There’s a curious withdrawal—apparently P. J. Beese and Todd Cameron Hamilton’s novel The Guardian, which I have neither read nor previously heard of, had enough votes for a nomination, but the administrators concluded that the votes were bloc votes and disqualified them. Locus says, “A group of enthusiastic New York area fans was later discovered to be responsible for the votes, exonerating Beese and Hamilton.” Whatever was going on, it’s not in print and not in the library, and I’d say it has sunk pretty much without a trace.
