

8%
Flag icon
Then something Tookish woke up inside him, and he wished to go and see the great mountains, and hear the pine-trees and the waterfalls, and explore the caves, and wear a sword instead of a walking-stick.
Andy Weir
Okay, I’ll blaspheme for a moment here: This is a case where the film is actually better than the book. I often run into the frustration of explaining beautiful sounds in prose. You can use whatever colorful language you want but, in the end, the reader just doesn’t get to hear it. So in the film, we were treated to a moving, dirge-like song from the dwarves and it was fantastic. Still, Tolkien was a master of this. The song moves Bilbo so much he envisions himself an adventurer and has a sudden desire to explore and fight evil foes – the complete opposite of his normal personality. The feeling passes as quickly as it came but it is a great way to demonstrate how powerful the song is.
Joe Pace
· Flag
Joe Pace
And the Rankin-Bass scene even better. That animated film captures the atmospherics of The Hobbit far better than Jackson’s bloated trilogy.
greatgrayprairie
· Flag
greatgrayprairie
I think that Bilbo was seeing the Dwarves as his friends for the first time. He had had help in the scullery and I think he was feeling equal with them.
Kevin Rosero
· Flag
Kevin Rosero
Agreed, both the Peter Jackson and Rankin Bass surpassed the book here
The Hobbit (Middle Earth, #0)
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview