If You Tell a Lie
Rate it:
Open Preview
Read between March 4 - March 24, 2025
16%
Flag icon
I was always watching them. Studying. Observing. Taking notes. They didn’t know I was always watching. It’s because rich kids are just like their rich parents.
16%
Flag icon
And it was time they found out. And not just who I was. They needed to learn about life. Real life. The one the rest of us lived.
17%
Flag icon
I was shocked to find out Thera was a practicing psychic and spiritual counselor, though. It was so out of the realm of science for her, and Thera was definitely a scientist.
17%
Flag icon
Grace was a supermodel now. She was internet famous.
17%
Flag icon
it was her OnlyFans account that was the most impressive. She was Bahd Barbie, and she’d made over $2 million last year.
17%
Flag icon
My wife, Claire,
18%
Flag icon
I’d skimmed those articles, too, and they practically made it sound like an arranged marriage.
20%
Flag icon
someone could come at any second, and I wasn’t getting caught. It left the ritual feeling a bit incomplete. Almost like I’d wasted it.
21%
Flag icon
Guys were throwing themselves at her this summer. There was something about her energy lately that pulled you to her, too, that had never been there before. And she wasn’t bothered by any of the attention, which only made them want her more.
21%
Flag icon
But still. He was supposed to want me. Not Meg. She was starting to get on my nerves. And when people got on my nerves, I wanted to eat. That’s what I did. Feelings always made me hungry. Ravenous.
22%
Flag icon
No more. Never again. That was four years ago, and I hadn’t stopped. It was my dirty little secret.
23%
Flag icon
But then I learned I wasn’t the only one living with a demon, and somehow that made it okay to have mine.
24%
Flag icon
What’s that they say in Stand by Me? There’s nothing like the friends you have when you’re twelve? Or something like that. They found a dead body lying next to the railroad tracks, and we found one at camp.
24%
Flag icon
How could we have known what Regina was going through? She and Mr. Crosby had seemed so happy. They looked like the perfect couple.
24%
Flag icon
We all picked our sides, and I fell on the side of wearing her shoes. I knew trauma could break you. Dismantle your insides. Pull your sense of reality right out from underneath you. Twist you and push you into doing things you never thought you were capable of doing.
24%
Flag icon
stabbed her husband 117 times.
24%
Flag icon
we were good kids and good kids weren’t supposed to get into trouble. They didn’t do bad things. But we did. We did a terrible thing and eventually you have to pay for something like that. You just couldn’t get away with it. It was too big. Things that bad didn’t go unpunished.
25%
Flag icon
Because the truth? If a group of teenage girls had done what we did? I might’ve wanted to hurt us too.
26%
Flag icon
He was the kind of prince you dreamed of when you were a little girl. If you were into that kind of thing. Which I was.
26%
Flag icon
See, the biggest problem with those girls wasn’t that they were every kind of privileged and white, even though they were. It was that they were so damn smart.
27%
Flag icon
All I had to do was call my daddy and let him know they’d split up me and my friends into different teams, throw in a few cries for good measure, and he’d be on the phone with the director as soon as we hung up.
28%
Flag icon
It was such a tragic story, but for some reason, I liked telling it.
28%
Flag icon
that one hit everyone differently. It hurt them, and part of me liked making them feel bad,
29%
Flag icon
It was the best story and even better because it was true. Mostly, anyway.
29%
Flag icon
It’s not like Blakely actually physically killed Jared. Was the one to hold the knife in her hand and stab him 117 times. That kind of annihilation was all about rage.
29%
Flag icon
It was like nothing I’d ever heard before, so I couldn’t identify it other than to say it sounded more animal than human.
29%
Flag icon
Because that summer was also the summer I figured out I was gay, and I would’ve done anything to keep people from finding out. Absolutely anything. It was pure survival.
32%
Flag icon
Do you know how freeing it was to live in a world where you didn’t give a fuck what people thought about you? Especially as a woman? There’s no better feeling on the planet. At least I haven’t found one yet.
33%
Flag icon
Truthfully, he seemed kind of annoyed with Blakely. That was the one thing I noticed when they were together. She was so obvious about trying to get his attention.
34%
Flag icon
He was stunningly gorgeous. So was his wife. The one person Blakely kept forgetting about.
34%
Flag icon
I hadn’t noticed the way he was with Blakely, but I’d noticed the way he was with Meg. Everyone had. If there was anyone he liked, it was her.
35%
Flag icon
We both have holes in our hearts now, but hers is bigger. Much bigger. And, I don’t know, there’s just something different about her. She was missing something else,
36%
Flag icon
I smiled and nodded at her, just like I’d been doing for weeks.
41%
Flag icon
There was one other thing I knew about housewives—and
41%
Flag icon
mortgage—and that was that they got bored. With all that time on their hands, they needed to find something to keep them busy. And Lord knows, Blakely needed constant stimulation and attention.
43%
Flag icon
This was supposed to be about the notes. Not her. Or had it always been about her? Had she set this whole thing up?
43%
Flag icon
Thera was upset. She was terrible at hiding her emotions. I felt bad. I needed to do a better job including her, but Meg just had such a better in with Jared.
50%
Flag icon
“Blakely wanted Mr. Crosby, and he rejected her. That’s how this whole thing started. You know that as well as I do. But somehow, it’s gotten all twisted up, and now the police are involved. Someone has to set them straight, and there’s nobody better to do that than you.”
50%
Flag icon
This time I was the one to shake my head at her. “No, I won’t, because I know the difference between reality and fantasy.”
51%
Flag icon
Believe me: no one wanted an explanation for the things I’d done more than me.
52%
Flag icon
Some days I agreed with them. Maybe that’s what happened when evil men squirted themselves inside you. They ruined you forever.
53%
Flag icon
Maybe after Mr. Crosby was officially gone, this would all blow over. There was still two weeks left of camp. We could salvage this. We had to salvage this somehow.
54%
Flag icon
“I’m the one who sent the letters. It wasn’t Regina. It was me.”
56%
Flag icon
“You’re in an awful situation. I understand just fine, but I don’t like being lied to. I definitely don’t like being played.”
58%
Flag icon
Blakely had just given us another secret to eat. But guess what? I was full.
61%
Flag icon
Blood tasted just like it smelled, but it wasn’t that bad. I kind of liked it.
62%
Flag icon
We always said camp let us be our truest self. The one place where we could let our guards down and just be ourselves. But you know what? Camp might’ve been the fakest we ever were.”
63%
Flag icon
But I’d seen it with my own eyes. I’d watched Regina mutilate him. But could Blakely have started it? Did it really matter if she had? My memory was so fuzzy. All the corners frayed.
65%
Flag icon
That was the only way, and I wasn’t sorry. Up until the point I started suspecting he might not have done it. Then, everything shifted.
65%
Flag icon
She flicked on the light when we got to the bottom of the stairs, and that’s when I saw them. Her dolls.