Pauly was the first one to arrive after me. When he walked in the door, I was like, Aight, we cool. This is gonna be good. He and I immediately clicked. I mean, his name is Paul Michael; mine is Michael Paul. My birthday is July 4; his is July 5. He’s a good-looking guy; I’m a good-looking guy. We both dressed great and were the same height. Both tan. Both jacked. He had a natural swag I recognized in myself. I knew that with us together, it was going to be an epic summer.

