The Worst Kept Secret (Secrets, #2)

by Q.B. Tyler

There’s a spike in my heart rate the second Theo Graham enters the room.

Despite my instincts telling me not to react, I can’t help it; my eyes are inexplicably drawn to Theo whenever we share a room.

I shiver thinking about that night when Theo had lifted me in the air and pressed me against the wall like I was nothing.

I haven’t seen Theo in almost six months. Six months ago, when we’d made out in his car and I’d sat in his lap and fucked myself with my fingers until I came with the promise of more. It wasn’t the first time we’d hooked up, having done so once the previous summer, but it was the furthest we’d ever gone. We hadn’t spoken about it after, almost as if we were both pretending it hadn’t happened. Me out of humiliation and hurt and him to keep it hidden from the one person he was sure it would hurt the most. Lucas Graham. My best friend. His son.

I’d made out with my best friend’s dad. And I wanted more.

“Oh? Here I thought you liked indulging in things you might be a little old for?”

“That you’re too gorgeous for your own good and one afternoon after I’d had a few drinks, I stupidly allowed myself to think that you were an option for me.”

“But it doesn’t mean I’ve stopped thinking about what your dick would feel like in my mouth.”

“And maybe once you let me inside of you, I’m going to lose my fucking mind and want it again. Maybe you only want it once, but…I don’t work that way.”

I was trying to be a good man, but I’m not a saint.

Her eyes drop to my dick instantly which is standing straight up with a pearl of precum pooling at the tip. She licks her lips and the rest of my resolve fucking snaps.

I see the moment he decides to say fuck it because he’s on the bed and on top of me in a fucking instant.

He kisses the way I do, like I want to be fucking consumed by the other person. I want to crawl inside Theo Graham’s skin and live there.

“Yes, whatever you want!” I agree, knowing that I’ll do anything he says in this moment to keep his hands on me.

“Good girl,” he says and goosebumps erupt on my flesh.

“Oh my Godddddd.” I moan as his tongue swirls around my clit before he begins to take long slow strokes up and down my cunt.

The sounds that his mouth and my pussy are making are obscene and make me even wetter.

“Thank fuck,” he says just before he suctions his lips around my clit and I fucking lose it.

“Let me in. Let me in your pretty cunt, right now.” I pull him closer and he slides in easily because of how wet I am, even with his size. “Fuuuuuuck you’re tight.”

“I should put you over my knee for having a body that looks and feels that good.” He pauses. “Don’t fuck anyone else, Avery,” he says through gritted teeth. “I won’t.” I cry. “I won’t. I don’t want to!” “Good.” He grunts. “This pussy is fucking mine now.”

“Fuck, it’s too much, Theo.” “You can take it, baby. Take me. You’re doing so well.”

“You’re so beautiful. I don’t know when you became this woman I can’t stop looking at but God damn, Avery.”

Avery appears with two bottles of water in one hand and her phone in the other and my eyes go to her stomach on instinct and I have to fight the intrusive thoughts of her round with my child. Fuck.

“Okay, Daddy,” I sass and I wonder how he’ll take the nickname.

“Fuck,” I hear him whisper into the phone. “Avery, you’re going to fucking pay for that.”

“Prom...

“Talk soon.” He grunts into the phone. ...

Me: No! No. Sorry, I was trying to figure out what to say that wasn’t a thousand heart eye emojis.

TG: I’ll take your heart eyes.

I feel the exact moment my mind starts to shift and I realize that this is definitely not just a fling and I am in a whole lot of fucking trouble.

I continue fucking her through my frustration over letting things go too far with Avery and now I’m addicted to her and I have no intentions of giving her up.

“In another life, it would be so easy.” “In another life, I probably don’t live right next door, so maybe we would never cross paths,” she teases. “I’d find you in every lifetime.”

“Don’t deny me what’s mine, Theo Graham.” I smirk and he shakes his head.

I smile at my phone, wishing that I could find her and kiss her smart-ass mouth.