No God but One: Allah or Jesus?: A Former Muslim Investigates the Evidence for Islam and Christianity
Rate it:
Open Preview
7%
Flag icon
Perhaps the most surprising shared feature is reverence for Jesus. Both Islam and Christianity teach that Jesus was born of a virgin and that he was the most miraculous man who ever lived. Both the Bible and the Quran teach that Jesus cleansed lepers, healed the blind, and even raised the dead. Indeed, both books teach that Jesus is the Messiah, and Muslims await his return, as do Christians.
7%
Flag icon
According to Islam, the way to paradise is sharia, a code of laws to follow that will please Allah and earn his favor. Sharia is literally translated “the way.”
34%
Flag icon
In Clermont, France, on November 27, AD 1095, Pope Urban II issued the First Crusade. He goaded Christians into traveling from Western Europe to the Middle East, where Muslims had lived for over 450 years, in order to fight against the “infidels” and “barbarians,” “an accursed race wholly alienated from God.”
Christian Ongtangco
1st crusade
36%
Flag icon
Still, I was convinced that no one should judge a religion by its followers.
36%
Flag icon
In my mind, there were only two people whose behavior mattered: Muhammad and Jesus.
36%
Flag icon
In 1268, Sultan Baybars I, a Muslim notoriously known as the Lion of Egypt, taunted a Christian ruler whose city had just been conquered in the latter’s absence. Baybars vividly describes what Count Bohemond VI would have seen had he been present in Antioch:
Christian Ongtangco
Sultan Baybars
36%
Flag icon
Just a few years before Pope Urban II called the First Crusade, the Seljuq Turks had conquered Nicaea, the same city where, 750 years prior, Constantine had convened the church’s First Ecumenical Council. The Seljuq Turks were Sunni Muslims, and they had taken Nicaea from the Byzantine emperor, a Christian. It was he, the Byzantine emperor, who asked Pope Urban II for help defending his lands at the Council of Piacenza in 1095. In other words, Muslims were actively attacking and conquering Christians, and the First Crusade was a defensive effort.
Christian Ongtangco
First crusade was defensive efforts.
36%
Flag icon
The Seljuq army contained warriors called mamluks, slave children who were trained to ultimately become young professional fighters.
Christian Ongtangco
Mamluks are young christian trained to kil other christians.
36%
Flag icon
This means Muslim rulers were capturing Christian boys and turning them into slave warriors to fight against other Christians.7
37%
Flag icon
By the time the Byzantine emperor asked for the pope’s help, two-thirds of the Christian world had been captured by Muslims.
37%
Flag icon
Your brethren who live in the east are in urgent need of your help, and you must hasten to give them the aid which has often been promised them. For, as most of you have heard, the Turks and Arabs have attacked them . . . and have overcome them in seven battles. They have killed and captured many, and have destroyed the churches and devastated the empire.
37%
Flag icon
The reality is that the Crusades were launched in defense of the Byzantine Empire after two-thirds of the Christian world had been conquered by centuries of Muslim attacks. Muslims understood this and held no grudge against crusaders until modern times, when postcolonial narratives came into vogue.
Christian Ongtangco
Byzantine empire
38%
Flag icon
All the same, I do not think a religion ought to be judged on the basis of some of its followers. The actions of some Christians do not necessarily say anything about Christianity, and the actions of some Muslims do not necessarily say anything about Islam.
Christian Ongtangco
Followers - Religion generalization.
39%
Flag icon
Quranic verses such as 2.256, which says, “There is no compulsion in religion.”
Christian Ongtangco
No compulsion of faith
39%
Flag icon
When we turn to the example of Muhammad’s life, we find multiple accounts of Muhammad not just allowing sex slavery but also encouraging Muslims who were hesitant to use their newly captured women for sexual intercourse.
Christian Ongtangco
Sex slaves
39%
Flag icon
The hadith say that this is the very reason why 4.24 of the Quran was revealed, so that men would not be hesitant to have sex with female captives whose husbands were still alive.
40%
Flag icon
Delineating stringent conditions of war, Augustine argued that fighting could be within the will of God, but it remained a necessary evil and something that required penance.
