I quickly opened the app, surprised to find that not only was Reed Darling now following me but he’d also tagged me in a picture. It was the one Paige had taken of the two of us at the dinner table. It was the perfect photo. We both looked so happy, and below the picture, Reed had shared a two-word caption: “My girl.” It made my heart leap into my throat, but it immediately plummeted right back down to earth. The caption wasn’t real.