The Housewarming
Rate it:
Open Preview
Kindle Notes & Highlights
Read between July 13 - July 17, 2025
1%
Flag icon
Zoe Gilbert, a young local jeweler from the mainland, was missing after a weeklong vacation with friends. The details were scarce: She’d stayed behind after the rest of her group boarded the ferry to leave Block Island on Sunday morning, telling them she wanted one more day on the beach. She
ruthie
Hmmm whay gapoemed to her
2%
Flag icon
and because Zoe Gilbert’s four friends were in the group.
ruthie
SO sehwnts to gt the inssdie scoop and thats why se volunteered theesearch aso sehs a podcaster and prrbaaly attractuv to beinside the search for better resikt wnd more evidece
4%
Flag icon
“Serious enough.” He looked straight into the camera. “Zoe, baby, I miss you. Come home. At least call me if you see this. Let me know you’re okay.”
ruthie
Oh what aaswoon and smoldeding lokey feel like he did it
6%
Flag icon
mind. Her stomach swooped. It was done. An olive branch extended to the friends who hadn’t spoken to her in five years. All she could do now was hope they’d accept it.
ruthie
Was there bad bkood after zoes disappearajce
7%
Flag icon
wasn’t from a wealthy family and didn’t have an impressive job. He meditated every morning and rarely drank alcohol. He was practically an alien to her parents.
ruthie
Oppodites attract
8%
Flag icon
Zoe could always read the group like that. She had radar for incoming trouble and could head it off before it arrived better than the rest of them.
ruthie
Ajd ironicakkt she us the ine missijng
8%
Flag icon
“I just wanted to say you have some nerve showing your face here. It takes a lot of gall.”
ruthie
Whattt
10%
Flag icon
“Some people believe that in the video circulating of you and your friends, you were discussing a plan to hide evidence. Is that the case?” “No, of course not.” 27 “The internet is abuzz right now with discussions on Zoe’s case. What is it about you and your friends that people seem fascinated by?”
ruthie
Are thry brjng pinned fir zies disappearabce
10%
Flag icon
Obsessed with the idea of a crime that never happened instead of finding Zoe. We have to all do
ruthie
Media is twidtung the stiry ir barrAtuve
10%
Flag icon
Are you positive none of you were involved in Zoe Gilbert’s disappearance?”
11%
Flag icon
What was Callie planning this time?
12%
Flag icon
with Zoe, the strange way she’d been behaving all week, and the argument that ended the final night of their trip.
ruthie
Hmmmm sud zoe purposwly dusappwar ir was takrn
13%
Flag icon
They’d kept countless secrets for one another over the years, as friends do. They kept quiet about Callie’s binge drinking that first summer at camp. Lindsey’s abortion freshman year of college. Tess’s one-night fling with an ex when she had a long-term boyfriend. Meg’s ill-fated visit to see her estranged father at seventeen even though her mother forbade it. But Zoe, she never asked anyone to carry secrets for her.
ruthie
All of tgese girls are somewyat trauma bonded
15%
Flag icon
No. Patricia’s fixation was one of malice. Tess’s only crime was caring too
17%
Flag icon
the end of the day, it’s about meeting people. I’ve never liked the pressure of dating, but I’m always interested in connecting with people.”
ruthie
Sake
17%
Flag icon
“For eating dinner? And going on coffee dates? Most people go out for free.”
ruthie
Like ca sugar daddy
17%
Flag icon
“And what, exactly, is wrong with Taco Bell?”
ruthie
I agree
19%
Flag icon
“Does this count as a date?” she asked as they started walking down the street. “I’m taking up your time,” he said. Lindsey tried to calculate how long she might have before Patricia exploded her life again. How many times she’d be able to go out with Fred before everyone in her orbit turned on her again.
ruthie
I fee.as thiugh fred saught lindsey out to ge insude info for ptrici for her oidccsst or am ik jus oarnaoies
23%
Flag icon
The book that will falsely name me as someone who harmed Zoe.”
ruthie
Oooooh patrucia id expoliting her ahd tarnishing her baje
24%
Flag icon
“You thought I would want to help you? After what you did to us?”
33%
Flag icon
“I’ll be honest. As nice as you two seem, some of the neighbors think you living here means our street will become a hot spot for the true crime folks. That disappearance left a mark.”
ruthie
I understabd this concern
34%
Flag icon
Everything’s coming together nicely. Can’t wait to watch their faces when they see you.
ruthie
To whom
37%
Flag icon
Got fired thanks to Patricia. Hasn’t really sunk in yet. No idea what I’m going to do.
ruthie
Ooof
39%
Flag icon
Our minds are conditioned to seek answers.
ruthie
I akndsr if this is why people love watching true crime
40%
Flag icon
Was Zoe the victim of toxic friendship? Did one or even all four of her friends have a hand in her disappearance and then try to cover up the only piece of evidence? Or did something else happen on that August day? And if so . . . what?
ruthie
Dittooo
49%
Flag icon
“I told you I was going away. Just took the boat out here for a few days.”
ruthie
Fred is si sus ri mr
53%
Flag icon
“How is Patricia 154Adele the one who got me on-air for the interview? And why didn’t you ever mention that minor detail to me?”
54%
Flag icon
“I’m sure she thought once we turned on you, we’d run to her to give our own interviews. She probably expected one of us to fold.”
ruthie
Yeah wyat is patrucuas mo
55%
Flag icon
We’re part of this; we should be involved in the memorial. Right? Something is off.”
ruthie
Wgat us callies mo fir the oarty
56%
Flag icon
And worse, what reason would Lindsey have to keep the truth from the others? Meg went back to her inbox and saw she had another response waiting for her.
56%
Flag icon
But Cameron Oakes had some kind of tie to Zoe, and Meg didn’t know him. Her curiosity was piqued.
56%
Flag icon
“Up until the very end when she asked us to leave her behind.”
58%
Flag icon
“You told me to do this—or risk being implicated with one of them.”
60%
Flag icon
Lindsey swallowed; it was almost too much to think of someone caring enough to worry about her to this extent or being able to read her so clearly, without judgment.
ruthie
I gey it
66%
Flag icon
“And you know the truth about how that situation came
66%
Flag icon
finagled
67%
Flag icon
had never naturally developed one of her own. But to have Fred in common?
ruthie
Yesss i knew he was somehoe vonnrcted byt how
69%
Flag icon
I told Zoe I had feelings for her.” 204 Lindsey’s mouth fell open. “Wait. What? You and Zoe? You did? Were you two ever . . . ?”
ruthie
Wait hs sge gay
72%
Flag icon
Something was up with her and we ignored it.
ruthie
Survivirs guikt
73%
Flag icon
was no way to tell them what she’d done. Speaking to Patricia had been a mistake, and as soon as she got back home after the weekend, she would contact Patricia and tell her to delete the file
76%
Flag icon
This sent Lindsey in a new direction—outrage. How dare he? Standing there acting like this was all-new information. She slithered out of his arm and sifted through the photos on the table until she found hers. His.
ruthie
Darn rught
80%
Flag icon
Do you have a platform we can use to spread the word? Can you circulate this video and help Zoe’s case go viral for the right reasons? Do you have a tip that might assist detectives? Or can you generously donate money to the reward fund? Spend some time at Zoe’s table tonight. It’s
81%
Flag icon
“I just want to know why Lindsey and Callie lied about their whereabouts the day Zoe went missing,”
ruthie
Hmm