At least the following seem crucial: • The ability to think well about political issues affecting the nation, to examine, reflect, argue, and debate, deferring to neither tradition nor authority • The ability to recognize fellow citizens as people with equal rights, even though they may be different in race, religion, gender, and sexuality: to look at them with respect, as ends, not just as tools to be manipulated for one’s own profit • The ability to have concern for the lives of others, to grasp what policies of many types mean for the opportunities and experiences of one’s fellow
...more

