We Don't Talk About Carol
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between July 25 - July 27, 2025
3%
Flag icon
the reverberation of the sound through the speakers sending goosebumps down my arms. “I can push my meeting and fly back out there.” Something swelled inside
Charley
oh she's on the phone with him. very unclear!!
3%
Flag icon
I found the podcasts oddly satisfying, scratching a very specific itch by unraveling each mystery in forty-five minutes or less.
Charley
same! ❤️
4%
Flag icon
like a cataract-clouded eye.
Charley
oh that's good...
4%
Flag icon
like the parting of parched lips.
Charley
this toooo!
5%
Flag icon
had a bad falling out when the girl was around sixteen
5%
Flag icon
Carol wasn’t the only girl that went missing around that time.”
8%
Flag icon
relief.
11%
Flag icon
Snake Pit, that terrible swampy place over by Rochester Heights.
11%
Flag icon
wandering along the creek behind our house, looking for crayfish, until he winds up all the way out in the swamp.
16%
Flag icon
Walnut Creek was
18%
Flag icon
“Lightning” Larry Singleton, the L.A. Rams
18%
Flag icon
But I guess that’s what often happens in relationships; it’s the things that initially attract you to someone, the things that make them different from you, that eventually become the very things that repel you.
19%
Flag icon
Black people make up like fourteen percent of the population of this country, but around forty percent of America’s missing kids are Black.
Charley
that is A TERRIBLE statistic 😢😢😢
20%
Flag icon
My sister Geri—Geraldine—disappeared a year before Carol.
20%
Flag icon
but Larry marched over and grabbed me by the arm, hard, and pulled me into an empty classroom.”
20%
Flag icon
“She was at Shaw? But she was only in high school when she disappeared.”
20%
Flag icon
I found out they were friends.”
21%
Flag icon
“Does the name Michael Hall mean anything to you?”
21%
Flag icon
Eloise Hall? And
Charley
so Michael is Eloise's son but she didn't mention him!!?
21%
Flag icon
Yvonne fought with Carol
21%
Flag icon
dated. I mean, it’s just such a common name, she’d said dismissively. No one in particular comes to mind.
Charley
yah that's a huge and obvious thing to lie about
22%
Flag icon
bring a friend along, so of course I brought Sally. She
24%
Flag icon
we don’t even know who Dad’s father was.
25%
Flag icon
my father’s blood alcohol level was five times the legal limit when his Corvette smashed into the jacaranda his supper clubs were named for; he
25%
Flag icon
his rage was a vicious animal in a subpar cage.
Charley
maybe he killed his own sister?!
33%
Flag icon
Geraldine and Sally enter a dark, early 1950s sedan on the days of their disappearances. One person speculated that the car was a Chevy 210—one
34%
Flag icon
“She told me Mary grew up not knowing her daddy, too,” he added.
Charley
there's something about this mysterious missing dad....
35%
Flag icon
surely you found mine?”
35%
Flag icon
Carol. I even still have her old trunk of things she kept at my apartment at Shaw.
36%
Flag icon
‘Y. Hall cancels report on C.S., citing conversation on 5/25/65.’
Charley
Yvonne, Michaels sister!
36%
Flag icon
Michael’s sister retracted Carol’s missing person report but never told Michael about it.”
Charley
so messed up!!
38%
Flag icon
The city seemed lively and energetic, bustling with a pride and sense of possibility that those TV stories seemed to have overlooked.
Charley
yes!!! I love Detroit!!!
39%
Flag icon
an old dad.”
Charley
so he was like 50 years old when Maya was born!!? dang....
39%
Flag icon
It was the unabashed giggle of a young girl, though she looked to be somewhere in her fifties, at least twenty years younger than her husband.
39%
Flag icon
This was the kind of warmth a child was meant to grow up in.
Charley
This is so sweet ❤️
39%
Flag icon
I didn’t expect him to have such negative feelings about his upbringing.
40%
Flag icon
‘When you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras.’
Charley
occams razor...
41%
Flag icon
“My sister was hardly the only ‘Y. Hall’ in Raleigh at the time.
41%
Flag icon
horses, not zebras—but
41%
Flag icon
leaning against the hood of a car. A dark sedan. A Chevy; its front reminded me of a catfish, its headlights like a pair of wide-set eyes, its grille a silver-toothed grimace.
Charley
Geraldine and Sally were seen getting into a car like this one
41%
Flag icon
Raymond Green.
42%
Flag icon
When he stopped hanging around, I figured he finally made good on his promise and headed north.”
42%
Flag icon
But I pointed out that four girls my age have gone missing from our neighborhood in the past year, three of which before graduating from Ligon. If the rumors are true, if there is a “Creek Killer” stalking girls in Raleigh, isn’t that more reason for me to leave? Isn’t that more reason not to delay my dreams?
Charley
touche
42%
Flag icon
He threw the plate across the room and slammed the door behind him.
Charley
he is so messy
44%
Flag icon
If you just got a real job and got out of that house, you could actually live your life and stop using Mom’s decisions as your excuses.”
Charley
she's a fucking nag if I'm being honest. that's not her place or her business suite frankly
45%
Flag icon
The restaurant disappeared from view as I plunged into blackness.
45%
Flag icon
Maybe this was the real reason I sometimes lost myself in investigating the mysteries of other people’s lives; because it dulled the pain of knowing I’d never have real answers for my own.
Charley
Yes!!!
47%
Flag icon
“Isn’t it possible both things might be true?”
Charley
❤️ and that's the tough part about life ...
47%
Flag icon
likely to protect her pastor father. I wondered what about his reputation needed protecting.
Charley
if he is a pastor, there is literally no telling the things he'd have needed kept quiet 🙄
48%
Flag icon
oval-shaped locket with the letters “SD”
« Prev 1