Christian Ongtangco
Augustine's penance
40%
Flag icon
So it was not until the Crusades, over a thousand years after Jesus, that Christians saw holy war as a positive endeavor that, instead of being a sin requiring penance,
Christian Ongtangco
wrong perspective
41%
Flag icon
The sword that Jesus brings is a machaira. Like a machete, a machaira is a long knife or a short sword designed as a multipurpose tool, such as cutting meat or cleaning fish. Also like a machete, a machaira can be used for fighting, but it is not its only or primary purpose. Its primary purpose is to divide, and here Jesus says his coming is as a machaira to divide families.
Christian Ongtangco
Sword that divides
41%
Flag icon
Now that we know what a machaira is, the answer is simple: He was telling them to be prepared for a long journey and to take along the appropriate tools. Context is helpful again:
41%
Flag icon
According to the Quran, polytheists are given three options: convert to Islam, depart from the land, or be killed (e.g., Quran 9.3–11).
41%
Flag icon
9.5 says, “Kill the polytheists wherever you find them, and seize them, and besiege them, and wait for them at every place of ambush.
42%
Flag icon
to 4.34 of the Quran, which allows men to hit their disobedient wives,
43%
Flag icon
I believed that Allah was loving, that Muhammad was peaceful, that the Quran was beautiful, that tawhid was the perfect doctrine, and that truly following sharia made one righteous before Allah. I did not feel any need for the gospel, and I certainly did not see it as a superior message.
Christian Ongtangco
What every muslim believes in.
44%
Flag icon
It was an organic flow from one topic to the next, covering issues as they arose in the course of our friendship.
Christian Ongtangco
Through friendship
44%
Flag icon
What defines Christianity at its core, and what defines Islam?
Christian Ongtangco
The focus of investigation
44%
Flag icon
Romans 10:9: “If you declare with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved” (NIV). Here we found the entire gospel message formulated as the minimum requirement for saving faith. It has three components: (1) that Jesus died, (2) that he rose from the dead, and (3) that he is God.1
Christian Ongtangco
The Gospel is Jesus
44%
Flag icon
if someone were to say, “I am God,” we would think them crazy; but if they were to then say, “I will prove my claim by rising from the dead,” and then they actually were to rise from the dead, we would have good reason to believe them. This is exactly what Jesus says the resurrection is for.2
Christian Ongtangco
Jesus claiming He is God
45%
Flag icon
Jesus’ death by crucifixion Jesus’ resurrection from the dead Jesus’ claim to be God The prophetic authority of Muhammad The divine inspiration of the Quran
Christian Ongtangco
Case for Islam and Christianity
45%
Flag icon
When skeptics challenged Muhammad to provide evidence for his claims, the primary proof he provided was the inspiration of the Quran.4 Repeatedly, at least five times, he offered the divine origin of the Quran as the reason why people should trust Islam. By contrast, when the early Christians proclaimed the gospel, the primary proof that they pointed to was the resurrection of Jesus, not the text of the Bible.5
Christian Ongtangco
Proofs
45%
Flag icon
What is difficult is pursuing the truth about your faith and assessing it honestly.
Christian Ongtangco
Pursuing the truth
46%
Flag icon
What Really Happened to Jesus, Lüdemann critically reexamines the life of Jesus from many angles, often dismissing the traditional Christian position outright. But in his section titled “The death of Jesus,” he spares only two sentences: “The fact of the death of Jesus as a consequence of crucifixion is indisputable, despite hypotheses of a pseudo-death or a deception which are sometimes put forward. It need not be discussed further here.”2 He then moves on, as if lingering on the matter were pointless.
46%
Flag icon
“The single most solid fact about Jesus’ life is his death: he was executed by the Roman prefect Pilate, on or around Passover, in the manner Rome reserved particularly for political insurrectionists, namely, crucifixion.”3
46%
Flag icon
John Dominic Crossan, who says, “There is not the slightest doubt about the fact of Jesus’ crucifixion under Pontius Pilate.”4 As if that were not emphatic enough, he elsewhere states, “That he was crucified is as sure as anything historical can ever be.”5
46%
Flag icon
The evidence for Jesus’ death by crucifixion is so strong that virtually every scholar who studies Jesus’ life believes it.
46%
Flag icon
Zealot, Reza Aslan made it abundantly clear that Jesus “was most definitely crucified.”7 Aslan is one of the most well-known Muslim scholars in the West, and on account of the historical evidence, he also believes that Jesus died on the cross, despite what the Quran teaches. He believes so strongly in Jesus’ death by crucifixion that he uses it as the foundation for his entire theory of Jesus’ life.
