Empire of AI: Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenAI

by Karen Hao

In a 2023 paper, Abeba Birhane and her coauthors would introduce the concept of “hate scaling laws” to critique the premise of training deep learning models on unfiltered data, or what they called “data-swamps.” They analyzed two publicly available image-and-text datasets used to train open-source image generators, LAION-400M and LAION-2B-en, both pulled from Common Crawl, with four hundred million and two billion images, respectively. They showed that the amount of hateful and abusive content scaled with the size of the dataset and exacerbated the discriminatory behaviors of the models trained on them. Models trained on the two billion images, for example, were five times more likely than models trained on the four hundred million images to label Black male faces as criminals. Later that year, a Stanford study analyzing LAION-5B, a dataset with five billion images used to train Stable Diffusion, would discover it contained thousands of images of verified and suspected child sexual abuse.