The Worst Kept Secret (Secrets, #2)

by Q.B. Tyler

For all of you that love a hot dad (And more specifically a Q.B. daddy)

I shiver thinking about that night when Theo had lifted me in the air and pressed me against the wall like I was nothing.

My eyes typically dance between brown and hazel most of the time, but there are moments when the sun hits them just right when you can see flecks of green.

Bitch!! Mine too!! Twins :P

A fact that Theo had brought up on more than one occasion.

I catch his eyes again and he’s closer than he was before, like he’s making his way through the crowd to get to me.

I haven’t seen Theo in almost six months. Six months ago, when we’d made out in his car and I’d sat in his lap and fucked myself with my fingers until I came with the promise of more. It wasn’t the first time we’d hooked up, having done so once the previous summer, but it was the furthest we’d ever gone. We hadn’t spoken about it after, almost as if we were both pretending it hadn’t happened. Me out of humiliation and hurt and him to keep it hidden from the one person he was sure it would hurt the most. Lucas Graham. My best friend. His son.

“Oh? Here I thought you liked indulging in things you might be a little old for?” I

“You’re playing with fire, Avery.”

“Please. I speak fluent fuckboy.”

“That’s all you would’ve done?” I lean across the truck. “You wouldn’t have tried to discipline me yourself? Maybe take me over your knee and spank me?”

He turns his head toward me, giving me a look that tells me he’s not amused. “I know what you’re doing.”

“That you’re too gorgeous for your own good and one afternoon after I’d had a few drinks, I stupidly allowed myself to think that you were an option for me.”

“You were just so sad, and I remember thinking the reason he was so angry was because he had feelings for you, and then…fuck. I don’t know, somehow, you were in my lap. I don’t even know how it happened.”

I remember. I was wearing a tiny tank top and he couldn’t keep his eyes off my tits so I boldly climbed into his lap to give him a better look.

“Are you close?” He asks and I nod. He pushes my hair away from my face. “I know you are. Come on, beautiful, let me see you.”

“But it doesn’t mean I’ve stopped thinking about what your dick would feel like in my mouth.”

“And maybe once you let me inside of you, I’m going to lose my fucking mind and want it again. Maybe you only want it once, but…I don’t work that way.”

“Let me in. Let me in your pretty cunt, right now.” I pull him closer and he slides in easily because of how wet I am, even with his size. “Fuuuuuuck you’re tight.”

His lips find mine as he grabs my hands and slowly brings them over my head, lacing them as he continues to fuck me and it’s even better than I imagined this would be.

“I should put you over my knee for having a body that looks and feels that good.” He pauses. “Don’t fuck anyone else, Avery,” he says through gritted teeth.

“I won’t.” I cry. “I won’t. I don’t want to!”

“Good.” He grunts. “This pussy is fuck...

He slaps it again and I can feel the orgasm starting t...

“Fuck, it’s too much, Theo.”

I’m going to hell. I’m so going to fucking hell

“You can take it, baby. Take me. You’re doing so well.”

Yes, papí. My fate in hell has already been sealed anyways💅🏼

“There will be plenty of times for you to suck me off, but let me recover from that.”

My eyes immediately meet his. “Plenty of times?”

He’s still on his back as he sighs. “I already kn...

TG: Alright. Looking forward to being alone with you. I don’t even mean just for sex. I just feel like I breathe easier around you.

I don’t reply right away because I don’t know what to say, and before I know it, minutes have gone by and I haven’t said anything. I’m trying to calm the rapid beat of my heart over his words.

TG: Shit. That was way too much. Ignore me. Probably shouldn’t have h...

Me: No! No. Sorry, I was trying to figure out what to say that wasn’t a tho...

TG: I’ll take your he...

I close the door behind me, and the skittering of my pulse at the thought of seeing her tomorrow sends up about a hundred red flags. I feel the exact moment my mind starts to shift and I realize that this is definitely not just a fling and I am in a whole lot of fucking trouble.

I make my way out of the bathroom, not looking where I’m going, and walk right into a wall of very hard unfamiliar muscle. His hands find my forearms and I look up to see a guy that’s probably in his mid-thirties.

“Oh, I’m sorry.” He’s attractive objectively and if I wasn’t so obsessed with my best friend’s dad, I may be able to appreciate it more. His brown eyes are warm and a smile finds his face.

“No need for apologies. A woman as gorgeous as you bumping into a guy—well, I should be thanking you.” He lets me ...

“Thank you.” I go to move down the hallway when ...

“The guy you’re with…” he starts and when I turn around his eyes drop to my hand, “I don’t see a ring on your finger, s...

“Not yet.” I hear Theo’s voice from behind me and then his hand snakes around my waist, pulling me closer to him. Theo moves to stand next to me and rubs my waist, holding ...

“You ready to go?” He looks at me before his eyes turn to the guy, looking him up and down once. The guy clears his throat and moves around us leaving us alone in the hallway outside of the bathroom. Theo narrows his eyes, following after him. “I told you everyone was looking at you,” he says before he turns his gaze back to mine.

“Not yet?” I blurt out, not giving a shit about who’s looking at me.

His lips find my neck as he whispers in my ear. “I was making a point.” Goosebumps instantl...

“Whic...

“That you’re spok...

“A...

He narrows his eyes with a look of confusion and maybe also a little irri...

“Spoken...

“We’ve been over this. Yes. You’re fucking mine, Avery, ju...

“But no one knows that.” I bl...