47%
Flag icon
By all standards of ancient history, the reports of Jesus are very early and very diverse. Starting just a few years after Jesus’ crucifixion, Christians, Jews, and Romans report that Jesus died by crucifixion. The testimony is unanimous for over one hundred years.
47%
Flag icon
1 Corinthians 15 contains a creed that was formulated within five years of Jesus’ crucifixion, and it testifies that Jesus died and was buried: “For what I received I passed on to you as of first importance: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried .
Christian Ongtangco
Within 5 years after Jesus' crucifixion
47%
Flag icon
It is critical to understand the import of this data: Before the New Testament was even written, Christians were passing down to one another the core doctrines of their faith, and the death of Jesus was among their first concerns. Not only was the teaching present in the very earliest days of Christianity, but also it was a central component of their doctrine.
Christian Ongtangco
Doctrines passed down before New testament was completed.
47%
Flag icon
sheer presence of bias is not reason enough to discredit reports. We would have to throw out all of history, indeed all news reports and personal stories from friends, if that were the case. Second, these sources are written by people of various backgrounds, and generally speaking, they did not start their lives as Christians. Though originally non-Christians, they found the Christian message convincing enough to convert, often at great cost. Therefore, if anything, their testimony may be granted an extra measure of credibility.9
47%
Flag icon
Josephus, the failed Jewish general who befriended the Roman emperor, also reports in the first century that Jesus died by crucifixion. He is joined shortly after by Tacitus, a Roman historian who also reports Jesus’ death.
Christian Ongtangco
Historians and Josephus
47%
Flag icon
In the first one hundred years after Jesus, we have Christian, Jewish, and Roman reports that Jesus died by crucifixion, and not a single report that he may not have died by crucifixion.
Christian Ongtangco
First 100 years
47%
Flag icon
Simply put, the cross was one of the most vicious, torturous, and effective methods of execution that human depravity has ever devised. The torment of the cross was so extreme that a word was invented to describe it: excruciating, which translates from Latin to describe a pain “from the cross.”
Christian Ongtangco
Excruciating
47%
Flag icon
“Can anyone be found who would prefer wasting away in pain, dying limb by limb, or letting out his life drop by drop, rather than expiring once for all? Can any man be found willing to be fastened to the accursed tree, long sickly, already deformed, swelling with ugly tumours on chest and shoulders, and draw the breath of life amid long-drawn-out agony? I think he would have many excuses for dying even before mounting the cross!”12
Christian Ongtangco
Why would he do it?
47%
Flag icon
Victims were at times fixed to the cross in awkward poses, at times nailed through their groins, at times forced to watch the violation of their wives, at times made to witness the slaughter of their whole families, and at times having their slain sons hung around their necks.13 Crucifixion was not just another means of execution, as there are much more efficient ways to kill. The cross was intended for brutality, and victims were not treated gently.
Christian Ongtangco
My savior did it for us.
48%
Flag icon
The ultimate end of crucifixion was execution, and it was easy to determine whether victims of the cross were alive or dead: Simply observe whether they were still moving. If they were not, they were dead, because it meant they were not breathing. On account of the way crucifixion victims were made to hang, their rib cages were fully expanded and their lungs could not generate the pressure necessary to exhale. In order to breathe out, they had to push up against the nail in their feet, and they could inhale as they sank back down. Once they had reached the limit of sheer exhaustion or blood ...more
Christian Ongtangco
One could easily die of asphixiation.
48%
Flag icon
“For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God” (1 Cor. 1:18 NIV).
48%
Flag icon
Jesus actually did die by crucifixion, and the disciples were preaching what they had to preach if they wanted to proclaim the truth.
49%
Flag icon
According to the historical record, the disciples preached Jesus as the Lord of life risen in glory, and that belief propelled them to spurn death to such a degree that they were more than willing to die.
Christian Ongtangco
The disciples were more than willing to die.
50%
Flag icon
what happened when the women went to the tomb on the third day. Mark’s gospel depicts a youth dressed in white, Matthew tells of an angel who rolled back the stone, Luke describes two men who appeared next to the women, and John says two angels were sitting where Jesus had been.
« Prev 1 3